dude had an elite deep ball and people are in here comparing him to cassel LMAO

sad

PS - Aikman MADE every receiver on those teams not named Irvin

I haven't read too much of this thread but are we really comparing Aikman/Elway to Alex Smith?


LMAO

that's the crazy 49er cat lady way

A hall of famer.

You Alex Smith assholes have me defending the Antichrist John ****ing Elway.

ROFL

Not even close. I bet you were the kind of guy saying Larry Johnson is better than Priest Holmes, too. What next, Kelce > Gonzalez?

Jimmy Johnson's Cowboys were the last of the stacked dominant teams that could be bought before the salary cap put an end to that.

All I know is that Alvin Harper was complete shit when he went to Tampa. I get the feeling Novacek would have been a JAG without Aikman throwing it and Irvin commanding double teams.

this is what Alex Smith would have been if he had been an NFL player in 1993:

http://www.gannett-cdn.com/-mm-/70cd...NSIVE-PATS.jpg

And the absolute best-case scenario for that era:

http://sports-kings.com/wp-content/u...rk-Brunell.jpg

Typical Clay to return to the thread when his fellow asshats arrive

Clay you opened up an account over at The Mane last season when you got banned and were shit talking on CP and the fan base, why don't you go back?

Troy Aikman's YPA rankings, 1991-1995 (best years of his career, the reason he's in the HO****ingF)

#4
#8
#2
#2
#4

I'm sure one of these days Alex will get above league average, though.

Comparing Alex Smith to John Elway.

Man, I've seen it all now.

Wrap your simple brain onto the reality that people are only pointing out that those two QBs can be highly overrated.

Can't really compare them to Alex, because their are so many differing variables between them.. and no one's really been trying to compare them.

What would have been intriguing, is to wonder how Smith would have performed had he been silver-spooned like that... but it's pure conjecture, and not really worth more than a momentary thought.

idiot

Novacek played with the Cardinals before signing with Dallas.
http://www.pro-football-reference.co...N/NovaJa00.htm