When people are posting that Siler misses 1 tackle in every 141 attempts and Johnson misses 1 tackle every 104 attempts, BlackBob is not the one getting smashed.

Also, tackle numbers along don't prove you're a good tackler. They just prove you're prolific. Those aren't necessarily the same thing.

I agree that his homer argument is pretty ****ing stupid, though.

How many pro bowls does siler have?

Other things Siler is better at than DJ:

Tetris
sitting on benches
blowing out achilles
making it rain at Hooters
signing vet minimum contracts
impressing morons
folding laundry
picking up gum wrappers at arrowhead
getting cut
carrying DJ's helmet

Siler's achilles weeps at this thread.

Yeah but he still misses tackles. I never said he shouldn't be on the field. I just said Siler is a better tackler. That means nothing to me.

Siler played in the SEC where everyone can tackle.

Then DJ shouldn't miss more tackles by their logic right? Then why did he?

Uh, do you even realize what 141 vs 104 means?

It means Brandon Siler misses one tackle every two games, more or less, if he was a starter.

It means Derrick Johnson misses one tackle every two games.

It's a negligible difference.

And since Brandon Siler hasn't played more than 387 snaps in a season the last FOUR ****ING YEARS, using missed tackle stats to elevate him over DJ, who plays 1,000 snaps a year, is pretty clueless.

It's worse than that. He's Belcher's scrub backup.

Did you see what pestilence posted?

Its all about the stops....

siler is a backup for a reason. He isn't too good.

I know you probably don't see all the games, but this is a case of the numbers not relating the truth, IMO.

DJ gets to a lot of players and gets his hands on them a lot when a guy like siler would have never gotten close...
Posted via Mobile Device

DJ is a better player. He just isn't as good of a tackler. If you think he is, then bet me.

He didnt -

they both had about 1 missed tackle for every 10 they made

DJ missed three more tackles than ray in 200 more attempts.

Ray was worse last year, I don't see how you can debate that...
Posted via Mobile Device

Black Knob polisher is either amazingly dense, or this is the most successful troll performance ever.

NO SHIT. I have been saying that the whole time. McGraw was a better tackler than Lewis but, guess what? I wanted Lewis to start.

It is not uncommon for back ups to be better at fundamentals than starters. NFL starters are generally play makers. That's what makes them the best of the best.

Where is the evidence that Brandon Siler is a good tackler?