PDA

View Full Version : Football Biggest Draft Busts Pick by Pick


notorious
04-25-2011, 02:26 PM
http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/The-worst-No-7-pick-ever-Choosing-biggest-bust?urn=nfl-wp1194


The worst No. 7 pick ever? Choosing biggest busts by draft order
By Chris Chase



There's an annual debate as to which player was the biggest No. 1 draft bust in history. But what about the guys who went No. 7? Should their NFL failures not be celebrated? To remedy this, Shutdown Corner looked back through the past 25 years of draft history and selected the biggest busts at every drafting slot from No. 1 through No. 10. Think of it as an all-time mock draft of ineptitude.




1. JaMarcus Russell(notes), QB, Oakland Raiders, 2007

Russell seduced scouts with his size and arm strength, traits that were great enough to obscure other obvious facts about him, like his lack of work ethic. It's great to show up to pro day and throw the ball 70 yards down field, but to do so while overweight (like Russell did in his LSU workout) should have been a red flag. Unlike some other players on this list, Russell's bust wasn't a surprise. It was more of an inevitability.

Honorable mention: Alex Smith (2005), Tim Couch (1999), Steve Emtman (1992)



2. Ryan Leaf, QB, San Diego Chargers, 1997

Leaf won his first two games as Chargers quarterback while Peyton Manning(notes) began 0-2, a start which led to this being written in the Sept. 14, 1998 edition of the Boston Globe:

For those Indy fans keeping score, that's six interceptions in two weeks for the 22-year-old phenom, whom the Colts selected with the first overall pick in this year's draft.

Actually, they chose him over another 22-year-old "can't-miss" kid named Ryan Leaf. Manning was supposed to be the one with more savvy.

Leaf would only win two more games in the rest of his career, 139 fewer than Manning.

Honorable mention: Charles Rogers (2003), Quentin Coryatt (1992)



3. Andre Wadsworth, DE, Arizona Cardinals, 1998

You were expecting Akili Smith or Heath Shuler? Both would have been fine choices here, but we're giving the nod to Wadsworth, the former Florida State standout who only lasted three years in the league after being taken after Manning and Leaf in the '98 draft. Though injuries derailed the defensive end, who only had eight sacks during his time in Arizona, his agents didn't help either. Wadsworth held out until the day before the 1998 season opener and refused to sign a one-year, $512,000 tender three years later. He never played in the league again.

Honorable mention: Smith (1999), Shuler (1995), Bruce Pickens (1991), Alonzo Highsmith (1987)



4. Peter Warrick, WR, Cincinnati Bengals, 2000

The biggest star in the 2000 national championship game between Virginia Tech and Florida State wasn't Michael Vick(notes). It was Florida State receiver Peter Warrick, who caught six balls for 163 yards and two touchdowns and scored on a 59-yard punt return. He had flashes of that brilliance in the pros, but they were too few and far between. Warrick bounced around some professional minor leagues before hanging it up for good in 2009.

Honorable mention: Mike D. Williams (2002), Michael Westbrook (1995)



5. Curtis Enis, RB, Chicago Bears, 1998

Like Blair Thomas, Ki-Jana Carter and D.J. Dozier before him, Enis kept up the grand tradition of Penn State running back busts. In three seasons with the Bears, Enis rushed for 1,500 yards and four touchdowns. He joins fellow 1998 top-five picks Leaf and Wadsworth on our list.

Honorable mention: Trev Alberts (1994), Mike Junkin (1987)



6. Lawrence Phillips, RB, St. Louis Rams, 1996

The St. Louis Rams couldn't resist. The team knew Phillips was trouble -- he had been arrested during Nebraska's run to the national championship for throwing his girlfriend down a flight of stairs -- yet took him at No. 6 anyway. He did manage 14 touchdowns in his brief NFL career, a total which will eventually be exceeded by his number of years in prison. The former star running back is serving a 31-year sentence for a variety of offenses, including choking another girlfriend and running his car into a group of youths at a pickup football game.

Honorable mention: Pacman Jones (2005), Kelly Stouffer (1987)



7. Andre Ware, QB, Detroit Lions, 1990

Ware was a bust not because of injury or character or attitude but because he wasn't all that great an NFL prospect to begin with. The seventh pick of the 1990 draft set 29 NCAA records in his final season at the University of Houston while helming the team's prolific run-and-shoot offense. It didn't translate to the NFL. Like David Klinger before him and Colt Brennan(notes) after him, Ware was a product of a great system who couldn't replicate his success against professional defenses. He had five touchdown passes in his career, one fewer than he had in a single 1989 game against SMU.

Honorable mention: Troy Williamson(notes) (2005), Mike Mamula (1995), Reggie Rogers (1987),



8. David Terrell, WR, Chicago Bears, 2001

If Terrell was half as good as he thought he was, he'd still be in the NFL instead of flaming out after burning bridges and dropping passes during his five NFL seasons.

Honorable mention: None



9. Tommy Vardell, RB, Cleveland Browns, 1992

When your nickname is "Touchdown" there are bound to be some unrealistic expectations that accompany your NFL career. Though the former Stanford star was hardly a JaMarcus-esque bust in the NFL, he never lived up to his billing as a scoring machine.

Honorable mention: Reggie Williams(notes) (2004), Tom Knight (1997)



10. Matt Leinart(notes), QB, Arizona Cardinals, 2006

Technically, the jury is still out on Leinart. Realistically, not so much. The thing is, Leinart may have been considered an even bigger bust had he come out of school after his junior season, when he would have been the likely No. 1 pick in the 2005 draft. Instead, he came back, slipped to No. 10 after his USC Trojans lost in the national championship game to Vince Young(notes) and Texas, and was relegated to the bench during Kurt Warner's(notes) epic NFL swansong. Once Warner retired, Leinart was the presumed Cardinals starter but was passed on the depth chart by Derek Anderson(notes) and eventually cut by the team prior to last season. He signed on with the Texans and didn't play a single snap in all of 2010.

Thig Lyfe
04-25-2011, 02:35 PM
230. Matt Cassel, QB, New England Patriots, 2005

notorious
04-25-2011, 02:37 PM
230. Matt Cassel, QB, New England Patriots, 2005

That's what they get for reaching.

Just Passin' By
04-25-2011, 02:39 PM
Just the way I look at 'busts, but anytime articles like this start using injured players as 'busts', I figure it's not worth the read.

notorious
04-25-2011, 02:41 PM
I only counted one player where the injury might have changed their career in Curtis Enis.

MoreLemonPledge
04-25-2011, 02:47 PM
230. Matt Cassel, QB, New England Patriots, 2005

Yep, that was an awful pick at 230.

HotRoute
04-25-2011, 02:47 PM
Brian bozworth

Tony mandrich

Thig Lyfe
04-25-2011, 02:48 PM
Yep, that was an awful pick at 230.

They should have just passed.

KC Tattoo
04-25-2011, 03:02 PM
Even tho he was a third round pick, WTF were the Donkos thinking with Maurice Clarett rb? LMFAO, don't think he even played a down for them.

whoman69
04-25-2011, 04:22 PM
Brian bozworth

Tony mandrich
Bosworth was a supplemental draft pick.

crazycoffey
04-25-2011, 04:31 PM
granted I haven't watched a lot of the 49ers, but is Alex Smith really a "bust". I mean, I get he hasn't lived up to expectations yet....

Al Bundy
04-25-2011, 04:33 PM
Tom Knight was awful... I had completely forgotten about him, also wasn't Bruce Pickens one of the guys that got toasted in the 93 AFC Championship game?

Rain Man
04-25-2011, 04:36 PM
Just the way I look at 'busts, but anytime articles like this start using injured players as 'busts', I figure it's not worth the read.


Yeah, injuries are not busts. They may have been wasted picks, but it's not the fault of the front office unless maybe - maybe - the guy was known to be injury prone or to have some potential career-ending structural weakness.

Rams Fan
04-25-2011, 05:03 PM
granted I haven't watched a lot of the 49ers, but is Alex Smith really a "bust". I mean, I get he hasn't lived up to expectations yet....

I think Smith is a bust considering where he was picked but I think he could turn out to be a serviceable QB.

Bump
04-25-2011, 05:15 PM
Ryan sims should at least get an honorable mention

crazycoffey
04-25-2011, 05:19 PM
I think Smith is a bust considering where he was picked but I think he could turn out to be a serviceable QB.

I mean, he HAS gotten a pretty raw deal so far, IMO. coaching, philosophies, weapons etc. It would have pretty hard for tom or payton to be as successful as they are, were they put in alex's shoes....

Rams Fan
04-25-2011, 05:22 PM
I mean, he HAS gotten a pretty raw deal so far, IMO. coaching, philosophies, weapons etc. It would have pretty hard for tom or payton to be as successful as they are, were they put in alex's shoes....

I agree to some extent, but he should also be blamed for some of his failures.

The fact that Singletary pulled the plug on him and put Troy Smith in was crazy. He needs to start one full season without any injuries or someone coming into replace him(unless it's a blowout).

Graystoke
04-25-2011, 05:38 PM
Chuck Long-86 Lions-12th Overall Pick
Up-me-some-Chuck

Joe Seahawk
04-25-2011, 05:47 PM
Dan Mcgwire way waaaay worse of a pick than Rick Mirer. Mirer actually set rookie records for completions, attempts and yards, and the Seahawks ended up trading him for a first round pick..

crazycoffey
04-25-2011, 05:49 PM
I agree to some extent, but he should also be blamed for some of his failures.

The fact that Singletary pulled the plug on him and put Troy Smith in was crazy. He needs to start one full season without any injuries or someone coming into replace him(unless it's a blowout).


naturally I agree in personal accountability... It's still been a pretty uphill battle. I wish we had gotten him somehow, instead of Matt, and seen what todd's structure, and charlie could have done with him up to this point. I personally think we'd be happy chiefs fans for the first time in a long time, with our QB.

Graystoke
04-25-2011, 05:51 PM
Dan Mcgwire way waaaay worse of a pick than Rick Mirer. Mirer actually set rookie records for completions, attempts and yards, and the Seahawks ended up trading him for a first round pick..

Two Iowa players. Two bad draft picks.

Rausch
04-25-2011, 05:57 PM
http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/The-worst-No-7-pick-ever-Choosing-biggest-bust?urn=nfl-wp11946. Lawrence Phillips, RB, St. Louis Rams, 1996

I think this one should be higher due to the total clusterfuck he was.

That wasn't just a bust on the field, not just problems off the field, it was a total pie-in-the-face circus that seemed to never end...

notorious
04-25-2011, 05:58 PM
I think this one should be higher due to the total cluster**** he was.

That wasn't just a bust on the field, not just problems off the field, it was a total pie-in-the-face circus that seemed to never end...

Gotta love Dick Vermeil. The guy had a heart of gold.