:spock:

Do you have any idea how utterly stupid you are?

Or is ignorance really bliss?

What was dumb about that post?

Alright, let's look at Steve Young vs. Stan Humphries.
'94 Super Bowl 49-26
Young was a failure in TB and ended up in SF as a backup to Montana and replaced him after the infamous Marshall hit.
He took over what was practically a Pro Bowl team. (They cheated the salary cap)
Humphries was brought in from Washington to replace Billy Joe Tolliver on an average team.
Humphries made "clutch" plays all season and the Chargers surprisingly made the Super Bowl.
If you were to switch QBs between the 2 teams do you think the 49ers would have won?
Yeah they'd win 28-26 with Humphries pulling a horseshoe out of his ass.
So, who's better in that situation? Humphries because he was "clutch" or Young even though he would have "choked"

Based on pure talent, there isn't a single player, other than Wilt Chamberlain perhaps, that would be drafted ahead of LeBron at 22 years of age.

Your retrospect bullshit is just ****ing stupid.

I'm at a loss.

I just can not explain it any more simply than what Ive already done.

Humphries had one great season, and never really played to that same level again.

Eli has consistenly raised the level of his game from year to year, and consistently come up big in big moments.

Drew Brees didn't choke against the 9ers this year.

Alex Smith had what is probably his "one horseshoe moment".

ROFL

That's great.

I think Cassel's came in the regular season, 2010.

So, interpreting your logic, if Alex Smith has another "horseshoe moment" he should be moved into the top 10 because he will then be considered "clutch" which is defined by making plays that seem improbable in the post season?
I'm still trying to understand your views on QB rankings since it doesn't actually have anything to do with their talent. It has to do with being "clutch".

:facepalm:Milk, There's no point in this.

LMAO He is trolling.

There is no other explanation.

NO ONE could be this obtuse.

He's just butthurt that Eli gave his Chaga's the middle finger and ended up going to the NYG and has since led them to not one, but two SBs which is more than Rivers and Peyton................COMBINED.

I'm not trolling. I would consider putting Cam in my top 10 based on talent.
The list should be based on the QBs with the most talent.

You seem to have difficulty with the word "Consistent".

And Eli Manning is talented,

He would not have been the #1 overall if he didn't have it, name be damned.

Well, then you're bitter.

This isn't 10-12 yrs ago. Talentless QBs don't win SBs anymore.

Sure, the Giants have some talent on D but nothing like Baltimore had.

If you cannot see Eli is talented, especially in crunch time, then you have a serious flaw in your football acumen.

And while Cam appears to be quite talented, his sample size is a bit small to be sure of anything at this point.