![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Nothing happened to the $1 but bad math. |
Quote:
Again, friction forces don't really enter into it. You WANT high friction, but whatever friction you have is going to apply equally to the wheels and the treadmill. The operative variable is resistance to the treadmill spinning freely. |
Quote:
He gave each back $1 (x3) = $30 total. Nothing to see here. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The original question is flawed (presumably by design). |
Quote:
For dragging you want low. For rolling you want high. |
I think orange and I have fundamental differences in how we each view this scenario, so keep that in mind as you are discussing this with us.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
For the wheels to keep up, they MUST roll or slide along the ground (unless you have a hopping plane). Once you generate enough speed to produce lift, you can then, well, "lift" them off the ground. |
Quote:
(large positive number) / (mass of jet) = acceleration Lets say after 1 second, the jet is moving at 1 mph. Jet speed 1 mph and gaining. Wheel speed 1 mph. Treadmill speed = 0. Now start your treadmill. Run it at 100 mph. Jet speed 1 mph and gaining. Wheel speed 101 mph. Treadmill speed = 100 mph. Double the speed of the tread mill, same thing. Meanwhile, the jet just keeps on picking up speed relative to the ground. The tread mill is just making the jet wheel free spin. The force of the engines cannot practically be overcome by spinning the wheels faster. Just like you can't break the rope by spinning the treadmill faster under the shopping cart. You just can't generate the force. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
You view the hypothetical as inviolable, the way you read the wording the airplane CANNOT be allowed to move forward or the conveyor is failing in it's [ambiguously] stated mission. If a plane can't move forward it can't take off. And if it takes wheels with Herculean rolling resistance sufficient to counteract the thrust of 4 jumbo jet engines so be it. However, hypotheticals generally assume [unless stated otherwise] negligible or no friction [rolling resistance]. And in that case the interactions of the wheels and the conveyor are akin to those of molecules flowing under a flying craft or in the water or ice under skids or pontoons on a thusly equipped craft, and they are irrelevant in the dominant force of forward thrust by the engines. |
Quote:
Let's not. The jet NEVER MOVES. The treadmill begins spinning at the precise same instant that the wheels start to turn. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:32 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.