keg in kc |
03-16-2013 03:02 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by splatbass
(Post 9506026)
There are a lot of very persistent people here saying that the Alex Smith trade is a failure, that we WON'T win in the playoffs or SB with him, and that they are done with the team. And you say WE'RE overreacting?
|
I can't speak for anybody else but I think it's possible they get to the playoffs, eventually, and maybe even win a wild card. My problem is that I think they're going about this (acquiring a starting QB) in completely the wrong way. I have no problem with going veteran over rookie, but think they grossly overpaid for a guy who has proven that he isn't very good, and who has never at any point in his career shown that he can fit the style of offense the head coach has run for his entire coaching career. Which is why I don't understand why Reid is so enamored with the guy. And the reason I'm not willing to give very much of a benefit of the doubt is that I've seen this same scenario play out countless times in the NFL, both in and outside of Kansas City, and it almost never works. I also watched Reid get progressively worse and worse results in Philadelphia, while spending enormous amounts of free agent cash on a virtual smorgasboard of top players, which is why I don't give him, specifically, much benefit of the doubt, and why I'm not convinced this offseason's spending spree is going to automatically equate with success.
It could work. Maybe Alex Smith here becomes a far better quarterback than he ever was before and maybe the last few years were an aberration and Andy Reid will be back to early 2000s form. I acknowledge the possibility. I don't, however, believe either scenario to be very likely. I'm sorry that I can't be blindly optimistic. Please don't take that as any kind of reflection on what you believe, because it's not. It just happens to be my opinion. Which I think I'm entitled to have and even to share, right or wrong.
And yes, I do realize that the "constant negativity" thread is the wrong place to post such a realistic explanation for why I'm not rainbows and cotton candy.
|