View Full Version : If XXXX goes down we're doomed!

09-06-2005, 09:32 AM
Who is it? Really?

Poll Forthcoming

09-06-2005, 09:36 AM
This is going to be a landslide vote.

Could anyone have seen what Trent Green was going to mean to this team in July 2001?

Rain Man
09-06-2005, 09:36 AM
It'll be interesting to see if this poll remains unanimous, or if some people will make an incorrect choice.

09-06-2005, 09:36 AM
Definitely Green. After that, I'd say Surtain and then Roaf/Shields

09-06-2005, 09:37 AM
If XXXX goes down we're doomed! (http://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?p=2670766#post2670766)

Who is it? Really?

Poll Forthcoming

Ohhh tempting Karma and the Football Gods I see. :Poke:

09-06-2005, 09:37 AM
Easy. Green.

Awhile ago, some people would have probably done a 50/50 split with Green and Holmes. But now that the emergence of Larry Johnson, I would tend to believe that it'll shift more into Green's favor now, especially that the majority of us are not confident on our back-ups.

09-06-2005, 09:39 AM
I figured I'd post this after I saw an article posted on the donx board from the SF Chronicle. I think Ira Miller needs a head check.


SoCals link: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/artic...feed=rss.sports

NFL 2005
Potential is there for a wild West
Offenses look like they are power-packed
Ira Miller, Chronicle Staff Writer

Tuesday, September 6, 2005

If the Raiders have their way this season, the AFC could bring back memories of the old American Football League in the '60s, when it was known for its high-scoring shootout games.

With an offense fortified by the addition of Randy Moss, the Raiders look to be in position to score a lot of points. But they also appear to have a defense capable of giving up a lot of points again, and the big question is how many of those 42-35 games they can win.

The Raiders' division, the AFC West, always has been one of the most intriguing in the league because the four teams have been rivals since 1960 and also because these rivalries are among the most heated in the league.

And, as usual, the division begins the year with more questions than answers. Here are the key questions facing each team, and a rating of the teams in various categories:

Raiders: Will their offense be as good as they expect it to be, and will the defense be any good at all?

Chargers: With all the starters back from last year's surprise team, can San Diego improve even more -- or will the Chargers regress?

Broncos: Can Mike Shanahan's coaching overcome some of his audacious personnel moves, like wasting a third-round pick on Maurice Clarett?

Chiefs: Is the defense, which has been significantly retooled, going to be good enough to win before the offense begins to deteriorate?


1. Shanahan, Broncos. There is no indication Shanahan is under any pressure from owner Pat Bowlen, but the fact is, he hasn't won a playoff game since John Elway retired.

2. Dick Vermeil, Chiefs. This could be his last year, and he hasn't had the impact with the Chiefs yet that they thought he would.

3. Marty Schottenheimer, Chargers. Showed he still had it last year but reverted to form with conservatism in the playoffs that led to an early exit.

4. Norv Turner, Raiders. This is a big year for Turner; the Raiders made some offseason splashes that he needs to turn into in-season victories.

1. Drew Brees, Chargers. There is still plenty of skepticism about Brees, whose first two seasons as a starter were pretty ordinary, but who last year had a Pro Bowl season and a 27-7 TD-interception ratio. If he can do it again, he'll make himself a lot of money, and Philip Rivers will be available in trade.

2. Trent Green, Chiefs. He has been a model of consistency the last three years, with passer ratings of 92.6, 92.6 and 95.2.

3. Jake Plummer, Broncos. Under Shanahan, Plummer has had the two best years of his career back-to-back. But he still throws too many interceptions.

4. Kerry Collins, Raiders. He's one of the best long-ball throwers in the league, but two numbers sum up his career -- 153 touchdown passes, 154 interceptions.

1. LaDainian Tomlinson, Chargers. He's the best running back in the league. His average season for a four-year career: 1,475 yards rushing, 505 yards receiving, 15 touchdowns.

2. LaMont Jordan, Raiders. After four years as Curtis Martin's backup, Jordan moves into a starring role in Oakland. By all accounts, he's ready for it, and the attention defenses must pay to Moss will ease his path.

3. Priest Holmes, Chiefs. Holmes is not a big guy, he has had some injury problems and he'll be 32 years old in October. All those factors would seem to mitigate his success, but he has beaten the odds before.

4. Mike Anderson, Broncos. Anderson ran for 1,487 yards as a rookie in 2000 and just 1,321 in four years since then, and he's coming off an injury. But Denver almost always has a 1,000-yard runner, and there is plenty of depth behind him on the roster, too.

1. Moss, Raiders. Say what you want about his off-field behavior and his history of not playing hard all the time, he's still one of the game's best weapons (and, word is, a much better teammate than that jerk in Philadelphia).

2. Tony Gonzalez, Chiefs. Yeah, he's a tight end. But he's also Kansas City's go-to guy, more reliable than wideout Eddie Kennison, and he has averaged more than 12 yards a catch for five straight seasons.

3. Antonio Gates, Chargers. Another tight end. He emerged last year as a terrific red-zone threat, and should be that again. And now that Keenan McCardell has had a training camp with the team, expect him to be a bigger part of the offense, too.

4. Rod Smith, Broncos. At age 34 a year ago, he added a new job as punt returner. Still going strong.

1. Broncos. There's depth up front and good experience. Denver actually had the No. 4 defense in the NFL last year but the points-against looked worse because of Plummer's 20 interceptions.

2. Chargers. San Diego's 3-4 gives it a bit of an edge because there still are so few teams playing it, which makes it difficult for opponents to prepare. Two first-round draft picks will help the Chargers, too.

3. Raiders. They'll be improved, and this year, they're playing a defense which better suits their players. A key is whether Warren Sapp has a year left, and he looked in camp like he might.

4. Chiefs. They'll be better because of the players they signed. But how much better?

Raiders: LB Kirk Morrison is working into the nickel defense and the coaches like what they have seen of him.

Chargers: LB Shawne Merriman is missing time due to hamstring and knee injuries, but look out when he gets healthy; he's a playmaker.

Broncos: CB Darrent Williams, a second-round pick, appears to have won the job as the team's primary punt and kickoff returner.

Chiefs: LB Derrick Johnson. He gives Kansas City the kind of play on the edge that its defense has not had since Derrick Thomas' tragic death.

Raiders: Jordan. Turner has directed successful offenses without stud quarterbacks or receivers, but not without a top running back.

Chargers: Tomlinson. You can't easily replace the league's best running back.

Broncos: Plummer. He has been making steady progress under Shanahan, and the backups behind him are not good enough.

Chiefs: Gonzalez. Maybe Larry Johnson can fill in for Holmes, but there's no one remotely close to being able to take over for Gonzalez.


Peyton Manning

Colts, QB

He'd have another big year even if the Colts did not have such a weak schedule.

Top rookie

Ronnie Brown

Dolphins, RB

Without a competent quarterback, the Dolphins will try to stay in games by leaning on their first-round pick.

Coach of the year

Marvin Lewis


It has been a long playoff drought for the Bengals.

Division winners

Denver, New England, Cincinnati, Indianapolis

Wild cards

N.Y. Jets, Oakland


Indianapolis over N.Y. Jets

Best veteran acquisition

Corey Simon

Colts, DT

Simon, a former Pro Bowler, gives the Colts a stud run-stopper on the inside to go with their quick pass rushers on the outside.




Take a look at how the Bengals played down the stretch last year.

Tough times ahead

Bill Cowher


His job's not in jeopardy, but Steelers won't approach 15-1 again.

Biggest bust

Kansas City

The Chiefs' defense is going to be better. Unfortunately, their offense will be worse.

09-06-2005, 09:44 AM
Green: without a doubt

Rain Man
09-06-2005, 09:50 AM
Can someone post a link of the article describing how Lamont Jordan was bitten by a radioactive spider and gained super powers? I must've missed it.

09-06-2005, 09:51 AM
Green, for the simple fact that if he goes down we'd be better off putting in Gary Coleman than Huard or Collins.

09-06-2005, 09:51 AM
No brainer here - Trent Green.

A lot of people, if lost, would hurt. But if Green goes down, we are done.

09-06-2005, 09:52 AM

Area 51
09-06-2005, 09:52 AM
This thread is irrelavent as we are going to lose none of the players listed.

Dr. Johnny Fever
09-06-2005, 09:53 AM
easy... Khari Long.

09-06-2005, 09:54 AM
I'm not sure what an Ira Miller is, but it sure doesn't know much about football.

09-06-2005, 09:54 AM
This thread is irrelavent as we are going to lose none of the players listed.

You're correct. Roaf and Shields are too big to lose and Green and Surtain are pretty well known.

09-06-2005, 09:55 AM
Right now Green or Surtain.

With Collins hurt we're as thin at QB as we are at CB...

09-06-2005, 09:58 AM
Green. Hands down.

Probably Surtain as a distant second.

I'd list Waters as a critical player too. The left side of our line is such a strength to our running game. We'd miss him hugely.

Anyway, here's to a healthy year :toast:

09-06-2005, 09:59 AM
So the general concensus is that Tony G is not the most irreplaceable player we have?

That's what I thought. :D

09-06-2005, 10:11 AM
How could we not vote for Green after seeing our QB's in preseason games ? :shake:

Rain Man
09-06-2005, 10:12 AM
Everyone certainly respects Tony, and he's certainly irreplaceable, but our depth at TE is better than our depth at QB, and QB plays a bit more critical role in the offense.

Archie F. Swin
09-06-2005, 10:42 AM
my vote goes to Laura Bush

Garcia Bronco
09-06-2005, 10:58 AM
Anyone on your offensive line...

Rain Man
09-06-2005, 11:17 AM
Anyone on your offensive line...

Who would you say is Denver's most vital player, garcia? I know that the backup QB situation there is rather controversial, but I'd also say that Trevor Pryce would be pretty vital to youse guys.