PDA

View Full Version : You rank the QBs, 1-32.


Direckshun
06-22-2007, 04:24 PM
Opening day NFL QBs.

1.) Manning - Indy
2.) Brady - NE
3.) Brees - NO
4.) Bulger - STL
5.) Palmer - CIN
6.) V. Young - TEN
7.) Romo - DAL
8.) Smith - SF
9.) Roethlisberger - PIT
10.) Hasselbeck - SEA
11.) Cutler - DEN
12.) Leinart - ARI
13.) McNabb - PHI
14.) Garcia - TB
15.) Kitna - DET
16.) Pennington - NYJ
17.) Rivers - SD
18.) Green - MIA
19.) Delhomme - CAR
20.) Favre - GB
21.) Schaub - HOU
22.) Russell - OAK
23.) Manning - NYG
24.) Croyle - KC
25.) Losman - BUF
26.) McNair - BAL
27.) Grossman - CHI
28.) Vick - ATL
29.) Frye - CLE
30.) Leftwich - JAX
31.) Campbell - WAS
32.) Jackson - MIN

kstater
06-22-2007, 04:29 PM
1. Brodie Croyle
2.-32. Who cares what they do.

Mr Luzcious
06-22-2007, 04:38 PM
Curse you kstater that is precisely what I was going to say.

JBucc
06-22-2007, 04:39 PM
I'm not going to make a list because that would take too long and a lot of it is splitting hairs. I'll just say that Brady and Manning are clearly a step above everyone else. Then their's a second teir of guys like Palmer, Bulger, Brees, Hasselbeck, maybe McNabb that put up big numbers for several years. Everything else is just a mess of above average to sucky to unkown.

ChiefaRoo
06-22-2007, 04:49 PM
1.) Manning - Indy
2.) Brady - NE
3.) Brees - NO
4.) Bulger - STL
5.) Palmer - CIN
6.) V. Young - TEN
7.) Romo - DAL
8.) Smith - SF
9.) Roethlisberger - PIT
10.) Hasselbeck - SEA
11.) Cutler - DEN
12.) Leinart - ARI
13.) McNabb - PHI
14.) Garcia - TB
15.) Kitna - DET
16.) Pennington - NYJ
17.) Rivers - SD
18.) Green - MIA
19.) Delhomme - CAR
20.) Favre - GB
21.) Schaub - HOU
22.) Russell - OAK
23.) Manning - NYG
24.) Croyle - KC
25.) Losman - BUF
26.) McNair - BAL
27.) Grossman - CHI
28.) Vick - ATL
29.) Frye - CLE
30.) Leftwich - JAX
31.) Campbell - WAS
32.) Jackson - MIN

Crashride
06-22-2007, 05:00 PM
How did croyle make it to 24 without anyone seeing him play...he should be 1

Ultra Peanut
06-22-2007, 05:10 PM
Brett Favre

FAX
06-22-2007, 05:14 PM
Swap Romo with Delhomme, Delhomme with Leinart, Rivers with Bulger, Bulger with Garcia, Favre with Jackson, and Jackson with Vick and I think you've got it, Mr. Direckshun.

FAX

Buzzsaw
06-22-2007, 06:42 PM
Rivers is a little low @17 , no?

61% completion, 3388 yards, 22 TD's, 9 INT's, 92 QB rating.

In comparison, you've got Alex Smith in the top-10 who had the following stat line last season:

58% completion, 2890 yards, 16 TD's, 16 INT's, 74.8 rating.

I understand the thread topic is a ranking based on how you think they'll fare this coming season, but what makes you think Smith will perform better in 2007 and Rivers will perform worse? 49'ers picked up virtually nothing on offense and lost Norv Turner, who is great with QB's.

Vince Young is also too high IMO. Teams have game tape on him now and he was pretty awful as a passer last season.

HolmeZz
06-22-2007, 06:55 PM
Jason Campbell's pretty good.

I don't think Croyle's done anything to prove he's been better than anybody.

58-4ever
06-22-2007, 07:38 PM
I think Croyle will be better than Eli. Count on it.