Roughly half his games in KC would be under snowy conditions?

Name the last real snow game in KC (not flurries... a legit SNOW game).

Barkley has experience playing in cold weather games... it was 30 degrees with a wind chill when Barkley dismantled Oregon's defense in Oregon a few weeks back.

This "Barkley can't play in cold weather" crap is complete bullshit.

Also it's not as if RGIII has a long history of playing in snowy conditions. He played high school and college football in Texas.

I love it when the Planet rallies behind a QB and defends the player as if they have no faults - it's so Sanchez and Clausen.

:facepalm:

Yeah, one thing Elway lacked was arm strength to overcome that factor.

Same goes for Aaron Rogers.

Or Brett Favre.

Or Matt Stafford.

Funny that those are the only examples people have brought up in this topic...all of them had full blown howlitzers.

Look, I dont know how many times I have to say this...Im not saying it could totally ruin his chances at being successful in the midwest, Im just saying that its one of the factors that will likely be looked into if he is to be drafted in the top 5 by a team in the states where weather is a big factor.

i love reading idiots talking about how playing in California means a QB can't handle cold weather....

it ranks right up there with not liking a QB because of his haircut...you know, wind resistance or something...

it's not one of the top 100000000000000000000 factors....good grief

just ****ing stop....please

This thread has taken a turn for the bizarre, and I disagree with Boss's analysis, but I'll give him credit for at least offering to critique a player.

For all the bitching about "drafturbators" there are far, far more chickenshit mother****ers who do nothing but go with the prevailing wind and bash whoever it is convenient to bash, whether it's a poster, the GM, the QB, et. al.

Fritz88's worthless ass comes to mind.

The "critique" you are having a wet dream over is completely baseless and full of bullshit.

"Half of the home games in KC would be in snowy conditions"? Name the last legit snow game in KC.

Also the same cold weather concerns could be applied to RGIII who has played both his high school and collegiate football in the state of Texas. Last I checked Texas wasn't Alaska.

What the **** are you talking about? Did I give that form of analysis one ounce of credibility or indicate an agreement with it at all?

What grade did you flunk out of? Jesus.

I make one comment and stand by it and all of a sudden Im a moron and and idiot.

Go **** yourself and your inability to talk about any of the faults (or even possible faults) of players you have fallen in love with.

If Im so wrong, surely you can back your side of this with something...anything other than personal insults....or maybe you CANT.

Like I said, you guys are making a mountain out of a mohill.

I get bashed all the time i'll gladly fall on the sword for Barkley. That's my QB http://static.bbmp3.com/smilies/sadto.gif

He either has the arm strength or he doesn't. He's either a pussy or he isn't.

If he's so much of a ****ing chickenshit that he can't play in cold weather, there would be numerous other pieces of evidence of his deadly disease of pussitis; it wouldn't be isolated.

Did you forget what you posted?

YOUR words:

You are giving credit for a critique that is completely baseless and full of bullshit.

You obviously give credit rather easily. Do you give credit to Palko for trying to be a QB?

i'm making fun of you for offering up one of the dumbest ways to criticize a player in human ****ing history...

stop it

don't ever say it again....EVER...it is that ****ing stupid

as for Barkley's weaknesses, anyone can google and find scouting reports that list his stengths and weaknesses....and guess what, none of them mention his inability to throw a football in -50 degree weather...

I don't like Kellen Moore because of all the traveling Boise State has to do. That's a lot of flying. What if one of the planes broke in two in mid-air?