Very nice feedback... I really enjoy reading the different views.

Apparently up there with Old Geezer ;)
 

My top 10 (that I've seen play) in no particular order:

Montana
Staubach
Starr
Bradshaw
Marino
Dawson
Fouts
Unitas
Jurgenson
Elway

No explainations necessary for the above

Honorable Mentions:
Stabler (always a thorn in KC's side)
Theisman (not flashy, played within his abilities and compliement his team perfectly)
Namath (Broadway Joe, it ain't braggin' if you back it up)
Griese the Elder (16-0 still the mark to beat)
Manning the Elder (if he'd only had a team to match his heart)
Esiason (anyone who can lead the Bengals to the SB deserves some credit)
Tarkington (Fran was the pentumulate scrambler)


But, with all polls such as these, your mileage may vary.