Too clarify, I don't think the McCluster pick was bad. I do think the Arenas pick was bad. That is what drug down the grade. I should have said that better.

This isn't a team that can be taking role players in the 2nd round.

there is no grade appropriate to the 2nd round relative to the picks we had and the value available....so bad no words can describe it


Berry is an A
Assmooga is a A simply because he could be an immediate starter and is not the pathetic disaster of the 2nd round picks...but we still took a guard while having no nt and no lbs or pass rushers on an absolute joke of a defense

So, basically, you wanted a stud and two busts?

Because Philly wanted a guy is not an acceptable reason to take someone.

I gave them a D+ because a blind, reeruned squirrel that just fell out of Hamas' AIDS tree could have picked Eric Berry.

ROUND) SCORE - GRADE

1) 95 - A

2) negative 15 - F minus

3) 87 - B plus

That same squirrel could have picked any two of about ten players in the second round and scored an A for the round.

No, the acceptable reason is that he projects out to be the next Wes Welker. He isn't a reach because Philly was going to take him.

Of course, then again, maybe they just lucked into a QB at some point and they are a bunch of idiots too.

pretty much spot on with my thoughts. One or the other IMO but not both of the 2nds with the needs. Mccluster could be a slot and return guy but the downside is his 172 lb frame. Arenas has the return skills as well but won't ever be more than a nickel CB.

I really like the Asumoah pick.

Gonna have to hope Cam Thomas slides to rd 4 to find our NT. ILB Donald Butler would be nice to have too.

2 out of 4 picks are starters. In this draft, that's an F. Drafting Berry instead of Okung made me move it up to a D.

why the **** are people running around claiming mccluster is the next wes welker?

Because Pioli drafted him, silly!

You're right. He is faster and has better moves than Welker.

Berry-A+

McCluster-B+

Arenas-D

Asamouh-A