Completely valid like the pre-2008 statistic that indicated that no black man could ever be elected President because it had never happened? We have an extremely small sample size of SB Champion coaches moving on to different teams and it's hard for any coach to win a SB in the first place.

There are only 18 SB Champion coaches in the first place (out of hundreds of coaches who have tried) and only 9 of those moved on to coach a second team.

Only SOFTER...

And even then, Hillary was the front runner all the way until almost the end.

Believing that it CAN happen and believing that it WILL happen are two different things.

Possibility <> probability

I'm not interested in completely ignoring history.

Dungy who's won playoff games and a superbowl is Marty and Cowher who's 59 games over .500 in his head coaching career is overrated?


..... wow

I don't get that either. He turned around 1 inept team and with the help of Peyton made the Colts SB contenders every year. Yeah he is conservative as **** and the Tampa 2 D is dead but he is still a very good coach.

Seriously. I would take either of those guys in a landslide over Norv, and if I were a Chiefs fan, I'd be celebrating if they replaced Crennell with Dungy or Cowher.

Dungy won a Super Bowl because of Peyton Manning.

Cowher won a Super Bowl because of Ben Roethlisberger.

Marty won a Super Bowl...oh wait, nevermind.

DO WE WANT TO WIN REGULAR SEASON GAMES OR DO WE WANT TO WIN A GODDAMN ****ING SUPER BOWL?!?!?!?!?!

Eh... Dungy? Eew. Cowher though, yeah.

ROFL

That's like a living contradiction.

Shannahan won super bowls because of elway, coughlin because of manning, belicheck Brady. You can make that argument with any coach. BTW big Ben was shit in that super bowl game so to say they won it all because of him isn't exactly correct.

Yes I want to win a super bowl but you have to have a guy who can get you there. Cowher can.

As a horrible 2nd year player.

That's bush league...

Dungy can't. And that was the original point.

He doesn't win a Super Bowl without Big Ben.

But as Billay said, at least Cowher could GET THERE. Dungy couldn't even do that.

Cowher went to 4 AFCC games.

He more than got there.

Cowher/Pitt became a lesser version of the Bills...

John Fox is a good coach. Dick Vermeil is a good coach. Dan Reeves is a good coach.

As much as it pains me to say it, Bill Cowher is a good coach.

All of those guys built teams that could make it all the way to the Super Bowl without a franchise QB. Once they found their franchise QB, they won it all.

Tony Dungy is not one of them and doesn't belong in that discussion.