ChiefsPlanet

ChiefsPlanet (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/index.php)
-   Nzoner's Game Room (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Royals 2010 Kansas City Royals Repository thread (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=221199)

Demonpenz 08-05-2010 08:24 PM

step up? for what? They front office has to do jack shit, they know people go to the games not for the team, just for social aspect and party. Then they rake in the money for luxury tax. Hell stepping up to front office just means making more money.

CaliforniaChief 08-05-2010 09:45 PM

Minor League Update (Since our AAAA team is off tonight):

Wilmington
Colon 1/4 (2B)
Myers 3/4 (2B), 2 R, RBI

Northwest Arkansas
Hosmer 0/4, K (Wow, he sucks) :D

Omaha
Moose 0/4
Jai Miller homered again.

Pretty quiet night.

duncan_idaho 08-05-2010 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CaliforniaChief (Post 6918094)
Agreed. And we can have someone in the HR Derby at the K in 2012.

Adding him would give us a respectable order:

1. De Jesus (CF)
2. Aviles (2B)
3. Butler (1B)
4. Dunn (RF)
5. Kila (DH)
6. Moustakas (3B)
7. Gordon (LF)
8. Pena (C) Lucas May?
9. Colon (SS)

And wait for Hosmer to take Kila's place, Myers to take Pena's.

Have you watched Adam Dunn play the outfield? He's absolutely horrible (hasn't played an inning there this year).

And I have to lol a little at Deez calling Billy Butler "Butterball" while drooling over all 6'6 290 of Adam Dunn. He's not exactly the most slender guy these days either...

Dunn is a premium home run hitter and walk drawer. He's also a premium strikeout maker. What he isn't is a premium run producer.

I don't know if you're talking about me, siberian. I'm not a big Dunn fan and I'm sure I was outspoken about that. Don't remember the exact conversation, but I would probably have talked about how bad he was defensively, how many of his HR were solo shots, his poor average with RISPs, and his poor overall run production relative to his HR totals. He's also a notoriously bad hitter with RISP.

I think he's a good player. I know sabermatricians love him. I think sabermetrics are important. But I think a purely sabermetric view overstates Dunn's worth. He's so worthless against lefties, he's a pretty easy out in important late situations against teams with decent lefties in the pen. That hurts his overall value. He doesn'y hit with RISP, and his heavy reliance on HR and walks hurts his run production overall. Throw in his lack of speed and horrible glove and his age/size, and I think you're talking about a dangerous guy to throw a huge offer at.

Anyway, signing Dunn would mean either Billy or Kila is traded in the offseason (or Kila gets to spend another season in Omaha...) in my mind. Can't see that happening.

DeezNutz 08-05-2010 11:33 PM

I'll take The Donkey over Butterball in the octagon every single day.

And I'll take a guy who puts a heavy reliance on walks and HRs. Those are ok qualities for me. If we're talking about his relative worth to a team, the pressure he would take off of Butterball and Moosetacos would more than make up for other weaknesses in his game.

He's not a perfect player. Far from it. But he makes much sense for KC. No worries, though, since DM is a blathering ****ing fool when it comes to ML roster management. I fully expect Bloomquist's smaller, yet older brother on Target-brand hGH (note lack of caps) for $15M per.

ChiefsCountry 08-05-2010 11:39 PM

Is the plan for Hosmer to play RF or what?

DeezNutz 08-05-2010 11:42 PM

1B.

BWillie 08-05-2010 11:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Demonpenz (Post 6919475)
step up? for what? They front office has to do jack shit, they know people go to the games not for the team, just for social aspect and party. Then they rake in the money for luxury tax. Hell stepping up to front office just means making more money.

Dude, the Royal's are in Kansas City. They aren't going to spend. They can't spend. Yeah, they could, but they won't because the owner would screw themselves if they did. The point of owning a baseball team is to make money. You think Glass makes as much money as the teams spending all the money like NYY, Boston etc? Hell no.

The Royals are 19th in payroll this year out of 30 teams. That is about as much as you can ask for when your market is Kansas City. The Royals have to utilize the farm system, and then when it's time, supplement them with a few nice free agents. That is all you can do.

duncan_idaho 08-05-2010 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeezNutz (Post 6919754)
I'll take The Donkey over Butterball in the octagon every single day.

And I'll take a guy who puts a heavy reliance on walks and HRs. Those are ok qualities for me. If we're talking about his relative worth to a team, the pressure he would take off of Butterball and Moosetacos would more than make up for other weaknesses in his game.

He's not a perfect player. Far from it. But he makes much sense for KC. No worries, though, since DM is a blathering ****ing fool when it comes to ML roster management. I fully expect Bloomquist's smaller, yet older brother on Target-brand hGH (note lack of caps) for $15M per.

He only makes sense for KC if you're OK with playing him in the OF, though. And if you thought watching Guillen play right was bad... you haven't watched Dunn play much OF (would be hard this year, anyway - hasn't played a single game there for Washington).

I mean, if you trade Ka'ahuie or Butler in the offseason, sure, Dunn makes sense (though I think $15 million is the absolute cap of his value, considering his size, age and limitations as a fielder/runner/run producer). Trading Butler after this season would be bad (you'd be selling low). And how is it going to be received if Kila rakes enough over the next few months only to be traded away?

BWillie 08-05-2010 11:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho (Post 6919747)
Have you watched Adam Dunn play the outfield? He's absolutely horrible (hasn't played an inning there this year).

And I have to lol a little at Deez calling Billy Butler "Butterball" while drooling over all 6'6 290 of Adam Dunn. He's not exactly the most slender guy these days either...

Dunn is a premium home run hitter and walk drawer. He's also a premium strikeout maker. What he isn't is a premium run producer.

I don't know if you're talking about me, siberian. I'm not a big Dunn fan and I'm sure I was outspoken about that. Don't remember the exact conversation, but I would probably have talked about how bad he was defensively, how many of his HR were solo shots, his poor average with RISPs, and his poor overall run production relative to his HR totals. He's also a notoriously bad hitter with RISP.

I think he's a good player. I know sabermatricians love him. I think sabermetrics are important. But I think a purely sabermetric view overstates Dunn's worth. He's so worthless against lefties, he's a pretty easy out in important late situations against teams with decent lefties in the pen. That hurts his overall value. He doesn'y hit with RISP, and his heavy reliance on HR and walks hurts his run production overall. Throw in his lack of speed and horrible glove and his age/size, and I think you're talking about a dangerous guy to throw a huge offer at.

Anyway, signing Dunn would mean either Billy or Kila is traded in the offseason (or Kila gets to spend another season in Omaha...) in my mind. Can't see that happening.

Jose Guillen makes $12,000,000 this year.

Adam Dunn makes $12,000,000 this year.

Just thought I'd point that out.

DeezNutz 08-05-2010 11:47 PM

I'm completely good on revisiting this entire conversation based on Kila's performance, but it's been made abundantly clear that DM values him only slightly higher than the bat boy.

What I don't want to see is Aviles II, and the problem is that we won't have a large enough sample size to know exactly what we have, most likely. In short, we've completely wasted the 2010 season.

What we know is that Dunn will supply a shit ton of power and walks. With very important young players coming up in the next season or two, we need his skill set. We absolutely must have a legit #4 so that our (young) foundational players don't press.

BWillie 08-05-2010 11:53 PM

BTW, Dunn can't be THAAAT bad at driving in runs in scoring position. Sure, with his power numbers it could be better. But the guy had 105 RBI's last year (currently 7th in RBI's in the NL) and you can rest assured that pitchers really don't want to throw to him when runners are on. The Royals haven't had a guy with 105 RBI's in a decade. Know who the last person to do it was? Carlos Beltran.

Mecca 08-05-2010 11:58 PM

I posted numerous times that the Royals should sign Dunn when he was a FA...I see Duncan is still saying the same shit today he did then.

duncan_idaho 08-06-2010 12:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BWillie007 (Post 6919785)
BTW, Dunn can't be THAAAT bad at driving in runs in scoring position. Sure, with his power numbers it could be better. But the guy had 105 RBI's last year (currently 7th in RBI's in the NL) and you can rest assured that pitchers really don't want to throw to him when runners are on. The Royals haven't had a guy with 105 RBI's in a decade. Know who the last person to do it was? Carlos Beltran.

He's a career .231 hitter with RISP (and last year hit a career-high .283). He's one of the worst "run producers" in the league with a runner at 3B/less than two outs. (This is a guy who has like 20 sac flies in his entire career, btw). Not exactly the type of hitter who's going to take pressure to produce off the guys behind him (though he certainly would protect Butler quite adequately).

His skills are hitting HRs and drawing walks. He's good enough at those things to be a good MLB player.

I'd be open to signing him (at a reasonable price in the $12-15 range), but it's going to require trading Kila or Butler to make room for him.

Mecca 08-06-2010 12:11 AM

Let's be fair there's no chance we sign him, Dayton Moore doesn't like players that know how to take pitches.

duncan_idaho 08-06-2010 12:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecca (Post 6919793)
I posted numerous times that the Royals should sign Dunn when he was a FA...I see Duncan is still saying the same shit today he did then.

I still think he's a great piece if he's not your primary guy. I still think his value is overstated if you don't have a consistent run producers to protect him (because he takes so many walks with RISP, the onus to produce often falls on the guys hitting behind him).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.