Well we're talking about things like "clutch plays" and "poise". Those types of things are a matter of inches.
I gleefully remember when Merriman caught Peyton by the shoe to end a potential game winning drive and I remember the Tyree play where it seemed like Eli's ass was grass twice before he chucked up the rainbow that landed on Tyree's head. Are you chalking up Eli's "poise" to talent as opposed to luck? Statistically, it’s not close. Peyton wins. I’m of the opinion that Eli has an enormous horse shoe lodged up his ass. Sometimes I wonder if you head is up yours.:D

Hopefully Denver doesnt go to the playoffs (obviously), but chances are if the donkeys play decent and Pey Pey stays healthy they will. It's sad but true, the Colts did it too many times not to deny that.

But I'm relieved knowing once they get there they don't have a prayer as Peyton is clearly the biggest choke artist in the "All Time Greatest" conversation.

Your arguments are not logical. Logic is little tweeting bird chirping in meadow. Logic is wreath of pretty flowers that smell bad.

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3591/...4b2051d7ff.jpg

I get it.

You're butthurt that Eli spurned your Chargers.

But the fact is, and I've told your dumb ass this before, Eli made that Tyree play.

The only ****ing reason people remember Tyree is the fact that he caught that ball with the help of his helmut.

They don't remmember that Eli escaped a certain sack and was able to get his head downfield to see an open receiver then threw a great pass that should have been an easy catch if Tyree doesn't **** up and bobble to begin with.

JFC.

And when you talk about luck if you make one or two big plays over the course of a couple of playoff seasons, then you might be able to attribute it to luck.

But when you do it again and again, and again, there's more than luck involved.

Eli just keeps making huge plays in huge moments.

I'll openly admit I didn't like what Eli did in that draft but I'm still a rational football fan.
I'd mentioned in my post that Eli escaped 2 certain sacks. The question was do you chalk that up to talent or luck?

JFC.

Did Eli ever toss a game costing pick-6 in a SB game? I know his brother did which is one reason why Eli has 2 SB rings to Peyton's 1.

I chalk it up to toughness, desire, and the will to never give up.

What about the pass to manningham? As good a it gets, especially at crunch time
Posted via Mobile Device

Nope, its luck. /bitter bolt fan

Bottom line. Is Eli more talented than Peyton?

In the post season, he is.

I'd rather have Eli in the postseason.

Of course not.

But if talent was all it took to win championships, then Jeff George would be considered by everyone as one of the greatest QB ever, while Johnny Unitas would be sitting on his couch at home talking about his semi-pro football glory days.

I don't think there is a GM out there that would choose a 22 year old Eli over a 22 year old Peyton.

Eli is clutch, great. But so is Paul Pierce and nobody would choose Paul Pierce over LeBron.