Amen! They could lose the game on that decision alone imo.

Baldwin will do just fine this year, the only thing he got going against him is the QB. He has skill set that can surpass Breaston doesn't have the experience but he will get there. Two years from now Breaston may not even be on this team while Baldwin will be a force to deal with.

Baldwin should be fourth on the depth chart. He hasn't done a thing yet. Pioli has done a poor job with depth at the OL.

2012 Pioli's Last Stand

Going into the season I thought we were going be stack at depth for OL but now not so much. Not looking good there.

Or he could be a total bust.

The evidence we have right now says he sucks.

Stop being a homer.

You're really going to use Cassel to argue the guys lack of production? If he fails it will be because he can't get separation and has stone hands.

There hasn't been any evidence he is going to suck this year or be a bust. He will do fine. Some players catch on quicker than others, but he will be out there making plays and looking good when he does.

Yeah maybe a bit of homer, but it's only his second year in the league. Last year was too much of a cluster **** for any of the players to get a fair read. Palko muther ****ing Palko. Our QB challenged team is what holds us back and development of what could be great players to see.

Not just Baldwins production but as a team. Cassel holds the team back except in the running game. I will give Cassel credit for being a great hand off QB.

And for one, you can't tell me if we had a QB like Aaron Rodgers we wouldn't be contenders right now. Rodgers would make all the guys look better or play up to there potential. It's just the way it is untill we get a QB of our own that can make the guys around him better. That's how great elite QBs work, they make the team better.

Yes there has...his best preseason game was 6 catches for 37 yards.

He dropped two passes in preseason and for a "deep threat" he has failed horribly so far in real games catching the ball down the field....apart from one game.

He is definitely the worst first round pick of the Pioli era so far and with Tyson Jackson on the roster that is saying A LOT.

Meh, give him time. He will produce, but I stand by that the QB holds the team back so that is against him.

If I had a million dollars i'd be a millionaire.


You can't have your cake and eat it too. If the team is being held back by Cassel it also means it's being held back by Pioli.

I don't understand the emphasis we're still putting on special teams with the kickoff rule change

Cassel sucks, but does he hold back Steve Breaston? Does he hold back Dwayne Bowe?

Yes, but those guys still produce at a solid level.

Baldwin looks like shit.

You see what I'm getting at here? Baldwin has done shit in every game he has played in the NFL except one.