PDA

View Full Version : Ripped sign spurs national debate


Hel'n
09-18-2004, 11:01 PM
By JIM ROSS - The Herald-Dispatch

HUNTINGTON -- Barboursville resident Phil Parlock and his children became national celebrities in the world of Internet blogging and conservative talk radio on Friday.

A Bush-Cheney campaign sign yanked from the hands of 3-year-old Sophia Parlock and ripped into pieces was the focus of all the attention. The incident occurred Thursday evening at Tri-State Airport during Democratic vice presidential candidate John Edwards’ campaign stop.

Republican supporters all over the Internet on Friday were saying Parlock was merely a Republican exercising his First Amendment rights, set upon by Democratic thugs.

Meanwhile, Democratic bloggers questioned whether Parlock staged the event that sent Sophia into tears as a news photographer captured her distress. Some even called him a serial protester and a bad parent for putting his daughter in harm’s way.

Edwards arrived around 5:20 p.m. and was met by about 200 supporters. He was at the airport to leave the area following a two-day campaign swing.

In the crowd were Phil Parlock, Sophia, Philip Parlock II, 21, and Alex, 11.

The Parlock family held signs supporting the Republican ticket of President George W. Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney. That was no surprise, as Parlock is a strong Republican. He has never held public office, although has run for the Cabell County Board of Education four times.

Phil Parlock said someone took the Bush-Cheney sign from Sophia’s hands, causing her to cry. Her emotion was caught by Herald-Dispatch photographer Randy Snyder, who was working on a free-lance assignment for The Associated Press. The Washington Times saw the AP photo and called Parlock on Thursday evening to talk about the incident. Before midnight, the photo was on the Internet.

By morning, it was on the Drudge Report.

Friday morning, conservative talk radio shows in Seattle, San Diego and other places had interviewed Parlock. Talk show host Glenn Beck interviewed him on the air twice. Columnist Michelle Malkin called.

"They’re all saying the same thing: This is horrible, deplorable," Parlock said Friday.

"We didn’t go there to make a scene. We stood there silently. We want to be in the background. We want to change people’s minds."

But several Democratic-oriented Web sites, such as democraticunderground.com, picked up on the story, too, and bloggers started doing some research into Parlock’s background. They found news articles showing he had claimed to have been assaulted at Democratic events in 2000 and 1996.

They also compared a Parlock family portrait with the photo of Sophia crying and suggested that one of Parlock’s own children was the sign grabber.

"No. No," Parlock said. "The printers’ union thug? How can I get away with that in a small town? That is not my son there."

The person that many Democrats said was Parlock’s son wore a T-shirt suggesting he is a member of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, AFL-CIO. Friday afternoon, James A. Williams, general president of the union, issued a statement apologizing to the Parlock family.

The incident at the airport "is an affront to everything we, as a union, pride ourselves to represent," Williams’ statement said.

"I have personally taken steps to address this issue internally, and will take immediate disciplinary action to the fullest extent allowed under U.S. Department of Labor regulations and the constitution of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades."

Lois Pauley of Huntington said she saw part of the incident at the airport. Pauley said she was there with her father, sister and son.

"At first he was being quiet and nice," she said of Parlock’s actions. Parlock was not being rude or obtrusive, Pauley said.

As Edwards neared the spot where Parlock stood, he reached into his pants legs and removed his Bush-Cheney signs, Pauley said.

Some materials, such as large handbags, umbrellas and signs, were banned from the event. The only signs that were allowed by the Kerry-Edwards campaign staff were the signs the campaign itself provided.

"The only thing I saw that happened was I saw people trying to cover up his signs with Edwards signs," Pauley said. She said she saw Parlock hoist Sophia onto his shoulders so she could hold a Bush-Cheney sign above the crowd.

Pauley said she moved away from Parlock at that point because she feared something bad was about to happen.

Near dusk Friday, Parlock was still taking calls from reporters.

"I am completely overwhelmed. I had no idea. We don’t go for the press. We go for the message," he said.

http://www.herald-dispatch.com/2004/September/18/LNtop1.htm

Michael Michigan
09-18-2004, 11:29 PM
Damn old media is slow.

THE LEFT IS DESPERATE FOR A HOAX
By Michelle Malkin · September 17, 2004 01:14 PM

Just got off the phone with Phil Parlock, who is amused by desperate liberal rumor-mongering that the man wearing an IUPAT t-shirt and holding a piece of his little girl's Bush/Cheney sign is his own son.

"That's ridiculous. This is a small town," Parlock told me from his home in Huntington, W. Virginia. "Everyone would recognize him."

Parlock and his daughter were surrounded by a group of about five or six nasty pro-Kerry folks, two or three of whom wore IUPAT shirts. He received a voice mail from the president of the IUPAT, whose apology (as noted below) is here. Am waiting for a call back from IUPAT president James Williams.

IUPAT members, by the way, were involved in a previous sign-tearing incident involving Parlock and his family, according to Parlock.

Meanwhile, Parlock's toddler is fine.

It's pathetic that lefty bloggers would smear Parlock and his children so quickly without bothering to check. Rathergate must be really getting to them.

Update: Captain Ed remains skeptical:

[T]he family history of victimization at Democratic rallies looks awfully suspicious, as does bringing a 3-year-old to an oppo rally.

Good running commentary at Dislogue, including links to a Glenn Beck interview with Phil Parlock.

I talked with the press person for the IUPAT, who says its local shop in Huntington is currently conducting an investigation of the individuals involved. We will be keeping in touch. The union deserves praise for its strongly-worded statement condemning any act of violence/disruption committed in its name.

And let me state for the record: If the union or I or anyone else finds out that this was staged, I will be the loudest to condemn Parlock and will send an apology and a dozen roses to Attaturk at Rising Hegemon.

http://michellemalkin.com/archives/000535.htm

Duck Dog
09-20-2004, 08:48 AM
By JIM ROSS - The Herald-Dispatch


Meanwhile, Democratic bloggers questioned whether Parlock staged the event that sent Sophia into tears as a news photographer captured her distress. Some even called him a serial protester and a bad parent for putting his daughter in harm’s way.

1. I wonder if the libs think meme is bad parent for taking her kids to protests and rally’s? Or the many, many other libs that bring their kids to protests and rally’s?

2. I didn't realize going to liberal rally could actually be labeled dangerous. But by the libs own words, apparently it is.