View Full Version : Football If the NFL used the BCS

11-23-2009, 12:20 PM
Thanks to Gallo over at ESPN, pretty funny:

It's late November. The NFL BCS picture is pretty much set. Let's take a look.

1. Indianapolis (10-0): There are some obvious weaknesses with the Colts. They seem beatable. But they've won every game on their schedule, won their annual rivalry game with the Patriots, and have a legitimate NFL Heisman candidate in Peyton Manning. They're in the NFL BCS title game with room to spare.

2. Minnesota (9-1): The Vikings slip in just ahead of the Saints, despite one loss, due to their far superior strength of schedule. They lost to the Steelers, but at least they had the guts to schedule a tough game on the road. The voters and the NFL BCS computer reward that.

3. New Orleans (10-0): It's tough to see the Saints miss out on playing for the national title, but look at their schedule -- who have they really beaten? With their weak schedule and the program's history, they get left out in the cold. Tough break -- but it's still been a good season, and playing for third in a prestigious NFL BCS bowl is nothing to be ashamed of. Who knows, maybe they'll even win, stay undefeated and get bumped up to second.

4. San Diego (7-3): Too little, too late for the Chargers. Five wins in a row down the stretch gets the attention of voters and moves them up into a great bowl -- but if they wanted the chance to contend for a title, they needed to avoid slipups in September. Every week in the NFL is like the playoffs. It's about the body of work, not who the best team is at the end of the season.

5. New England (7-3): It's been a nice season for the Patriots, but they had to win that game at Indianapolis to have any chance of playing for a national title. Bill Belichick gambled and lost. His parting gift is a huge NFL BCS bowl payout. The Patriots probably hoped to play for the title at the start of the year, but they'll take the money, too.

6. Cincinnati (7-3): Like the crosstown Bearcats, the Bengals had a memorable and surprising season that fans will remember forever, despite the fact they won't get to play for a national title despite winning one of the top divisions. Those are just the breaks. But the Bengals opened eyes and converted some skeptics. That could pay off in future years in the minds of voters, and maybe even get them a title shot one day. Either way, it was a positive season for the program.

7. Pittsburgh (6-4): The defending champs didn't have the season they wanted, but thanks to opening up the year at No. 1 they never dropped too far down in the polls and still will be able to slip into an NFL BCS bowl -- a respectable way to follow up a national title. This is why they are one of the best programs in the country.

8. Dallas (7-3): They may not win pretty and impress the voters with big margins of victory, but the Cowboys -- like Notre Dame -- are an established football brand, and voters usually will give them the benefit of the doubt. Just getting into the last BCS spot should be enough for Wade Phillips to keep his job.

Out of the BCS

Arizona (7-3): Missing out on a BCS bowl has to hurt, because the Cardinals have a better record than the Steelers and the same record as four of the eight teams who received bids. But Arizona strikes voters as nothing more than another high-scoring team from the West in a bad division. They have to schedule a much tougher out-of-division schedule. Who knows, maybe if there was a playoff system, the Cardinals would get to prove they are good enough to reach the title game. But that's unlikely.

beach tribe
11-23-2009, 12:23 PM
College football will never be close to my heart until the BCS is GONE, and a PO format is installed.
Can you imagine college football playoffs? It would be pandemonium. How can they not see the cash cow that it would be to make PO games bowl games.


11-23-2009, 12:27 PM
I relatively new when it comes to trying to understand the BCS; and why it's in place instead of a PO.
I'd be curious to hear the pros/cons etc