![]() |
^ That's where GMDM should be (and I'm assuming) at. Come on guys. Danny Duffy is not a long term "prospect" any more. He's a guy. With Talent. That's it
|
He's the oldest of the bunch pitching wise, flip him
|
There's got to be an alternative to improving the staff by flipping Duffy plus other pieces for a half season of Cueto. It's a logical move in a lot of respects. You need an ace or a guy with ace upside to get you through a month of high pressure baseball.
But at the same time, getting a Cueto feels like it would end up a lot like how Lester's stint with the A's went last year. Surely you can get a good percentage of the upside Cueto gets you with a guy that's more akin to a "dust a guy off from the heap and put him in a position to win with an All-Star defense behind him" type... right? EDIT: **** it. Get Fiers out of Milwaukee because YOLO. |
Quote:
That's my thing with him. He's inexperienced on the field but not a youngster anymore...he's 26 & not 23 as his experience would make you think he is with 368 innings. |
I don't think I did an adequate job of explaining why I think this trade is not exciting, here lets try again.
We all seem to agree that SP is our biggest problem, and if we are going to improve the team, thats what we need to focus on. We got sidetracked into arguing whether there is something magical about having an ace. Some of you seem to think our biggest problem is #1, but I believe our biggest problem is good, quality depth #1 through 3/4, and if we don't do anything or if we just replace one of our top guys, then we're not fixing that problem at all. We'd be counting on Medlen in a big way if we either did nothing or made this trade. Hopefully Medlen will come through, but I don't like counting on that and right now Duffy is not our #4 or #5 starter. I know we have to be careful with removing bad starts because we can play that game all day, but Duffy was terrible in May and then out for a while with an injury. If you presume he's fixed whatever his problem was and take away May, then he's one of our top 3 starting pitchers. He's probably our #2 right now, and in a 5/7-game series he is probably starting two games. Cueto can't pitch every day, with this trade you are only replacing those 2 Duffy starts, and you are still counting on Volquez and whoever. Whatever you think about Young or Ventura, we are still badly shallow after this hypothetical trade. Replacing a guy who we probably need in the playoffs with someone else is not very exciting, compared to keeping Duffy AND adding someone like Cueto for some VERY badly-needed depth and insurance. If the goal is to win this year, then it makes a lot more sense to deal away one of our "untouchable" prospects to win this year than Duffy. |
I agree with al and have been saying as much for a while. I don't think we are going to trade for a pitcher anyways, but I am supremely confident we won't trade Duffy.
|
If we don't trade Duffy then the Reds will probably want a package of Mondesi, Finnegan & Dozier for Cueto.
|
Quote:
I don't care much about ERAs with the starting pitchers on this team. The reason is that the guys with the low ERAs eat lots of innings, while ours are not doing that so much right now. But for this team, especially in the playoffs, an innings eater is almost irrelevant because we are not going to hide our bullpen. We want to feature our bullpen. If any one of our guys pitches to the lead after 5 or 6 innings, we are most likely winning that game. We don't need a starter who can then pitch the 7th and 8th because those spots are already on lockdown. It would be nice for a starter to do that, but we don't NEED it. Which is why I don't think trading Duffy for Cueto gives us much, if any, benefit or gain. If Cueto goes 7 innings and two runs but Duffy only goes 6 innings for two runs we have not gained much, if anything, by losing Duffy. Obviously though if we can get Cueto without losing any MLB guys that is fine. I just don't think we will do that because GMDM is going to continue to trust his process and the moves he made, specifically that Medlen will be like our trade for a starting pitcher. |
From a MLB writer Richard Justice
Here's the interesting part: Despite all that pitching, Moore is checking to see if there are top-of-the-rotation arms available. His shopping list surely includes Shields, Johnny Cueto and David Price, but it's unclear if any of them will be moved. He also has the depth to add a bat, and if the Padres decide to trade Justin Upton, the Royals almost certainly will be interested. |
Quote:
|
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr"><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Royals?src=hash">#Royals</a> recall LHP John Lamb as the 26th man for today's split doubleheader. Lamb is 9-1 with a 2.68 ERA with Omaha this year.</p>— Royals (@Royals) <a href="https://twitter.com/Royals/status/622048610843144192">July 17, 2015</a></blockquote>
<script async src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script> |
2 Attachment(s)
My thoughts from the NWA game last night:
1) Raul Mondesi looks really good. Hitting, defense, baserunning - it looks like he has all the tools. He also laid down a perfect sacrifice bunt, so he'll be great for Ned. 2) Terrance Gore is incredibly fast. I can't wait till this guy gets back up just so we can watch him run the bases again. He bunted for a hit and beat the throw by about a full second. 3) Cody Reed got shelled, but he showed some good stuff. He retired the first 10 batters and then collapsed after that. He was hitting 95-96 consistently. I noticed him hit 97 at least once. 4) Bubba Starling had a great night. He had two hard-hit doubles into the gap and showed good speed. |
*** Official Royals Repository, Part 3 ***
http://www.forbes.com/sites/maurybro...r-programming/
Quote:
|
Duffy is a good comp to Danny Jackson in terms of style and stuff. But not even close in terms of actual production. DJ was 23 in 1985 and in the playoffs he threw 26 IP of 1.07 ERA ball, 19-6 ratio. He tossed the huge 2-0 shutout in Game 5 vs Toronto (down 3-1) and then a complete game in the 6-1 win over STL also in Game 5. I'd eat my own vomit if Danny Duffy ever threw a single complete game, let alone pitching like that.
DJ avg 206 IP his 3 years here with an avg WAR of 4.1. Duffy in his 4 years avg 75 IP (with a TJ surgery the main cause) and he ha a total WAR of 3.8 including 2015, his fifth year. He isn't remotely close to DJ in durability and that's a big reason he's really not 1/10th as valuable as many of you think |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:53 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.