Look, not groundbreaking difference here but if we want to look at Smith Vs Cassel 2009 to present here what it looks like. One guy improving another getting worse.

I have not claimed Smith is a world beater but I liked the guy in SF the last few years before he was traded so I am not going to just reverse field now like many here.

http://i541.photobucket.com/albums/g...ps73e280f3.jpg

Bull shit. There wasn't very many here who wanted Alex Smith and if they were they were being shot down.



I call bull shit on your post.

Could?

He already has. 2010.

Smith - 2011/2012:

187 yards per game
1.15 TD per game
.38 INT per game
64% completion
7.36 yards per attempt
.3 fumbles per game

Matt Cassel - 2010

208 yards per game
1.8 TD per game
.46 INT per game
58.2% completion
6.92 yards per attempt
.13 fumbles per game

As I said the Cassel debate all over again. His level of suck equals Cassel with injury issues.

I am not referring to the off season, I am talking in season for the last 2 years.


Clay had an entire thread dedicated to Alex Smith. You need to do some research.

Matt Cassel played well beating Brees in a playoff game and almost won the NFCCG? **** me.

You all are some jaded mother ****ers.

I don't have to do any research at all I was here. Last season as soon as Alex Smith was benched a bunch of us went on a neg rep spree to any one who pimped for Alex Smith to come here. Not many at all wanted Alex Smith to come here just a few. Only a handful of posters wanted anything to do with Alex Smith before the trade.

The old version of QB rating?

ROFL

Desperate.

Eagles game, 2009. Cassel throws for 90 yards and a 5 yard average in a game we lost by 20 points. QB Rating?

124.5.

Every starting QB and many b/u's are better than Ca$$hole.

That doesn't make Smith good - it means he's not a horrible failure in every way...

I can't see how these guys keep bringing up ONE game out of an eight year career.

say it aloud Marcellus.

That was only one game. Out of eight years
Posted via Mobile Device

One game against what I believe was the 30th ranked pass defense makes up for 7 years of futility?

I understand you want to have hope for the guy, but don't piss on my leg and tell me it's raining. Even in his best seasons, he's been average at best. To act as if 1 playoff game against a shit defense makes up for 7 years of sub 200 yard efforts and a 1:1 TD:GAME ratio is ridiculous.

I'm sick of watching shit football, so I hope he's decent, but "decent" isn't good enough. You all are expecting to cash in a lottery ticket. Expecting the frog to magically turn into a prince.

Sad that "Better than Cassel" is the rallying cry.

Because that one game is the toothpick holding their weak argument together.

How's my favorite Asian mechanic from Mid-Missouri, BTW?

doing great buddy, busy as hell at work. Finally got good help it seems and I can relax and supervise lol.

How about you?
Posted via Mobile Device

Same here, busy. Last day with kids tomorrow, teacher work day on Friday and then summer break.

you guys get your breaks when I'm blowing up busy lol. Lake weather. I love it.

Have a great summer man.

I'm hoping Smith works, I know you are too lol, but that's all it is.

Really not much else to base it on...
Posted via Mobile Device