PDA

View Full Version : PLANET'S OFFICIAL "AMERICAN IDOL" GAME


Frankie
04-04-2006, 06:30 PM
Taylor Hicks = 9
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/taylor.jpg

Chris Daughtry = 8
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/chris.jpg

Mandisa = 7
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/Mandisa.jpg

Paris Bennett = 6
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/Paris.jpg

Kellie Pickler = 5
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/kellie.jpg

Bucky Covington = 4
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/bucky.jpg

Katharine McPhee = 3
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/katharine.jpg

Elliott Yamin = 2
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/elliott.jpg

Ace Young = 1
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/ace.jpg

Rules of the game:

Above is an example of my ranking of the remaining 9 Idol contestants. Please list your order of preference (NOT YOUR PREDICTION) as to who you would like to see as the American Idol. Assign the value of 9 to your top choice and values of 8 through 1 to others (in descending order. 1 goes to your lowest chouce). Those are the points you will add to your total every week that particular contestant survives. All point will be tallied continously. The winner(s) will get some sort of reward. Help me out with ideas here. Right now, I'm thinking some formula that rewards all players in reps with respect of their finish. We will hammer that out later. Above is my own order of choices with values assigned.

Keep in mind:

A- Be fair and honest.
B- Go with your preference and NOT PREDICTION.
C- Only entries BEFORE this Wednesday night's elimination show will be considered.
D- If there are not enough hits by tomorrow night I may restart this after tomorrow night's show with top value of 8.

Katipan
04-04-2006, 06:34 PM
Preference!


Katherine
Chris
Paris
Ace
Bucky
Kelly
Mandisa
Elliot
Taylor

EDIT: I really have no desire to make listing an order of favorites more complicated by adding numbers to a sequential list. :P The one at the top rocks. The one at the bottom sucks ass.

Tribal Warfare
04-04-2006, 06:35 PM
Hicks- 9

Daughtry -8.5



Yamin- Voice is a 9 but stage presence is a 5

so he's a 7

McPhee- 7
Mandisa- 7

Pickler a 3
Bucky-2

Ace- 0.5-1

Frankie
04-04-2006, 06:38 PM
Preference!


Katherine
Chris
Paris
Ace
Bucky
Kelly
Mandisa
Elliot
Taylor

So:

Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=7
Ace=6
Bucky=5
Kelly=4
Mandisa=3
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

?

Frankie
04-04-2006, 06:40 PM
Hicks- 9

Daughtry -8.5



Yamin- Voice is a 9 but stage presence is a 5

so he's a 7

McPhee- 7
Mandisa- 7

Pickler a 3
Bucky-2

Ace- 0.5-1
Resubmit please. You have to break ties in your list. It was very difficult for me too. Especially with my top three.

Cochise
04-04-2006, 06:40 PM
:thailor:

DomerNKC
04-04-2006, 06:42 PM
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
4. Mandisa
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky
my preferences. even though vote for the worst.com might screw it all up. lol

Frankie
04-04-2006, 06:50 PM
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
4. Mandisa
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky
my preferences. even though vote for the worst.com might screw it all up. lol

That's the way to do it. Thanks Domer. The rest of you, do like Domer.

I'll be gone the rest of tonite. I'll check for your entries in the A.M.

Thig Lyfe
04-04-2006, 06:56 PM
9. Mandisa
8. Taylor
7. Paris
6. McPhee
5. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
2. Ace
1. Bucky

Tribal Warfare
04-04-2006, 06:58 PM
Taylor - 9 Daughtry- 8.5 McPhee -8 Yamin- 7.8 Mandisa-7.5 Paris- 7 Pickler-3 Bucky-2 Ace- 0.5-1

KCFalcon59
04-04-2006, 07:02 PM
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=7
Taylor=6
Paris=5
*************
These are worthless

Kelly=4
Elliot=3
Ace=2
Bucky=1

Frankie
04-05-2006, 08:21 AM
up

jspchief
04-05-2006, 09:08 AM
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 5
Bucky 4
Paris 3
Mandisa 2
Ace 1

Blackened
04-05-2006, 09:54 AM
I don't know anything about American Idol, but I do know that Katharine is HOT!

Duck Dog
04-05-2006, 09:56 AM
I hope those of you playing along are girls.

Jilly
04-05-2006, 09:58 AM
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
6. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky

can I we vote on how cute they are too???? You know, because it all comes down for me to if they are hot or not!

Frankie
04-05-2006, 12:26 PM
9. Taylor
can I we vote on how cute they are too???? You know, because it all comes down for me to if they are hot or not!
That would be another thread. Thanks for posting here though.

DeepSouth
04-05-2006, 01:02 PM
Kelly Pickler = 9
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 4
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

Reaper16
04-05-2006, 01:05 PM
Paris = 9 (Because I don't want Chris or Taylor to be sucked into shitty pop music contracts. They will be signed, both of them, immediately after they're booted off.)
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 4
Kelly = 3
Ace = 2
Bucky = 1

ChiefsCountry
04-05-2006, 01:08 PM
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 4
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

luv
04-05-2006, 01:13 PM
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
6. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky

can I we vote on how cute they are too???? You know, because it all comes down for me to if they are hot or not!
Going off looks, I would place Ace as number one. :drool:
I think Bucky would look better with short hair.

Unfortunately, I haven't seen a single show this season, so I can't rank them by voice or performance. :(

siberian khatru
04-05-2006, 01:24 PM
9. Daughtry
8. McPhee
7. Mandisa
6. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
3. Kellie
2. Bucky
1. Ace

Frankie
04-05-2006, 03:00 PM
Wow. It looks like this game is a go. Remember, the cut off time to submit your list is right at the begining of tonight's (Wed.) elimination show.

DeepSouth
04-05-2006, 03:05 PM
Wow. It looks like this game is a go. Remember, the cut off time to submit your list is right at the begining of tonight's (Wed.) elimination show.
If ChiefsPlanet has any ability to judge talent, it looks like Ace or Bucky are history.

listopencil
04-05-2006, 04:54 PM
I vote for Bucky/Ace to go.

Frankie
04-05-2006, 08:42 PM
Well Mandisa is out. :( Technically the most complete voice in the group. It took country music to eliminate her.

I'm gonna start adding up your scores now but don't expect me to finish and post them tonight. I have a life, you know. ;)

Logical
04-05-2006, 09:07 PM
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 4
Ace Young = 3
Kellie Pickler = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

Logical
04-05-2006, 09:11 PM
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
6. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky

can I we vote on how cute they are too???? You know, because it all comes down for me to if they are hot or not!Pickler and Ace go at the bottom if you use that criteria, then Mandissa to finish the bottom 3 of cuteness.

Frankie
04-05-2006, 09:33 PM
Well here's your score so this week: (Your bet for Mandisa has been changed to 0)

Frankie: (38)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 6
Kellie Pickler = 5
Bucky Covington = 4
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 1

Katipan: (42)
Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=7
Ace=6
Bucky=5
Kelly=4
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

Tribal Warfare: (40) (Rounded based on order)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 8
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-4
Pickler-3
Bucky-2
Ace-1

DomerNKC: (41)
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky

ArrowheadWolf (36):
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
7. Paris
6. McPhee
5. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
2. Ace
1. Bucky

KCFalcon59: (38)
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=5
Kelly=4
Elliot=3
Ace=2
Bucky=1

jspchief: (43)
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 5
Bucky 4
Paris 3
Mandisa 0
Ace 1

TitsMagee: (39)
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
2. Ace
1. Bucky

DeepSouth: (41)
Kelly Pickler = 9
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

Reaper16: (41)
Paris=9
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 3
Ace = 2
Bucky = 1

ChiefsCountry: (41)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

siberian khatru: (38)
9. Daughtry
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
6. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
3. Kellie
2. Bucky
1. Ace

Vlad Logicslav: (39)
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 4
Ace Young = 3
Kellie Pickler = 2
Bucky Covington = 1

Frankie
04-05-2006, 09:36 PM
One last comment about Mandisa:

She had a great voice, and depending on the stuff she records I'll probably buy it. Also inside that big big body there's definitely a beautiful girl that needs to come out.

Thig Lyfe
04-06-2006, 10:59 AM
Damn. I got screwed.

Frankie
04-11-2006, 09:48 PM
Last week's recap:

jspchief: (43)
Katipan: (42)
DomerNKC: (41)
DeepSouth: (41)
Reaper16: (41)
ChiefsCountry: (41)
Tribal Warfare: (40)
TitsMagee: (39)
Vlad Logicslav: (39)
KCFalcon59: (38)
siberian khatru: (38)
Frankie: (38)
ArrowheadWolf (36):


Thanks to ArrowheadWolf I avoided the cellar.

Frankie
04-12-2006, 11:08 PM
[QUOTE=Frankie]Well here's your score and your rank after this week: (Your bet for Bucky has been changed to 0)

jspchief: (43)+(39)=(82)
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 5
Bucky 0
Paris 3
Mandisa 0
Ace 1

DomerNKC: (41)+(40)=(81)
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
3. Pickler
2. Ace
0. Bucky

DeepSouth: (41)+(40)=(81)
Kelly Pickler = 9
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 0

Reaper16: (41)+(40)=(81)
Paris=9
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 3
Ace = 2
Bucky = 0

ChiefsCountry: (41)+(40)=(81)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 2
Bucky Covington = 0

Katipan: (42)+(37)=(79)
Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=7
Ace=6
Bucky=0
Kelly=4
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

Tribal Warfare: (40)+(38)=(78)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 8
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-4
Pickler-3
Bucky-0
Ace-1

Vlad Logicslav: (39)+(38)=(77)
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 4
Ace Young = 3
Kellie Pickler = 2
Bucky Covington = 0

TitsMagee: (39)+(38)=(77)
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
2. Ace
0. Bucky

KCFalcon59: (38)+(37)=(75)
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=5
Kelly=4
Elliot=3
Ace=2
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (38)+(36)=(74)
9. Daughtry
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
6. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
3. Kellie
0. Bucky
1. Ace

Frankie: (38)+(34)=(72)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 6
Kellie Pickler = 5
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 1

ArrowheadWolf: (36)+(35)=(71)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
7. Paris
6. McPhee
5. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
2. Ace
0. Bucky

Tribal Warfare
04-12-2006, 11:31 PM
Taylor -9 Daughtry -8 Mcphee- 7 Yamin- 6 Paris-5 Pickler -3 Ace-1

Frankie
04-13-2006, 09:34 AM
Taylor -9 Daughtry -8 Mcphee- 7 Yamin- 6 Paris-5 Pickler -3 Ace-1
ROFL
Nice try TW. But you can't change your originat bet.

Cochise
04-13-2006, 09:38 AM
inside that big big body there's definitely a beautiful girl that needs to come out.

It might be too late. How long ago did she eat her?

Thig Lyfe
04-13-2006, 11:04 AM
Wow. I'm doing really poorly.

Frankie
04-13-2006, 12:35 PM
It might be too late. How long ago did she eat her?
ROFL
that's actually funny. But didn't she have a very nice and delecate personality and a pretty face? I think she did.

Frankie
04-13-2006, 12:37 PM
Wow. I'm doing really poorly.But you have good choices at the remaining top of your list. They'll keep bringing you good points I think.

jspchief
04-26-2006, 09:22 AM
What the hell happened to the game? Frankie, you're slacking. You can't just quit because you suck.

Jilly
04-26-2006, 10:11 AM
I'm pretty sure my top three are screwed up as far as order. I would probably drop Taylor down a few and bump up McPhee.

Frankie
04-26-2006, 10:42 AM
Sorry. Been both ill and busy. But I was going to post before tonite's show. And yes I do suck. But thanks to ArowheadWolf I'm not the suckiest.

Here's your score and your rank after last week: (Your bet for Ace has been changed to 0)

jspchief: (82)+(38)=(120)
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 5
Bucky 0
Paris 3
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

DomerNKC: (81)+(38)=(119)
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
3. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

DeepSouth: (81)+(38)=(119)
Kelly Pickler = 9
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

Reaper16: (81)+(38)=(119)
Paris=9
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 3
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0

ChiefsCountry: (81)+(38)=(119)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

Tribal Warfare: (78)+(37)=(115)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 8
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-4
Pickler-3
Bucky-0
Ace-0

TitsMagee: (77)+(36)=(113)
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
3. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Vlad Logicslav: (77)+(35)=(112)
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 4
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 2
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (75)+(35)=(110)
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=5
Kelly=4
Elliot=3
Ace=0
Bucky=0

Katipan: (79)+(31)=(110)
Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=7
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=4
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

siberian khatru: (74)+(35)=(109)
9. Daughtr
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
6. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
3. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

Frankie: (72)+(33)=(105)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 6
Kellie Pickler = 5
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 0

ArrowheadWolf: (71)+(33)=(104)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
7. Paris
6. McPhee
5. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Reaper16
04-26-2006, 10:43 AM
I'm about to be slaughtered seeing as Paris will get sent home tonight.

Frankie
04-26-2006, 10:47 AM
I'm about to be slaughtered seeing as Paris will get sent home tonight.
I doubt it. I think it will be Kellie, though I think she did a lot better than the judges stomped all over her for.

Reaper16
04-26-2006, 11:00 AM
I doubt it. I think it will be Kellie, though I think she did a lot better than the judges stomped all over her for.
She deserves to go, but she was worse last week and got the HIGHEST AMOUNT OF VOTES OF ANY CONTESTANT! That very notion is almost inconcieveable, but it happened. I think that she might make bottom 3 tonight for the first time, but she's got too strong of a fanbase to get the gong.

I'd love to be wrong about that, though.

Frankie
04-26-2006, 11:53 AM
She deserves to go, but she was worse last week and got the HIGHEST AMOUNT OF VOTES OF ANY CONTESTANT! That very notion is almost inconcieveable, but it happened. I think that she might make bottom 3 tonight for the first time, but she's got too strong of a fanbase to get the gong.

I'd love to be wrong about that, though.
I like her (for another couple of weeks). I like to see Elliot go tonight. I can't see how his pretty average performance last night brought so much ga-ga out of the judges. They must be hearing a lot different there from what we hear at home.

Reaper16
04-26-2006, 11:54 AM
I like her (for another couple of weeks). I like to see Elliot go tonight. I can't see how his pretty average performance last night brought so much ga-ga out of the judges. They must be hearing a lot different there from what we hear at home.
I want Elliot to go as far as possible :harumph:

Clint in Wichita
04-26-2006, 11:57 AM
I like her (for another couple of weeks). I like to see Elliot go tonight. I can't see how his pretty average performance last night brought so much ga-ga out of the judges. They must be hearing a lot different there from what we hear at home.


Elliot is the only decent male vocalist left.

Pickler is a retard who can't sing at all, and should've been gone long ago.

Clint in Wichita
04-26-2006, 11:59 AM
I doubt it. I think it will be Kellie, though I think she did a lot better than the judges stomped all over her for.


She was awful. Very, very awful.

Maybe there are millions of tone-deaf people in this country that think Pickler is right on key.

CosmicPal
04-26-2006, 12:03 PM
People actually watch this shit.

Clint in Wichita
04-26-2006, 12:04 PM
It's like crack...nobody intentionally starts, and everyone knows it's bad for you.

At least I haven't voted for anyone.

BIG_DADDY
04-26-2006, 12:06 PM
QUIT SHOUTING WHEN POSTING A THREAD YOU ****ING RETARD!!!

ChiefsCountry
04-26-2006, 12:09 PM
I know one thing none of them will be a superstar. None of them have the special thing that makes them it.

plbrdude
04-26-2006, 12:10 PM
i get a kick out of it. would like to see chris win. i think all left, with the exception of kellie have a future in music.

Reaper16
04-26-2006, 12:25 PM
I know one thing none of them will be a superstar. None of them have the special thing that makes them it.
yup

Frankie
04-26-2006, 12:50 PM
Elliot is the only decent male vocalist left.

Pickler is a retard who can't sing at all, and should've been gone long ago.
Chris. And Taylor. They are both far better.

OmahaChief
04-26-2006, 01:56 PM
Chris. And Taylor. They are both far better.

As far as pure vocals go Chris and Taylor are not even in the same league as Elliot. Chris and Taylor both have more entertainment value to them and would be an easier POP chart sell. Elliot has a weird look about him, I htink it is his teeth. Chris has the most commerical appeal far and away. I think in the end Chris will win because he has more of the "it" factor then the others but I am rooting for Elliot as I think his voice is golden.

RedNFeisty
04-26-2006, 02:31 PM
I like her (for another couple of weeks). I like to see Elliot go tonight. I can't see how his pretty average performance last night brought so much ga-ga out of the judges. They must be hearing a lot different there from what we hear at home.

RedNFeisty
04-26-2006, 02:32 PM
As far as pure vocals go Chris and Taylor are not even in the same league as Elliot. Chris and Taylor both have more entertainment value to them and would be an easier POP chart sell. Elliot has a weird look about him, I htink it is his teeth. Chris has the most commerical appeal far and away. I think in the end Chris will win because he has more of the "it" factor then the others but I am rooting for Elliot as I think his voice is golden.

Perfectly said!

Frankie
04-26-2006, 07:08 PM
As far as pure vocals go Chris and Taylor are not even in the same league as Elliot. Chris and Taylor both have more entertainment value to them and would be an easier POP chart sell. Elliot has a weird look about him, I htink it is his teeth. Chris has the most commerical appeal far and away. I think in the end Chris will win because he has more of the "it" factor then the others but I am rooting for Elliot as I think his voice is golden.Taylor is the closest voice to Ray Charles I've ever heard. To me, Elliot's voice, while pretty good, does not even come close to the quality of Taylor's. Elliot and Chris are the two more closely compared. And between those two, Chris has a lot better and versatile voice. JMO.

Frankie
04-26-2006, 07:11 PM
Perfectly said!
I know you meant post 60. You must be a psychic?

Frankie
04-26-2006, 07:16 PM
People actually watch this shit.
What do you watch, CP?

I do not apologize for watching AI. It's the ONLY reality show that I watch. I love the way it starts out goofy funny and gradually changes to showcasing a lot of talent.

Logical
04-26-2006, 07:19 PM
If there is a God Cat Eyes Pickler and her fake little innocent little me act will get the boot tonight. Her performance last night was simply putrid.

jspchief
04-26-2006, 07:24 PM
What do you watch, CP?

I do not apologize for watching AI. It's the ONLY reality show that I watch. I love the way it starts out goofy funny and gradually changes to showcasing a lot of talent.Yea, I went from not wanting to watch it, but grudgingly putting up with it for my wife, to watching and liking it but not admitting it to anyone, and I'm finally to the point that I watch it and don't give a shit what anyone has to say about it.

If you like a lot of kinds of music, there's no reason you wouldn't like this show. Sure, there's some bad performances and crappy songs. But there's also usually a few really good performances too. To me, nothing beats a singer who's voice hasn't been masked by producers, and some of these people can really sing. Probably better than a lot of pros.

Reaper16
04-26-2006, 08:44 PM
I'm sooooooo happy that The Pickle got the boot.

Frankie
04-26-2006, 10:41 PM
To me, nothing beats a singer who's voice hasn't been masked by producers, and some of these people can really sing. Probably better than a lot of pros.Exactly. Every season of this show I consistantly see singers get booted out who blow the likes of Britney Spears out of the water.

plbrdude
04-26-2006, 10:48 PM
I'm sooooooo happy that The Pickle got the boot.


me too. america was already the laughing stalk of the world for re-electing bush. how bad would it have been if kellie had been voted in as the next american idol.

Logical
04-26-2006, 11:31 PM
Hallelujah "Cat Eyes" Pickler is gone. PBJ PBJ PBJ

I don't have to look at her and listen to the airhead statements any longer.

Frankie
05-01-2006, 05:20 PM
Here's your score and your rank after last week: (Your bet for Kellie has been changed to 0)

DomerNKC: (119)+(35)=(154)
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
7. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Reaper16: (119)+(35)=(154)
Paris=9
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 0
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0

jspchief: (120)+(33)=(153)
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 0
Bucky 0
Paris 3
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

ChiefsCountry: (119)+(31)=(150)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 0
Paris Bennett = 6
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

Tribal Warfare: (115)+(34)=(149)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 8
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-4
Pickler-0
Bucky-0
Ace-0

DeepSouth: (119)+(29)=(148)
Kelly Pickler = 0
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 6
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

TitsMagee: (113)+(33)=(146)
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
4. Paris
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Vlad Logicslav: (112)+(33)=(145)
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 4
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (110)+(31)=(141)
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=5
Kelly=0
Elliot=3
Ace=0
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (109)+(32)=(141)
9. Daughtr
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
6. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
0. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

Katipan: (110)+(27)=(137)
Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=7
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

Frankie: (105)+(28)=(133)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 6
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 0

ArrowheadWolf: (104)+(28)=(132)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
7. Paris
6. McPhee
0. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky

jspchief just fell from the thrown. ROFL That's what he gets for telling me I 'suck" at this game. Another guy taking a big tumble was DeepSouth. Katipan, who started strong is slowly but surely making her way to the bottom. Sorry mer!

Frankie
05-09-2006, 10:09 PM
Here's your score and your rank after last week: (Your bet for Paris has been changed to 0)

jspchief: (153)+(30)=(183)
Daughtry 9
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 0
Bucky 0
Paris 0
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

DomerNKC: (154)+(28)=(182)
9. McPhee
8. Daughtry
0. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Reaper16: (154)+(26)=(180)
Paris=0
Chris = 8
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 0
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0

Tribal Warfare: (149)+(30)=(179)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 8
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-0
Pickler-0
Bucky-0
Ace-0


ChiefsCountry: (150)+(25)=(175)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Kelly Pickler = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

TitsMagee: (146)+(29)=(175)
9. Taylor
8. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
0. Paris
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Vlad Logicslav: (145)+(29)=(174)
Chris Daughtry = 9
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 0
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0


DeepSouth: (148)+(23)=(171)
Kelly Pickler = 0
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 7
Paris Bennett = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (141)+(26)=(167)
Chris=9
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=0
Kelly=0
Elliot=3
Ace=0
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (141)+(26)=(167)
9. Daughtr
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
0. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

Katipan: (137)+(20)=(157)
Katherine=9
Chris=8
Paris=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

Frankie: (133)+(22)=(155)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 8
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 0

ArrowheadWolf: (132)+(21)=(153)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
0. Paris
6. McPhee
0. Pickler
4. Elliot
3. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky

jspchief
05-09-2006, 10:30 PM
Looks like me and Tribal are the only ones that still have our top 4.

I think McPhee may be gone next (based on tonight's performance), so I could lose a little ground. If voters vote with a memory, Taylor or Elliot will be gone, because Katherine has had so many strong past performances.

listopencil
05-09-2006, 11:30 PM
Time to get rid of Elliot Yamin.

Reaper16
05-10-2006, 01:12 AM
Time to get rid of Elliot Yamin.
You're ****ing insane - he killed it tonight. Again.

listopencil
05-10-2006, 02:35 AM
You're ****ing insane - he killed it tonight. Again.




Melisma

It's a fact: Words like "girl" and "baby" do not have 25 syllables. But thanks to that R&B-spawned, 'Idol'-promulgated school of vocal histrionics -- wherein one overdoes gospel ululations like Whitney Houston with a noseful -- neither the shortest word nor sweetest melody can go unmolested by a uvula-spazzing "showstopper."

http://music.aol.com/home/blender/rock-6

listopencil
05-10-2006, 02:37 AM
Elliot Yamin absolutely destroyed the Elvis songs he did. Even Daughtry had the sense not to **** with Elvis.

Halfcan
05-10-2006, 02:47 AM
I can't believe a guy started an Idol thread?

Frankie
05-10-2006, 09:42 PM
OMG, Chris got booted off!!! :(


Here's your score and your rank as of Wednesday 5/10/06: (Your bet for Chris has been changed to 0)

jspchief: (183)+(21)=(204)
Daughtry 0
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 6
Kellie 0
Bucky 0
Paris 0
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

DomerNKC: (182)+(20)=(202)
9. McPhee
0. Daughtry
0. Paris
6. Taylor
5. Elliott
0. Mandisa
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Tribal Warfare: (179)+(22)=(201)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 0
McPhee -7
Yamin- 6
Mandisa-0
Paris-0
Pickler-0
Bucky-0
Ace-0

Reaper16: (180)+(18)=(198)
Paris=0
Chris = 0
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 6
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 0
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0



TitsMagee: (175)+(21)=(196)
9. Taylor
0. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
5. Elliott
0. Paris
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Vlad Logicslav: (174)+(20)=(194)
Chris Daughtry = 0
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 7
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 0
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

ChiefsCountry: (175)+(17)=(192)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 0
Kelly Pickler = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0


DeepSouth: (171)+(16)=(187)
Kelly Pickler = 0
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 3
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (167)+(17)=(184)
Chris=0
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=0
Kelly=0
Elliot=3
Ace=0
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (167)+(17)=(184)
0. Daughtr
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Paris
5. Taylor
4. Yamin
0. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

ArrowheadWolf: (153)+(18)=(171)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
0. Paris
6. McPhee
0. Pickler
4. Elliot
0. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky[/QUOTE]

Katipan: (157)+(12)=(169)
Katherine=9
Chris=0
Paris=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=2
Taylor=1

Frankie: (155)+(14)=(169)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 0
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 2
Ace Young = 0


Look who's at the bottom now!! :(

Logical
05-10-2006, 09:53 PM
OMG, Chris got booted off!!! :(


Frankie you can quit calculating my score as I have now been mathematically eliminated.

Thanks this was fun.

Oh and may I say what BS that Katharine stayed over Chris.:shake:

Reaper16
05-10-2006, 10:00 PM
Tribal's going to win if McPhee is eliminated.

Mohammed
05-11-2006, 12:46 AM
Turn away from this celebration of the flesh, my son. It is unseemly for one of my own to be so obsessed with that which does not truly matter.

Reaper16
05-11-2006, 12:50 AM
Turn away from this celebration of the flesh, my son. It is unseemly for one of my own to be so obsessed with that which does not truly matter.
http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/images/muhammedwesterga_1.jpg

Mohammed
05-11-2006, 12:55 AM
http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/images/muhammedwesterga_1.jpg

That's really not a very good likeness.

Mohammed
05-11-2006, 12:56 AM
Don't make me start a jihad.

Loki
05-11-2006, 12:58 AM
I can't believe a guy started an Idol thread?
...

Reaper16
05-11-2006, 12:59 AM
...
Is that the satellite from Goldeneye?

Loki
05-11-2006, 01:11 AM
Is that the satellite from Goldeneye?

i haven't a clue... :shrug:

Loki
05-11-2006, 01:14 AM
Don't make me start a jihad.

jspchief
05-11-2006, 08:03 AM
Tribal's going to win if McPhee is eliminated.The only way Tribal can pass me is if Taylor wins.

jidar
05-11-2006, 08:30 AM
FAGS!

Clint in Wichita
05-11-2006, 08:50 AM
I'm so glad that fag got booted off the show.

If I wanted to hear that sh_t, I'd listen to some crappy Nickelback, or one of the dozen or so soundalikes that have popped up in the last year.

The guy sucked ass, and couldn't sing.

Frankie
05-11-2006, 09:39 AM
Frankie you can quit calculating my score as I have now been mathematically eliminated.

Thanks this was fun.

Oh and may I say what BS that Katharine stayed over Chris.:shake:
Thanks. But i will see this through. Actually it's easier for me that way. :)

Reaper16
05-11-2006, 09:51 AM
The only way Tribal can pass me is if Taylor wins.
Which he obviously will if McPhee gets the outs. No way does Elliot win.

ChiefsOne
05-11-2006, 10:08 AM
Clint I'm so glad that Rump Ranger got booted off the show.

If I wanted to hear that sh_t, I'd listen to some crappy Nickelback, or one of the dozen or so soundalikes that have popped up in the last year.

The guy sucked ass, and couldn't sing.


Do you actually think ET is better than Chris? Ellioit sucks ass and should been gone long ago.

Jilly
05-11-2006, 02:06 PM
I think Elliot is really good, I just don't think he's an American Idol. I really hope that Chris gets to flourish somewhere though, preferably in a band, he was excellent.

Frankie
05-11-2006, 04:22 PM
I think Elliot is really good, I just don't think he's an American Idol. I really hope that Chris gets to flourish somewhere though, preferably in a band, he was excellent.
Agreed 100% on both points.

Tribal Warfare
05-11-2006, 04:25 PM
Clint


Do you actually think ET is better than Chris?


I think Yamin is the spitting image of Bobby Beuche

Frankie
05-17-2006, 10:02 PM
Well, after spending the last week in the basement with Katipan, I have left her there and came up with a smile on my face.

After next week the winner of this game will be officially announced on this very thread. He/she will receive 3 reps from me on 3 of his most undeserving posts. The second place (or all tied for that position) shall receive one rep (each) on an unworthy post. The person who finishes last shall receive one negative rep on his/her next post, undeserving of one. The rules of this game do not allow for exceptions, especially in the case of the last place finisher.... Unless, off course, his/her boyfriend is a mod on this forum. :p

Here's your score and your rank as of Wednesday 5/17/06: (Your bet for Elliot has been changed to 0)

jspchief: (204)+(15)=(221)
Daughtry 0
McPhee 8
Taylor 7
Elliot 0
Kellie 0
Bucky 0
Paris 0
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

DomerNKC: (202)+(15)=(217)
9. McPhee
0. Daughtry
0. Paris
6. Taylor
0. Elliott
0. Mandisa
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Tribal Warfare: (201)+(16)=(217)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 0
McPhee -7
Yamin- 0
Mandisa-0
Paris-0
Pickler-0
Bucky-0
Ace-0

TitsMagee: (196)+(16)=(212)
9. Taylor
0. Daughtry
7. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Elliott
0. Paris
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Reaper16: (198)+(12)=(210)
Paris=0
Chris = 0
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 0
Katherine = 5
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 0
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0


Vlad Logicslav: (194)+(13)=(207)
Chris Daughtry = 0
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 0
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Paris Bennett = 0
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

ChiefsCountry: (192)+(14)=(206)
Katharine McPhee = 9
Chris Daughtry = 0
Kelly Pickler = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

DeepSouth: (187)+(13)=(200)
Kelly Pickler = 0
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Katharine McPhee = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (184)+(14)=(198)
Chris=0
Katherine=8
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=0
Kelly=0
Elliot=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (184)+(13)=(197)
0. Daughtr
8. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Paris
5. Taylor
0. Yamin
0. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

ArrowheadWolf: (171)+(14)=(185)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
0. Paris
6. McPhee
0. Pickler
0. Elliot
0. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Frankie: (169)+(12)=(181)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 0
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 3
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0

Katipan: (169)+(10)=(179)
Katherine=9
Chris=0
Paris=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=0
Taylor=1

jspchief
05-17-2006, 10:06 PM
I've already won.

For someone to tie me, they would have to have 219 points, and their 9 point contestant remaining. No one has 219 points, so no one is within reach of my minimum score of 228.

Thanks for playing, suckers.

Reaper16
05-18-2006, 12:02 AM
I've already won.

For someone to tie me, they would have to have 219 points, and their 9 point contestant remaining. No one has 219 points, so no one is within reach of my minimum score of 228.

Thanks for playing, suckers.
But you had Katherine McPhee as an 8, so you lose in your own way for liking that garbage. :)

Tribal Warfare
05-18-2006, 12:16 AM
I've already won.

For someone to tie me, they would have to have 219 points, and their 9 point contestant remaining. No one has 219 points, so no one is within reach of my minimum score of 228.

Thanks for playing, suckers.Let see who wins the competition next week, because the winner of American Idol should have exponentially higher bonus points

jspchief
05-18-2006, 07:35 AM
But you had Katherine McPhee as an 8, so you lose in your own way for liking that garbage. :)When I made those rankings, I felt she was second best in the competition. While she seems to get worse and worse every week, I'm not sure Elliot or Taylor have done a whole lot to pass her.

A month ago, I would have said I thought the field was all very talented. But lately, they have impressed me less and less. I think Elliot has a great voice when he doesn't averdo the vibrato, but he's a niche singer who's commercial success will be hindered by the genre he's suited for. Taylor may be a great performer, but vocally he's inferior to the other top 3.

If I had it to do over again, I probably would have made Elliot the 8 and Katherine the 7. And it's not about liking Katherine's music. It's about recognizing her talent.

Frankie
05-18-2006, 12:39 PM
Let see who wins the competition next week, because the winner of American Idol should have exponentially higher bonus points
Actually I've had the same idea all along. So since there's already support for this idea I think if your top pick becomes the American Idol you will get 5 bonus points. So it shall be written. So it shall be done.

Logical
05-18-2006, 03:11 PM
When I made those rankings, I felt she was second best in the competition. While she seems to get worse and worse every week, I'm not sure Elliot or Taylor have done a whole lot to pass her.

A month ago, I would have said I thought the field was all very talented. But lately, they have impressed me less and less. I think Elliot has a great voice when he doesn't averdo the vibrato, but he's a niche singer who's commercial success will be hindered by the genre he's suited for. Taylor may be a great performer, but vocally he's inferior to the other top 3.

If I had it to do over again, I probably would have made Elliot the 8 and Katherine the 7. And it's not about liking Katherine's music. It's about recognizing her talent.
You know I understand what you are saying when this game was created I had Mandissa as only the 4th best performer, but after the ensuing weeks have passed it is now clear as hell that she should have been in the top 3. Hell I had McPhee as 5th best and after seeing her perform the last 4 weeks I now believe she did not even belong in the top 5. I am pleased with Taylor doing so well because he is such an entertainer and really is that not what this should be all about, who is the most entertaining along with talented. I must admit I will be pissed as hell if McPhee wins this thing.

For me that will be like watching the Raiders win the Superbowl, there is just absolutely no good that can come from it.

Thig Lyfe
05-23-2006, 03:01 PM
YESSS I'm no longer in last place!

Tribal Warfare
05-23-2006, 07:20 PM
Round 1- Taylor OWNED!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Tribal Warfare
05-24-2006, 09:10 PM
I won

Frankie
05-24-2006, 10:03 PM
Well it's over. Taylor Hicks is this year's American Idol. Below is the final ranking of the participants. Your McPhee points has been changed to zero for this tally. Remember those who had picked Taylor as their top choice receive 5 bonus points:

Tribal Warfare: (217)+(9)+(5)=(231)
Taylor - 9
Daughtry- 0
McPhee -0
Yamin- 0
Mandisa-0
Paris-0
Pickler-0
Bucky-0
Ace-0

jspchief: (221)+(7)=(228)
Daughtry 0
McPhee 0
Taylor 7
Elliot 0
Kellie 0
Bucky 0
Paris 0
Mandisa 0
Ace 0

TitsMagee: (212)+(9)+(5)=(226)
9. Taylor
0. Daughtry
0. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Elliott
0. Paris
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

DomerNKC: (217)+(6)=(223)
0. McPhee
0. Daughtry
0. Paris
6. Taylor
0. Elliott
0. Mandisa
0. Pickler
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Reaper16: (210)+(7)=(217)
Paris=0
Chris = 0
Taylor = 7
Elliot = 0
Katherine = 0
Mandisa = 0
Kelly = 0
Ace = 0
Bucky = 0


Vlad Logicslav: (207)+(8)=(215)
Chris Daughtry = 0
Taylor Hicks = 8
Elliott Yamin = 0
Mandisa = 0
Katharine McPhee = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Ace Young = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

ChiefsCountry: (206)+(5)=(211)
Katharine McPhee = 0
Chris Daughtry = 0
Kelly Pickler = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Taylor Hicks = 5
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

DeepSouth: (200)+(8)=(208)
Kelly Pickler = 0
Tayloy Hicks = 8
Chris Daughtry = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Katharine McPhee = 0
Mandisa = 0
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0
Bucky Covington = 0

KCFalcon59: (198)+(6)=(204)
Chris=0
Katherine=0
Mandisa=0
Taylor=6
Paris=0
Kelly=0
Elliot=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0

siberian khatru: (197)+(5)=(202)
0. Daughtr
0. McPhee
0. Mandisa
0. Paris
5. Taylor
0. Yamin
0. Kellie
0. Bucky
0. Ace

Frankie: (181)+(9)+(5)=(195)
Taylor Hicks = 9
Chris Daughtry = 0
Mandisa = 0
Paris Bennett = 0
Kellie Pickler = 0
Bucky Covington = 0
Katharine McPhee = 0
Elliott Yamin = 0
Ace Young = 0

ArrowheadWolf: (185)+(8)=(193)
0. Mandisa
8. Taylor
0. Paris
0. McPhee
0. Pickler
0. Elliot
0. Daughtry
0. Ace
0. Bucky

Katipan: (179)+(1)=(180)
Katherine=0
Chris=0
Paris=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=0
Taylor=1

Frankie
05-24-2006, 10:21 PM
:clap: Congratulations to TRIBAL WARFARE, the winner of the 2006 Planet's Official "American Idol" game. :clap:

As previously mentioned as the winner you will receive three positive reps on three of your unworthy posts. Should you for any reason be unable to perform your duties as the winner in the next twelve months the first runner up, jspchief will assume your position.

jspchief, as the official runnerup, will earn one positive rep on one of his unworthy posts.

For finishing dead last Katipan will receive a negative rep on one of her undeserving posts. Sorry Mer. Hate to do this to you. But Endelt, I'm sure, will be there to comfort you like the prince that he is. ;) :p

Thank you all for playing. :)

OldTownChief
05-24-2006, 10:24 PM
:clap: Congratulations to TRIBAL WARFARE, the winner of the 2006 Planet's Official "American Idol" game. :clap:

As previously mentioned as the winner you will receive three positive reps on three of your unworthy posts. Should you for any reason be unable to perform your duties as the winner in the next twelve months the first runner up, jspchief will assume your position.

jspchief, as the official runnerup, will earn one positive rep on one of his unworthy posts.

For finishing dead last Katipan will receive a negative rep on one of her undeserving posts. Sorry Mer. Hate to do this to you. But Endelt, I'm sure, will be there to comfort you like the prince that he is. ;) :p

Thank you all for playing. :)

I'll give her a positive rep for putting that freak at the bottom.

Tribal Warfare
05-24-2006, 10:55 PM
My acceptance/thank you post

:deevee: I like to thank God for giving the strength in picking the approximate order for this American Idol. There were alot of hardships in path for this honor. poor performances for som of the favorites or shocking turn of events included, but I thank the Lord for allowing to prevail :deevee:


I thought I had to add the generic acceptance speech :D

jspchief
05-24-2006, 11:02 PM
5 bonus points? When did you invent that f*cking rule?

Save your positive rep you douche bag, you'll need it to offset the neg I give you for adding some stupid ass rule on the last week of the competition, after I already had the thing won.

Weak.

Logical
05-25-2006, 01:17 AM
5 bonus points? When did you invent that f*cking rule?

Save your positive rep you douche bag, you'll need it to offset the neg I give you for adding some stupid ass rule on the last week of the competition, after I already had the thing won.

Weak.
I pretty much agree with jspchief, who should be the winner. Why change the rules at the last minute?

Tribal Warfare
05-25-2006, 02:24 AM
I pretty much agree with jspchief, who should be the winner. Why change the rules at the last minute?


If McPhee would've won he wouldn't be complaining ROFL

Logical
05-25-2006, 03:39 AM
If McPhee would've won he wouldn't be complaining ROFLThough I understand you, he would have won either way had the rules not been changed.

By the way you did a really find job with your picks as well and that should be recognized.

Tribal Warfare
05-25-2006, 06:04 AM
5 bonus points? When did you invent that f*cking rule?

Save your positive rep you douche bag, you'll need it to offset the neg I give you for adding some stupid ass rule on the last week of the competition, after I already had the thing won.

Weak.


http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showpost.php?p=3212343&postcount=102

jspchief
05-25-2006, 07:26 AM
http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showpost.php?p=3212343&postcount=102 Yea, I had the thing won, per the rules that had existed throughout the entire thread. Only after I wrap it up a week early, does Frankie mention these mysterious 5 bonus points.

Pretty lame to change the rules 8 weeks into the game.

Regardless TW, you did a nice job. I know you and I were the only ones that still had our top 4 remaining with 4 contestants left.

And I really don't care who won. I preferred Chris over all of them, but it's not like I was attached to anyone.

Ari Chi3fs
05-25-2006, 07:49 AM
Katipan: (0)+(0)=(0)
Katherine=0
Chris=0
Paris=0
Ace=0
Bucky=0
Kelly=0
Mandisa=0
Elliot=0
Taylor=0

You know how I know you all are gay? If you seriously participated in this...

Frankie
05-25-2006, 10:00 AM
5 bonus points? When did you invent that f*cking rule?

Save your positive rep you douche bag, you'll need it to offset the neg I give you for adding some stupid ass rule on the last week of the competition, after I already had the thing won.

Weak.

Thank you jspchief for voicing your concerns. And legitimate concerns thery are. Hopefully the following points and explanations will put you at ease:

1- This was a new game with not much thougt about if the point system was going to work. I had to see it in use for a few weeks to see if it was fair. I was uneasy about the point system discouraging some from early stages when they would lose someone from near the top of their list. Every week thereon they would lose more ground faster and faster. I felt the need, from the very beginning, for a bonus incentive to keep folks hopeful and excited. In fact I was thinking about 10 points for bonus.

This year's game was basically the betta version. It had bugs that became more evident as we went on. It needed to be debugged. Next year hopefully we will have a tighter point system from what we learned this year. And hopefully we will start from the top 12 stage.

2- One of the things that got adjusted as we went along was the fact that originally the winner was going to receive one positive rep. If we had stuck to the original format you would have received (as winner) one rep. Well you have received the same as the runnerup now.

3- If my changing/adjusting the format were to help me win, then you could legitimately cry foul. As it is I was so far out of it that it didn't make any difference to me. i did it for the integrity of the game itself.

Hopefully now you, Logical and others concerned can see the motives behind the format adjustments. Good luck next year if you choose to participate.

Frankie
05-25-2006, 10:03 AM
You know how I know you all are gay? If you seriously participated in this...
On the contrary, we are the ones who are so sure of the strength of our manhood that we don't have to worry about it. Hopefully you will become sure enough of yours to participate next year.
;)

Katipan
05-25-2006, 11:11 AM
...

Katipan
05-25-2006, 11:13 AM
I gave you positive rep Frankie. I hope you enjoy it.

Logical
05-25-2006, 11:14 AM
Thank you jspchief for voicing your concerns. And legitimate concerns thery are. Hopefully the following points and explanations will put you at ease:

1- This was a new game with not much thougt about if the point system was going to work. I had to see it in use for a few weeks to see if it was fair. I was uneasy about the point system discouraging some from early stages when they would lose someone from near the top of their list. Every week thereon they would lose more ground faster and faster. I felt the need, from the very beginning, for a bonus incentive to keep folks hopeful and excited. In fact I was thinking about 10 points for bonus.

This year's game was basically the betta version. It had bugs that became more evident as we went on. It needed to be debugged. Next year hopefully we will have a tighter point system from what we learned this year. And hopefully we will start from the top 12 stage.

2- One of the things that got adjusted as we went along was the fact that originally the winner was going to receive one positive rep. If we had stuck to the original format you would have received (as winner) one rep. Well you have received the same as the runnerup now.

3- If my changing/adjusting the format were to help me win, then you could legitimately cry foul. As it is I was so far out of it that it didn't make any difference to me. i did it for the integrity of the game itself.

Hopefully now you, Logical and others concerned can see the motives behind the format adjustments. Good luck next year if you choose to participate.

My only comment is your timing was horrible. You announced the bonus only after it was clear that no matter what jspchief had won, then you add a bonus to make the final week important. Not good form IMO.

Katipan
05-25-2006, 11:17 AM
I'll give her a positive rep for putting that freak at the bottom.

I definitely won't be calling you a pathetic fag in rep then. xoxo

Frankie
05-25-2006, 02:41 PM
I gave you positive rep Frankie. I hope you enjoy it.
ROFL
Very creative. Check your reps.

Frankie
05-25-2006, 02:47 PM
My only comment is your timing was horrible. You announced the bonus only after it was clear that no matter what jspchief had won, then you add a bonus to make the final week important. Not good form IMO.
I agree. But as I saw this first ever game as a work in progress, something had to give. And B/N I did not check to see if anyone had an insurmountable lead. I truly thought this way was the fairer of the two ways. This first game should be considered a test anyway.

Jilly
05-26-2006, 04:44 PM
2 pts from second place....story of my life!!!!