I gave him one too :/

I say HELLNO to GENO

:shake:

http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1682851/uscee.gif


Yeah cause that's a noodle arm

He never said Barkley had a noodle arm

No.

Again, which non-QBs do you see that are remotely worth the top 5 pick?

Great couple of stops!

Please.

Any old noodle arm can chuck the ball 50 yards with that much arc on it.

Matt Cassel could do that. He might overthrow it, but he could put arc on a 50-yard pass.

Duuuuooo. He da USC quarterback. He be like matt castle. Doodedoodedooo...

There wasn't that much arc. Matt couldn't do that. He certainly wouldn't hit the receiver in stride. I am not really a Barkley fan, but you don't have to make him out to be a giant turd to argue that Geno is the right selection.

If I had to put money on it I would say Tyler Wilson will be the #1 QB. I think there's so many bad teams that just drafted QB's one will trade back and a team will grab either Geno Smith or Barkley.

So your point is that this year's draft is so weak that they are the best of a shit draft?


well ... that makes be feel better. #notreally

what a difference a year makes ... last year's #2 pick worth a bajillion times more than this year's is going to be worth.

The ball left the ****ing frame. It was a freaking balloon ball. Get real.

Barkley is a 2nd round talent.

Geno has accuracy, I just don't like the staredown interception and cop out on third down in the red zone.

:hmmm:

wow ... Wilson being the first QB picked would be a bit of an 'upset'

Right so lets go dig up JaMarcus Russell cuz that is what you want:thumb:

I only brought it up to diffuse your point that these QBs should go between 8-15.

There are enough teams that need QBs and enough quality QBs to see three of them go in the top 6 or so this year.

Jeff George and JaMarcus Russell had cannons how did that work out?

Geno needs to tie this shizz up.

Show us somefin gold toof dawg.

Good stop.

That ball went 60 in the air, and I've never seen Cassel throw one that far.

You can't always make friends .

you guys will be on the Glennon bandwagon soon

Any word on Barkley Injury????

Balls leave the screen on certain throws from all QBs. I don't think he has a great arm and I am not really a fan, but you try to hard to make all your arguments be so black and white when just your original point was fine.

Lets stop comparing our possible future QBS to Cassel

I hope Landry Jones goes to a team like Oakland. Then they can know the pain that we feel from Matt Cassel.

The point is using that GIF as some kind of evidence that Barkley has a good arm is silly.

He has a Trent Green arm at best.

Erratic in the pocket and shitty completion percentage.

No thank you.

That would be a great turn of events.

yea, but i'm trying to look more at the talent level value of the players not just the relative value to a shit draft.

Geno has a shit ton of potential ... but he is going to need quality coaching.

I think Oakland will stick with Palmer next year

All rookie QBs need quality coaching.

Using Gifs of Geno throws is the same

How big of a talent difference is there between Landry Jones and Matt Barkley?

ouch

I can agree with that.

Shitty possession. Gotta do better G-Dawg.

Geno is cracking under the pressure a little

Geno has faced 2 real D this year and has looked like dog shit.

Leaps.

Barkley would have 100% completion in this game right now if he were Oklahoma's QB.

Jones will be taken in the 3rd round I imagine. He shouldn't, though. He should go in the 4th at the earliest.

Barkley will go in the top 5, and possibly at the #1 overall spot.

I'm not trying to start a fight but obviously you don't watch him .

he's the next matt ryan ( you can can save this )

One bad possession = Geno cracks under pressure.

Riiiiight

Wow the D is reall showing up now

He's had 3 this game so far

it's not just one possession

He hasn't looked dominant for several games now

He's is learning to deal with more pressure and adversity ... which is a good thing.

better now then in the NFL

i'm not a hater, just talking

teams have figured him out

nice throw

Tight ****ing throw there.

PI!!

That was a great throw.

Bull shit call.

does college football have the PI 'uncatchable' exception rule?


sure looked like it should apply there

Tavon Austin needs to suck so he will be there in the 2nd round lol

17 runs and 9 throws, what's that West Virginia?? We want to see geno c'mon!!

Getting bailed out on a heinous throw and forcing the reciever to come out of the endzone on a curl isn't helping smith, but I can see pioli still drafting a medicore quarterback to placate a fanbase and play the victim.

No, it's fine. He hasn't looked dominant, but you really have to consider what he's got to work with and what he's facing. I've made this point 1000 times this year, but here it is again.

Ben Roethlisberger for Miami, OH put up INSANE stats in his weak conference. Whenever he played a tough opponent outside of the conference, he got crushed.

Geno's almost in the same position. He's got a Miami, OH offensive line and defense going up against a lot of tough competition. But he's not getting crushed. He's doing a good job maintaining order as his team is in a tough transition year.

Pioli isn't gonna be here, dude.

How'd he look against a good TCU defense? You try too hard to be this stupid.

Draft Stedman Bailey as a replacement for Terrance Copper when he has to retire

The game he went 32-54 and 260 yards?

Ell.

Oh.

Ell.

That comeback route to woods was a beauty of a throw.

Geno Smith really looked terrible on that TD by Oklahoma

And Barkley has a good D?

Yea, he really has to learn how to tackle properly.

59% completion rate and 3 TD's against a good secondary is a good game you ****tard.

Rothlesburger/rapeisburger didn't have track stars for recievers and a giant offensive line. He had a donkey dick team in division I/II.

Better than Geno's

"Giant offensive line"

Lol. Riiiight.

I am right. He's got a division one offensive line and recievers that could start for the New York giants.

Dude, what's your problem? I LIKE Barkley. I just prefer Geno Smith, that's all.

I'm not going to cry if the Chiefs draft Barkley

Geno probably has 3 or 4 offensive weapons that are going to play in the NFL.

Austin might go in the 1st round pick if he was bigger
Bailey is a Day 1 guy if he runs well at the combine
Wood will be drafted
Buie will have to be converted to a slot WR but he has solid chance too

lots of talent and speed around Smith

He's got a shitty offensive line, dumbass.

Geno has a horrible coach, horrible defense, below average OL and a non-existent running game.

His ST's only gets a break because of Tavon Austin. Even with him, they give up more TD's on ST's than Austin has scored. And their kicker sucks.

He's got a real line, not a patch work line filled with dairy queen workers in ohio. I never said he's playing behind the hogs, snowflake.

^

Same can be said about Barkley bud beside the RB.

Barkley has a butt load of talent around him

so much so that i just don't trust the evaluations about him

He could turn to complete shit once he gets to the NFL where the talent level is so close.

How many of these gift calls are WVU getting here?

And he's doing a good job using that talent when he goes up against superior teams with very good defenses.

He's not getting blown out with 4 INTs like Roethlisberger did. He's putting up averageish stats and points against them. Against Ok State and TCU, those were very winnable games that he could have had.