|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Wow....he got benched....so therefore he shouldn't play the QB position ever again. Is he the greatest QB ever to play the game? No. But you denying the fact that he has talent....makes you look like a complete douchebag. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
No. Giving up a chance to get another player like Powe late in the 2012 draft isn't worth a 4$million contract and a loser qb with a career 53/51 TD/INT ratio and fumbling issues.
It doesn't make sense to give up $4million and a draft pick for Smith so he can compete with Stanzi for a backup spot. |
Quote:
|
I believe if Smith had left SF, he'd be an okay starting QB this season.
The way fans have treated him, Singletary switching from him to Troy Smith and the changes at OC that happened almost every season have not helped him. At all. |
Quote:
He got benched for a young guy who outplayed him and is now out of football. He was benched because he sucks and turned the ball over every freaking game. That is all my point was. Not trying to be a douchbag, I just have seen firsthand that the guy does not have the talent to play QB in this league. He won't come in off the bench and win anything. It is my opinion and I don't think he is worth any trade. |
Quote:
Not at all. First off, Singletary handled the QB situation horribly. He benched Alex Smith for Troy Smith, the first time T. Smith started was against the Rams. He did things to the Rams that shouldn't be done by a shitty backup QB like him. From that point on, Troy Smith had no really good games, only 1 or 2 decent ones at best. And Singletary couldn't make up his mind on who to start or bench, switching Troy and Alex Smith in and out of games frequently. Alex Smith is still in San Francisco because he's better than Troy Smith and they need someone to start as their backups are Kapernick(a rookie) and Josh McCown. |
Quote:
|
Why the hell not if the price is right. We do have Zorn in house.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
People its for a back up job, hes more than suitable to be a back up QB
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The OP says the 49ers want Kaepernick to learn the ropes from someone other than Smith. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
It would be interesting to see what the required compensation would be.
|
What is funny is the 49ers were talking about bringing in Culpepper. Even they think Culpepper is an upgrade over Smith to backup Kapernick.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Ummm NO. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
God, I hope Cassel can turn things around and show everyone he is a good QB this year playing the top defenses. But even if he didn't he already showed with the Patriots he can come in as a backup and not lose a game for his team. Alex Smith has never shown that. That is why the fans hate him so much and would rather he headbutt a flaming AIDS tree than play QB even as a backup. |
Quote:
Yeah, especially passing on Rogers for Smith. Mike Mcarthy is now very happy. But after they went from Joe Montana to Steve Young it makes me sick to hear them complain about QB's. |
Hahaha some guy named Larry writes an amateur article and it gets 8 pages of posts on here. What an astute bunch you all are.
|
Quote:
Yeah they went with McCown over Culpepper. They are both pretty horrible. McCown started 31 games in eight seasons in the NFL with four different teams. No matter what the depth chart says, I can't imagine he is ahead of Kapernick when the season starts. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
No way can Kapernick be worse than Smith or those other scrubs. |
If we're going to trade a pick for a QB i'd rather trade for Mike Kafkha.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I seriously think Alex Smith ran over his dog or ****ed his mom. |
Quote:
"The 49ers drafted a quarterback for their future and now are looking to bring in a veteran quarterback to lead the team for a year and let Colin Kaepernick learn the ropes from someone other than Smith." They are more ok with Kaepernick learning from McCown than Smith. My point is if they are not ok with Smith as a backup we shouldn't be either. |
Quote:
He went to run over my dog, missed and hit a fire hydrant. I posted earlier I wouldn't even let him try and **** my mother cause he would fumble it up and then miss her by 5 yards. ROFL |
Quote:
|
51/53 really isn't that bad for a backup QB. Especially considering hes coming from such a bad and messed up organization. Odds are pretty good that Stanzi will throw more picks than TD's this year just like most rookies would just being thrown out to the wolves. I don't know what his contract is, but I wouldn't be against him being here for insurance for a year or two at MOST until Stanzi has a full grasp on everything. Even if Stanzi had a full offseason here, at least 9/10 times a rookie QB isn't going to be ready to take over.
|
Quote:
I disagree with you. Deal with it. You don't have to be such a ****ing asshole. |
Quote:
It wouldn't be THAT bad if it wasn't a trade. I just think giving up a draft pick for him is a bad idea. Ranks up there with trading Charles for a 3rd. Personally, I think if Cassel goes down, they might as well throw Stanzi out there and see what he can do, cause our season really depends on Cassel anyway. |
Quote:
You like him so much you should take him home to **** your mom. I'll let you know when I am done with her. |
Quote:
|
This would be an awesome acquisition.
But only because I believe you should always have a backup who can at least not embarrass you when he comes in. Smith will NEVER be starter material. But he's not a bad guy to have for 3-4 games if your starter's out. |
Quote:
|
We could do worse for a backup quarterback. Justa sayin'. :shrug:
|
I have never seen it w/ A.Smith. It's a blah move if they make it. I like the fact they're allegedly trying to do something about the disaster that is our backup qb situation.
|
Quote:
|
For a 6th or a 7th round pick, I'd take him.
Has more experience and is a better QB than Palko. |
Bring him in. Thomas Jones will whip his ass into shape. :)
|
I prefer to spell it cheefs
|
I would be in favor of this. I know Palko's stint on the field ended with 10 points on the board, bet he was also very fortunate to not have a couple of INT's... one of which would have been an easy pick-six.
Stanzi made some nice throws, and missed on a couple that would have made his stock go up a little more. It would be nice to see what he could do with a little more protection up front, instead of the guys who will not make the roster blocking for him. |
Quote:
and unlike Brody, he's also won a game. |
Quote:
Palko's performance was misleading. Sure he scored BUT he was very fortunate not to have thrown a couple of pics that could easily have lead to points the other way. Stanzi looks like he's aiming the ball.. |
Alex Smith would be a decent #2 QB.
Neither Palko or Stanzi look anywhere close to NFL quality at this point. |
Quote:
|
Bring in Smith for a backup, you have to. Palko and Stanzi have no business getting on the field this year
|
Quote:
You have been a rude ****ing prick asshole. Apologize, or go cyber **** yourself. |
anyone worried that the odd man out would the the Stanz?
|
Quote:
Congrats. Thats the first time that anyone has demanded an apology from me over the net. But yeah......you aren't getting one. |
Quote:
Hey, at least I made ya laugh. I cracked myself up when I typed it. |
Quote:
Everyone should pray our #2 or #3 doesn't play, so might as well let it be our guy vs. someone elses trash that they would love to get rid of. Former #1 pick with history of INT, fumbles, bad decision making, never a winning record. There is a reason crowds boo him. Might as well look at Jamarcus Russell too then, at least he wouldn't cost a draft pick. |
no the jerkoffcus ... no to smith too ... better old QBs out there ....
|
All I want for Christmas is a franchise QB.
|
Alex Smith? Please.
No thanks. He is junk. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Sometimes Stanzi looks better in the pocket than Cassel.
Arm and throwing mechanics are sure as shit better than Cassel's. I'd really like to see Stanzi behind a good Oline as opposed to running for his life as soon as the ball is hiked. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
We signed a franchise QB off the street back in 1962. Since that time, we haven't signed, traded for, drafted, or shit a franchise QB. So, in short, no we don't do jack except dream about franchise QBs. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
http://sports.gather.com/viewArticle...81474979971113 is this where you got it?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
As has been said: it's to be the backup. Not the starter. If you can bring in a guy, for cheap money, who has already thrown over 50 touchdowns in the NFL, compared to two backups with little experience, it's a no-brainer. Hell, as a Patriots fan, I'd be more than happy if Belichick traded Brian Hoyer to you guys, and then traded for Alex Smith to be Brady's backup. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
He was a very good QB for the Chiefs, and a great fit for the system that Vermeil and Saunders brought to the team. However, a franchise QB is a guy that takes over games, who makes the people around him better, and isn't as reliant on others to make him better. That was not Green. |
Quote:
My educated guess is that Harbaugh (who is a damn good guy as far as quarterbacks go) doesn't see the potential in him that the front office did when they resigned him for 4 million for one "lets see what Harbaugh thinks about you" year...with a possibility of adding another million through incentives. That should be enough to pass on the kid in any trade. Why would we trade for him anyway? He doesnt know our offense. He is a turnover machine He hasnt developed into a quality player, even if looked at as a backup. Dudes garbage. Just the thought of giving up a draft pick and that salary for him makes me :facepalm: |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:10 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
