PDA

View Full Version : Newt has his prescription


Baby Lee
09-06-2006, 06:34 PM
http://www.humanevents.com/winningthefuture.php?id=16863

Newt has outlined his proposed strategy for Republicans. Let's see if we can assess the merits of the plan as a plan, rather than engaging in a more general XWNJ v. YWNJ, you are teh suchs, petty exchange.
So, is this the roadmap to follow, or are there things that should be excised? Things that should be added? Things to be emphasized? Things that cross the aisle in appeal. Are there too many points for the electorate to follow? Anything a downright turnoff? Discuss.

1. Make English the Official Language of Government.
The House should pass a bill making English the official language of government, abolishing multilingual ballots and reaffirming that new citizens should be required to pass a test on American history in English. The Rasmussen poll reported that support for English as the official language was 85%. The Zogby poll had it at 84%. Why do Republican leaders find it so hard to side with more than four out of every five Americans? How many liberal Democrats who currently assume they are unbeatable would suddenly have a hard time explaining a series of votes against English to their constituents? Remember, at 85%, there are no anti-English congressional districts no matter what the elite media says.


2. Control the Borders.
The House should pass a narrowly focused bill to ensure that the United States can control the border. The current Senate bill is a disaster. It is impossible to pass a "comprehensive" immigration bill in the next two months. The American people overwhelmingly want the borders controlled and every act of terrorism reminds us that having the borders uncontrolled makes us more vulnerable to attack. The House should immediately pass a border-control bill and conservative Republican senators should move every day to bring it up in the Senate. Let Democrats and elitist Republicans block controlling the border and make that a referendum test for Election Day.


3. Keep God in the Pledge.
Congress should take two steps to preserve the right to say "one nation under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance, a right which is supported by 91% of all Americans. The American people feel deeply that our Declaration of Independence is correct in saying that each of us is endowed by our Creator with inalienable rights. Beginning with the Supreme Court's 1963 decision outlawing school prayer, the courts have waged a 43-year assault on the core values of American liberty. It is time to return to a balanced Constitutional system. There is no Constitutional case for five lawyers' on the court being a floating majority for a permanent Constitutional Convention.

The American people would rally to the elected branches' taking steps to rebalance the Constitution. First, the House should pass a bill suspending the recent federal district court decision in California outlawing the words "one nation under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance. Second, the House should pass a law blocking the Supreme Court from reviewing the constitutionality of the Pledge of Allegiance (a power of the Congress expressly granted in the Constitution).


4. Require a Voter ID Card.
The American people overwhelmingly support (85% in one poll) having a voter id card so we can be sure only legal citizens are voting. Passing a bill to require this in all federal elections would be a big step toward more honest elections.


5.. Repeal the Death Tax, for Good.
The American people have consistently supported the total repeal of the death tax and the House should simply pass it once a week and attach it to various Senate bills to force the Senate to deal with it again and again. Let liberals explain why they oppose something that more than 70% of the country favors.


6. Restore Property Rights.
The American people are deeply opposed to local politicians' being able to seize a citizen's home or business. The Supreme Court's Kelo decision on eminent domain is one of the most unpopular in recent years and is also one of the most dangerous. Anyone who knows the history of local government corruption in America knows it will not be long before some corrupt developers engage some corrupt politicians and this power is exploited at the cost of most Americans. Members of the Black Caucus have been among the most vocal in pointing out that it is poor people who will be the most victimized so rich developers and greedy politicians can make the money off their homes and businesses. The House should pass a powerful bill returning the constitutional law to the pre-Kelo rules and blocking the Supreme Court from reviewing it.


7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.
The country is eager for a straightforward new energy strategy for national security, environmental and economic reasons. The combination of $3 gasoline, watching Iran, Venezuela, Saudi Arabia and Russia get more of our money, and concerns about the environment come together to require real change. The House should meet that need. Starting with Rep. Jim Nussle's (R-Iowa) bill on renewable fuels, adding to it clean nuclear power using new technologies that are safe and produce little waste, developing more clean coal solutions, investing in a conversion to a hydrogen economy, incentivizing conservation, providing tax credits so the auto industry can invest in the new technology and new manufacturing equipment needed to produce revolutionary new vehicles, creating the tax incentives to build the distribution system for biofuels, hybrids, and hydrogen, providing deeper tax incentives for radically better cars (imagine a substantial tax credit for cars exceeding 200 miles to the gallon of petroleum through a combination of E-85 or biodiesel, hybrid use of electricity and hydrogen), and a bill to create state flexibility in exploring off shore with a 50% split in revenue so state legislatures and governors would have an incentive to develop environmentally sound methods of exploration and production.


8. Control Spending and Balance the Budget.
The House should pass new budget legislation to control spending, leading to a balanced budget in seven years (the length of time we gave ourselves in the Contract with America and which led to the first four balanced budgets since the 1920s), with special focus on programs liberals will fight to increase spending. Let the country see who is really committed to smaller government with lower taxes and who is committed to bigger government with higher taxes.


9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability.
A major result of the No Child Left Behind legislation has been the clear revelation that a number of schools systems are crippling and destroying children. When the Detroit school system only graduates 21% of entering freshman on time, it is clear the children are being cheated. The American people strongly support reforms designed to save the children. The first step would be to insist that federal funds only go to school systems which require teacher competency and accountability. A clear choice between those who want to save the children and those who want to save the bureaucrats would mobilize the country in favor of dramatic education reform.


10. Defend America From the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.
Terrorism is a real threat. Congress should hold hearings on the recent terrorist activities in Canada, the U.K. and Morocco. The House should move bills that strengthen our security from terrorists with increased powers for surveillance, an overruling of the disastrous Hamdan decision and a series of other steps.


11. Focus on Iran and North Korea.
The American people are very prepared to believe we face extraordinary threats from a nuclear North Korea and an Iranian regime actively seeking to develop nuclear weapons. Any actions in Iraq need to be recast in terms of their impact on Iran. A weak America in Iraq will be unable to stop Iran. Stopping Iran is potentially literally a matter of life and death. Congress should hold hearings on the scale of the Iranian and North Korean threat, the statements of their key leaders and the requirements for action to replace these dictatorships before they succeed in killing millions of Americans. The Santorum Iranian democracy bill should be forced out of the Senate in the context of these threats. Everything about Iraq should be debated within this larger and much more dangerous context.

Cochise
09-06-2006, 06:52 PM
Sounds good to me. Particularly 1-4 seem very low-risk. I don't think anyone would be willing to stand in front of voters and explain a vote against it all through election season.

banyon
09-06-2006, 07:30 PM
I agree with 1-4, 6, so long as it's targeted at private development, 7-8, 9 is the wrong approach, 10-11 are too vague and rhetorical to really decide either way on.

Adept Havelock
09-06-2006, 07:34 PM
1. Make English the Official Language of Government.
Why? We've always been a nation of immigrants, and areas in cities where a foreign language is predominant is nothing new. It's a nice populist issue, but personally I don't see much worth getting bothered about on either side of it.

2. Control the Borders.
Sounds good to me. However, does this mean keeping a weather eye on who comes across our historically open borders, or attempting to build Fortress America? If the latter, count me out.

3. Keep God in the Pledge.
Bah. We got along fine without it until the Religious folks got it put in there in the 50's. I do agree that I was endowed with inalienable rights by my Creator(s)... however, my creator(s) were my parents, not some supernatural entity, AFAICS. However, if people choose to say "under God" I don't have a problem with it. Freedom of superstition and all that...

4. Require a Voter ID Card.
Sounds good to me.

5.. Repeal the Death Tax, for Good.
As soon as someone proves the dead person is being taxed for dying. Last time I looked, the tax was on the transfer of wealth from one person to another. Also, I happen to agree with the idea that it's a good thing in a democracy to dissuade concentration of wealth through inheriting it. Wealth=Power and if you want it work for it. Also, it encourages private companies to go public to avoid this taxation, which helps the economy by allowing more people to profit from investment. I do agree with exempting any estate under $5 million or so. Paris Hilton doesn't need another tax break. :p

6. Restore Property Rights.
Agreed.

7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.
Agreed, but lotsa luck with that.

8. Control Spending and Balance the Budget.
Again, lotsa luck with that one. The Republicans have proven themselves as bad as the Democrats when it comes to this.

9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability.
As long as school "administrators" are a considerable part of that accountability, fine with me. Also, as long as that accountability is limited to a teacher's effectiveness in the classroom barring a crime.

10. Defend America From the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.
Terrorism is a real threat. Congress should recognize it as such, and that it's no more a strictly military problem than when the previous administration tried to treat it strictly as a law enforcement issue. They certainly shouldn't throw away the constitution to do it. Also, we should be trying to undermine the terrorists by offering people (not installing at gunpoint) in regions that traditionally support them superior options. "Islamofascism" or whatever you want to call it won't be "dealt with" until the militants know that to move against us=death, and the supporters in the general population turn their backs on them because they have better offers from the rest of the world. Something along the lines of the effort to undermine the religious warfare in N. Ireland, for starters.

11. Focus on Iran and North Korea.
We've contained the Soviet Union and now China for decades. We were treated to the same arguments that they were not rational actors and couldn't be dissuaded by mere deterrence. That argument was wrong then, and it's wrong now. Contain them, absolutely. However, military action would be spectacularly stupid, IMO.

Again, all of the above is JMO. Disagree? Good. That's what makes this nation great.

patteeu
09-06-2006, 08:15 PM
Looks pretty good to me.

WilliamTheIrish
09-06-2006, 08:30 PM
1) Absolutely. I don't care how. Just please have people make an attempt to learn the frappin' language.

2) Agree. But how?

3) meh.

4) Agree.

5) Agree.
There's plenty of wealth out there. Go make your own instead of grabbing the money that people have left to their heirs.

6)F'in Agree.

7, 8) Should be on the list as 1 and 2.

9) I don't know what the answer is on certain PS districts. Throwing more money at them doesn't seem to make them better.

10)Agree. But again, how do you contain something that they (may) already have?

Otter
09-06-2006, 08:48 PM
More Cow Bell?

jettio
09-06-2006, 10:40 PM
[QUOTE=Baby Lee][url]

1. Make English the Official Language of Government.

If you think this is a problem, you are confused and hateful, go to church and pray.

2. Control the Borders.

How about budgeting the money to do it. there are already laws on the books.

3. Keep God in the Pledge.

This issue does not deserve an exception for constitutional interpretation. That is an astonishing proposal. History prof who hates lawyers kind of crazy sh*t proposal. Newt must be back into the psychedelics, what church does he go to?

4. Require a Voter ID Card.
If you think this is a problem, you are confused and hateful, go to church and pray.

5.. Repeal the Death Tax, for Good.
Our oldest tax is the inheritance tax. Calling it a death tax is just the latest PR trick used by the people that want to feather their own nest even when it is against the national interest. If you think this is a problem, You've been punk'd, go to church and pray.

6. Restore Property Rights.
Property rights have not been diminished a whole lot.

7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.
Good idea. Can the GOP get it done before November?

8. Control Spending and Balance the Budget.
Good idea. Can the GOP get it done before November?

9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability.
What is Newt going to do with the kids that are failing and have their schools shut down because their teachers suck? send them out to the suburbs.

10. Defend America From the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.
I think kicking their azz would be better than holding Congressional hearings, but then again Newt is only talking about how to hold on to the confused and hateful white guy vote and not how to solve real problems.

11. Focus on Iran and North Korea.
The American people are very prepared to believe we face extraordinary threats from a nuclear North Korea and an Iranian regime actively seeking to develop nuclear weapons. Any actions in Iraq need to be recast in terms of their impact on Iran. A weak America in Iraq will be unable to stop Iran. Stopping Iran is potentially literally a matter of life and death. Congress should hold hearings on the scale of the Iranian and North Korean threat, the statements of their key leaders and the requirements for action to replace these dictatorships before they succeed in killing millions of Americans. The Santorum Iranian democracy bill should be forced out of the Senate in the context of these threats. Everything about Iraq should be debated within this larger and much more dangerous context.

I am very prepared to believe that instead of blowing smoke up voter's azzes, maybe we ought to have honorable and competent people making the decisions.

BucEyedPea
09-06-2006, 11:45 PM
http://www.humanevents.com/winningthefuture.php?id=16863

As a Randite/Misean I realize most of mine will never be implemented, that I'm ahead of my time( LOL!) but what the heck. It's just ideas.

1. Make English the Official Language of Government.
English is doing just fine without govt mandating our official language.
Multilingual ballots are unecessary however.

2. Control the Borders.
Agree.

3. Keep God in the Pledge.
This is not a federal issue. It's local.

[quote]Second, the House should pass a law blocking the Supreme Court from reviewing the constitutionality of the Pledge of Allegiance (a power of the Congress expressly granted in the Constitution).
I do believe this power IS granted to Congress.I can support this...as it
keeps the issue at the state/local level.

4. Require a Voter ID Card.
WTF? I already have one in Florida.
Not a federal issue...I believe for the most part.

5. Repeal the Death Tax, for Good.
As Misean and a Randite I am for this. But I can also live with status quo.
This doesn't really affect me.

For every rags to riches story there is a riches to rag story of those who inherited wealth. It's harder to keep it.

6. Restore Property Rights.
Yes! Yes! Yes!

7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.
Fine up to point...that is as far as the federal govt is concerned. Newt's plans smacks of too much govt central planning...always a disaster because govt cannot allocate resources correctly or efficently. ( to be expected with a NeoCon though) I have more faith in the market with a touch of govt...but that's it.

8. Control Spending and Balance the Budget.
Absolutely! But it will never happen. I'm just waitin' for the collapse that all democracies end in as they vote themselves largesse. Then we'll start all over again like Greece, Rome and the Soviet Union...probably not far after Sweden and Europe...but we will just as surely follow.

9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability.
Not a Federal problem or issue. Abolish the Dept of Education where all the rotten experimentation is coming from. We've had more problems since it's implementation.

Allow education to be very, very local for more parental involvement...and break the back of the NEA teacher's union.

Govt is NEVER going to improve education. The more govt in it the worse it gets. That's a FACT.

10. Defend America From the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.
Leave the entire ME and tape it off all around with yellow crime scene tape.

Contain the problem, stop antagonizing them, stop imposing democracy at gunpoint but get out of and off their land, get our bases out, stop bribing their puppet govts. Israel has over 200 nukes it can engage in MADD with Iran. Time for it to defend itself.

Before leaving, if possible: We do have to talk for a negotiated peace on the Israeli Palestinian conflict by working with the non-extremists on both sides. So that the extremist can eventually be choked off. Same in Iraq even if it means partition with revenue sharing. If the south wants to go with Iran...so be it. If they war with each other after that...

...let them all kill one another but we stay out of it.

The terrorist threat is real but exaggerated and far more controllable with changes in our foreign policy. Unrealistic? That's just a consideration. The status quo has not worked.

11. Focus on Iran and North Korea.
Leave them alone. The best defense is no offense. I believe MADD worked before with the Soviet Union and can work again.

We can't stop the world from getting nukes without draconian measures that are just not feasible.

I'd add:
12. Teach American school children Freedom Philosophy and what democracy is and is not: that it is not the best form of govt...that we are a Constitutional Republic where the people do NOT make the laws but our reps do, subject to certain limits. Of course this is not a Federal issue...but I'm all for using the bully pulpit.

13. Repeal the Income Tax....a compromise would be the Fair Tax as an in between step. But get rid of the IRS!

14. Restore us back to sound money.

15. Repeal NAFTA and GATT, get out of WTO and all other sovereignty eroding trade agreements ( and non-trade ones too). Keep tariffs low to encourage trade but let the people get on with it on their own. We must have free trade in the US first. We must have less socialism so business will stay in the USA!

Fishpicker
09-07-2006, 12:07 AM
All of those are good points. I would vote for him if he hadn't defended Rummy's Nazi-appeaser statement.

Ugly Duck
09-07-2006, 12:18 AM
I had the pleasure of meeting Newt several times. He's a goofy, care-free guy in real life. Like a kid with one of those beenies with propellers on it. Too bad he's such a scum-suckin Republican doucebag when he goes to work....

banyon
09-07-2006, 09:05 AM
9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability.
Not a Federal problem or issue. Abolish the Dept of Education where all the rotten experimentation is coming from. We've had more problems since it's implementation.
Govt is NEVER going to improve education. The more govt in it the worse it gets. That's a FACT.

Evidently. :)


I'd add:
12. Teach American school children Freedom Philosophy and what democracy is and is not: that it is not the best form of govt...that we are a Constitutional Republic where the people do NOT make the laws but our reps do, subject to certain limits. Of course this is not a Federal issue...but I'm all for using the bully pulpit.

I'm confused...who implements this policy? The Pentagon?

BucEyedPea
09-07-2006, 12:29 PM
Evidently. :)




I'm confused...who implements this policy? The Pentagon?
ROFL Read it again....silly man. No implementation by Fed... use the bully pulpit.

Chief Henry
09-07-2006, 12:59 PM
I could vote for Newt as President easily.

oldandslow
09-07-2006, 01:43 PM
1. absolutely makes no difference to anyone. Plus you cannot enforce it. Are you going to tell a Navajo, for example, that he can't speak his native language. Ridiculous idea.

2. Control the borders.
How? No one has any idea how to stop the influx of foreign nationals into this nation and the only rational option is to help Mexico develop its own economy so people will stay home.

3. Keep God in the Pledge.

We did fine for 175 years with God out of the Pledge. This is simply pandering.

4. Require voter ID card. Many states do. The key word there is STATE.

5. Repeal death tax.

That I can live with.

6. Restore Property rights.

Yep, good idea.

7. Energy.

This is the only idea of the 12 that really matters and Newt has no idea how to do it. If it were me, I would fund major universities energy research departments to the max.

8. Control spending.

The only people who spend more than the democrats are the republicans.

9. Education

LOCAL CONTROL!!!! I get sick and tired of the feds trying to run local school districts. NCLB is just the latest incarnation.

10. Terrorists.

The best way to defend yourself against a Rattlesnake is to leave it alone. We should never have gone to the ME. Period.

11. Iran and N. Korea.

Let their neighbors influence them. What we do is going to have little impact on either nation.

Most of Newt's points are either unworkable, undesireable, or in some instances, counter-productive.

I a'int voting for him.

Brock
09-07-2006, 01:50 PM
1. absolutely makes no difference to anyone. Plus you cannot enforce it. Are you going to tell a Navajo, for example, that he can't speak his native language. Ridiculous idea.

Is it really ridiculous to think that the US government should not be obligated to provide bilingual services? Nobody is telling anybody not to speak their language, just that we "no habla".

patteeu
09-07-2006, 01:51 PM
1. absolutely makes no difference to anyone. Plus you cannot enforce it. Are you going to tell a Navajo, for example, that he can't speak his native language. Ridiculous idea.

I suspect that the intent is that government would operate exclusively in English, giving those who don't speak the language an incentive to learn it. If you don't think it makes a difference to anyone, we might as well do it, right?

8. Control spending.

The only people who spend more than the democrats are the republicans.

That certainly remains to be seen. I hope it remains to be seen for a very long time.

Chief Faithful
09-07-2006, 02:00 PM
8. Control spending.

The only people who spend more than the democrats are the republicans.



One group wants us to believe the deficit can be brought under control by increasing taxes and the other wants us to believe the solution is cutting taxes. Both are delusional. Good to see Newt saying the solution is to control spending.

oldandslow
09-07-2006, 02:08 PM
I suspect that the intent is that government would operate exclusively in English, giving those who don't speak the language an incentive to learn it. If you don't think it makes a difference to anyone, we might as well do it, right?

No, not at all. The rational approach in a situation like that is to remain status quo.



That certainly remains to be seen. I hope it remains to be seen for a very long time.

Not really. Reagan and Bush II admins have spent far more than Clinton and Carter admins. I think that 2008 will see a dem pres and 1 chamber changing hands.

Chief Faithful
09-07-2006, 02:11 PM
I suspect that the intent is that government would operate exclusively in English, giving those who don't speak the language an incentive to learn it. If you don't think it makes a difference to anyone, we might as well do it, right?


You are correct, the intent is about government operations not about what language is present in the public space. Example, considering road signs are in English it is a good idea that everyone who has a drivers license passed a drivers test in English.

Chieftain58
09-09-2006, 09:37 PM
7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.

Not going to happen with the Republicans in the pockets of the Oil Companies.

headsnap
09-09-2006, 09:55 PM
...and it's, MORE COWBELL!!!

whoman69
09-09-2006, 10:41 PM
1. Make English the Official Language of Government
Normally if you are going to make a list like this, the most important would be first. Is this really going to cure America's ills. Make a list of the things that need the most attention is this is going to come somewhere around 250.

2. Control the borders
Good luck with that one. This is pandering to the public, as is most of the list.

3. Keep God in the Pledge
Just playing to his base. This is issue #789 in importance.

4. Require voter ID card. Many states do. The key word there is STATE
Never a fan of states rights, but this is not a federal issue. I was surprised as hell when I went to vote a few years ago, showed my card and was told by the people working there it was illegal for them to ask for the card.

5. Repeal death tax
This issue has been the most clouded issue in the last 50 years. Nobody understands the tax. Republicans came up with a real snappy name for this one. They should call it the millionaires don't need to take it with them tax. How come Democrats can only come up with crap names like global warming?

6. Restore Property rights
This is an issue better handled at the state level since its those governments that will have to deal with the issue.

7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence
Then stop repealing every form of energy legislation that gets passed. Republicans have been fighting against energy independence for the last 30 years and looking on the supply side. We stop using so much, the supply will take care of itself.

8. Control Spending and Balance the Budget
Republicans love spending, it makes them look good to their constituents. Reagan always blamed the Democrats as being tax and spend but when he got a Republican Congress the spree continued. The current lot of Republicans have no idea how to shut the government's wallet.

9. Tie Education Funding to Teacher Accountability
The every child left behind program is so bass ackwards. Why the hell are we following the mold of one of the worst educational systems in the country, that of Texas?

10. Defend America From the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam
We created more terrorists in Iraq then we ever got rid of in Afghanistan. This administration has missed the mark entirely in the war on terrorism. For all their talk of blaming countries that support terror, Iran and Syria have gotten off scott free.

Brock
09-11-2006, 10:30 AM
7. Achieve Sustainable Energy Independence.

Not going to happen with the government in the pockets of the Oil Companies.

FYP