Quote:
Originally Posted by KChiefs1
(Post 12478852)
FYP
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
Yost has actually been a pretty damn good postseason manager. In 22 games, he's only made 1 clear blunder (bringing in Ventura in the WC). Even putting in Madson was a defensible decision because of the oncoming storm. Yost and the staff worried about the longterm risks for Davis' health in a rain delay, and with Davis' 2016, those fears may have been justified. I still think the right move was bringing in Davis and worrying about 2016 later, but Yost did have legitimate justification for his decision making.
He arguably could have been more aggressive in Games 4 and 7 of the 2014 World Series, but I honestly think Tito and Bochy may have been the only managers in the game with the gonads to go straight for the kill with Herrera in the (early) 4th innings of those contests.
What won me on Yost was how he seemed to learn his lesson after his experiences in 2014. While Terry Collins waited until their were two runners on in the 8th to bring in Familia, Yost went straight for the knockout and put in Davis for a clean 2 inning save, a move even Maddon has been hesitant to make so far in the postseason. Yost went with Davis in the 8th three times in the 2015 postseason, illustrating obvious growth for him as a postseason manager.
Even if you want to say he had 2 major mistakes in 22 games, this is still a pretty good ratio, all things considered. Maddon's bullpen management in Game 3 was as questionable as any moves Yost has made in October (outside of Ventura), and Bochy's meltdown today matched any of Yost's playoff blunders as well.
Edgar earned me as a fan for life in the 2015 playoffs. He matched Gibbons and outmanaged both Hinch and Collins to earn the title. In his postseason career, I believe Bochy is the only one to have ever outmanaged him, and that even includes Buck "Chessmaster" Showalter.
His stubbornness with Soria in 2016 was incredibly frustrating, but I'm willing to give him a pass because of the major injuries we had at every part of our roster. It was pretty sad and telling that when he finally tried switching Soria out for Strahm and Kelvin, they both blew multiple saves, with even Wader blowing a couple down the stretch.
The team just wore down this year, but I have all the faith in the world that we can gear up for another run in 2017, and yes, that includes with Edgar as the captain.