She has a very goregous face, but shes a little thick for me, though I would still do her after a few beers. I'll give her a 6.

I give her about an 8, maybe 7. But last years winner, Carrie Underwood is a 9 or 10!

If she didn't have a great rack most of you would be rating her below 5.

The first two photos are probably airbrushed and touched up a bit. You can't compare the pictures. Kind of like that beach photo of Kelly Clarkson someone posted. You can find all sorts of professional photos where she looks 100x better than that candid shot.

That's not a very flattering dress.

I'd go with a 4. Maybe a 5.

Thank you. I was pretty sure I was the only one who thought this.

McPhee 7.25

Jolie 8.75

She looks like she could pop out 11 pound babies all day long.. IMHO

DT

I'd have to give her an 8.5

A gorgeous face and some good quality birthing hips to boot!

We can work on her losing those few extra pounds in the sack!!!

6

Pick your own numbers, copycat.

Is this where the line forms?


McPhee is a strong 7 in my book.

I think her boobage would all go away with the needed weight loss but I would like to find out at least. Here is a more common view of what you saw of her most of the time in American Idol, she sure loves maternity clothes.

http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/..._katharine.jpg

This one really shows her jelly roll above and below the belt
http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/..._katharine.jpg

Where I come from we call those jelly rolls "boobs"......