PDA

View Full Version : Would you do this trade?


Sure-Oz
08-28-2009, 08:51 AM
I have been offered

Fred Jackson RB, Jay Cutler QB, and Kevin Walter WR

for

Larry Johnson RB, Chad Pennington QB, and Josh Morgan WR


My team is as follows

QB Eli Manning, NYG QB 0.4
QB Brett Favre, Min QB 18.2
RB Steven Jackson, StL RB 100.0 +0
RB Ronnie Brown, Mia RB +0
RB/WR Eddie Royal, Den WR 100.0 +0
WR Andre Johnson, Hou WR +0
WR Anquan Boldin, Ari WR
TE Vernon Davis, SF TE
D/ST Vikings D/ST, Min D/ST 100.0 +0
K Jason Elam, Atl K

Bench Larry Johnson, KC RB 100.0 +0
Bench Braylon Edwards, Cle WR 100.0 +0
Bench Chad Pennington, Mia QB 30.0 +1.9
Bench Percy Harvin, Min WR 3
Bench Rashard Mendenhall, Pit RB 85.8 -2.4
Bench Josh Morgan, SF WR 13.7
Bench LeSean McCoy, Phi RB
IR Marshawn Lynch*, Buf RB O

There are no QB's in the league and that is my obvious weak position...and RB is kindve too

Mile High Mania
08-28-2009, 09:30 AM
Fred Jackson RB, Jay Cutler QB, and Kevin Walter WR
for
Larry Johnson RB, Chad Pennington QB, and Josh Morgan WR

I'll view it like this...

LJ > Fred Jackson
Cutler > Pennington
Walter > Morgan

So, you're upgrading at 2 of the 3 positions in my opinion. LJ (the only downgrade in this deal) is your #3 and it definitely weakens your depth until Lynch returns, and I like McCoy.

You are 3-strong at WR, and while I like Royal a lot... I have no idea what to expect with all this turmoil and I really like Walter in PPR formats. Edwards is nice as well.

I don't know that Cutler is going to be a phenom in CHI, but I think he should do better than Eli and Brett. And, you could flip one of them to upgrade at RB down the road.

I just might pull the trigger on this deal.

Sure-Oz
08-28-2009, 10:01 AM
I was thinking it was an edge too, even though i have andre johnson already...i may pull hte trigger cause my QB's are real weak an di have a feeling my backup rb's will get play sometime If Cutler was with denver this would be a no brainer for me

Sure-Oz
08-28-2009, 12:27 PM
I accepted the trade, i asked someone else and they mentioned what you did as well. should benefit me longterm