he can't hold Montana's reconstructed elbow...

Montana never had the "heart" of Farve?

please....Montana was a god damned ninja

Favre and Marino over Montana and Elway.

you know, this isnt fantasy league we are talking about. its the real game where wins and losses mean something.

let me guess, Manning is #3?

I always thought Marino was better than Montana.

at what, coming apart in big games?

Halfwit,
How many ints has Favre thrown.

He's second all time, only 6 or 7 behind George Blanda, who played for, like a 100 years.

Favre
Marino
Montana
Baugh
Unitas
Graham
Fouts

Montana had a certain calm and composure in the pocket that very few had.

But he won SBs with teams that were loaded with talent, both offensively and defensively.

Marino never played with teams that came close to matching that talent.

you're like Hootie when he's 60...

You, my friend, are a dumbass.

At throwing for over 60,000 yards and 420 TD's for a team that had average wideouts, crappy defense, and no running game.

If Montana had played for the Fins all those years-nobody would remember him. Put Marino on the 49ers and he would have 70,000 yards and at least 6 SB's.

I like you, Halfcan..and I dont mean to pile on...but..are you kidding me??

I think that's all anybody needs to know about your perspective in this discussion.

There's no doubt Marino had a great arm.

He was about as mobile as a fire hydrant though, and because of it, his team was forced to use all of their team resources to protect him.

Marino doesn't even approach Montana in the GOAT discussion without addressing him as "Sir."

Top 5, Top 10, doesn't matter.

He's won a SB ring, a SBMVP, and he'll have a bust in Canton.

That pretty much speaks for itself.

If Montana played on the Fins all those years, the Dolphins might be known for winning Superbowls, and not for being post-season chokers.