PDA

View Full Version : ****Offical "Who won this deal?" Thread****


OnTheWarpath58
09-11-2008, 09:44 PM
Might as well combine all of these in one place.

Feel free to post any deals you've made, or are looking to make.

Here's a couple of scenarios from my league:


Team A gives: Reggie Wayne, Maurice Jones Drew

Team B gives: Brandon Marshall, Matt Forte


Another:


Team A gives Reggie Wayne, Maurice Jones Drew

Team B gives Chad Johnson, Chris Johnson

Ceej
09-11-2008, 09:54 PM
In my smaller money league Colston went down. That leaves me Cotchery, Galloway, Mason, Bryant Johnson, DJ Hackett.

My RBs are Portis, Barber, TJones and Selvin Young. I'm looking to move TJones as trade bait. If you guys had to guesstimate - what prototypical WR should I get for him? I was thinking of offering him for Hines Ward. Bad - good trade?

We start 3WRs and it's .5pts a reception.

10 Team league. Here's a list of everyone's current 3 deep WRs.

Fitzgerald, Holt, Jennings
Andre Johnson, Bowe, Roddy White
TO, Roy Williams, Eddie Royal
Wayne, Coles, Stallworth
Santonio Holmes, SMoss, Ocho Cinco
Burress, Curry, Harrison
Edwards, Evans, Marshall
Boldin, Chambers, Ward
Randy Moss, Houshmanzadeh, Calvin Johnson - RBs consist of Grant, Freddy Taylor

So, what about Thomas Jones for Calvin Johnson?

OnTheWarpath58
09-11-2008, 10:01 PM
Ahem.

Please be considerate to the thread starter and weigh in on his hypotheticals when you post yours.

:D

To answer your question, I would lean towards Marshall, Jennings or Ward and see if anyone bites. I think they'll be more consistent in receptions over the long haul than CJ.

JMO.

Ceej
09-11-2008, 10:03 PM
I like what group A gets in league 1. And, Team B in league 2.

This is just based on who I think will produce more and whatnot. PPR? Keeper league?

OnTheWarpath58
09-11-2008, 10:05 PM
I like what group A gets in league 1. And, Team B in league 2.

This is just based on who I think will produce more and whatnot. PPR? Keeper league?

Standard scoring.

6 pt TD's

10 yards per point

rad
09-11-2008, 10:09 PM
Might as well combine all of these in one place.

Feel free to post any deals you've made, or are looking to make.

Here's a couple of scenarios from my league:


Team A gives: Reggie Wayne, Maurice Jones Drew

Team B gives: Brandon Marshall, Matt Forte

If I was team A, I'd do it.

Another:


Team A gives Reggie Wayne, Maurice Jones Drew

Team B gives Chad Johnson, Chris Johnson


If I was team A, no effin way.

Ceej
09-11-2008, 10:09 PM
I'll stick with what I originally said.

JAX is up in the air right now. They had an awful week. And Freddy T. had one of his best seasons to date.

So, I offered TJones for Hines Ward.


I sure hope McGahee or Selvin Young show up this week magically. Last week I won like 49 to 42, or something.

I'm 7 out of 14 in my league. The very last of the (for now) undefeateds.

But, I'll be here often sir. I'm a trade nut.

This CasinoPlanet needs night owls like you and I.

Old Dog
09-12-2008, 01:55 PM
Team B wins both of those IMO

rad
09-19-2008, 07:10 PM
Does anyone think Forte for Santonio Holmes is a good deal? If the guy that has Forte has crappy WR and the guy with Holmes has shitty RB's?

rad
09-20-2008, 08:16 AM
C'mon, what do you guys think?

FD
09-20-2008, 10:59 AM
I think Forte is worth more than Holmes. Holmes has been quiet so far and Big Ben's health is an issue. I think you can do better.

Ceej
09-23-2008, 09:34 PM
I recieved Derek Anderson, TJ Houshmanzadeh, and Steven Jackson for Ben Roethlisberger, Santonio Holmes and Chris Cooley.

Here's my team afterwards:


Derek Anderson, Matt Schaub
Selvin Young, Willis McGahee, Steven Jackson, Rudi Johnson, Hightower, Kolby Smith
Fitzgerald, Houshmanzadeh, Mason, Hackett, Deion Branch
Benjamin Watson - I desperately need to pick up a TE, or trade for one.
Rob Bironas
Pitt D, Atl D.


Thoughts?

I've also just been offered Carson Palmer, Felix Jones, for Selvin Young, Derek Anderson, Deion Branch.

Do it?