Originally Posted by Rain Man (Post 12070438)

I want to see a replay, but I didn't think it ever hit the ground. It was bouncing around a lot, but when the play was done and Von Miller had put his knife back in his sock, the receiver had the ball in his hands and it had never touched dirt. That's by definition a catch.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 12070437)

Most everyone thought it was a catch including BOTH announcers and the ref on the phone. All said it would be a reversal. I suggest that YOU take another said visit to the replay booth. :shake:

Originally Posted by jd1020 (Post 12070430)

So I guess Talib didn't get called for taunting.

Originally Posted by Rain Man (Post 12070438)

I want to see a replay, but I didn't think it ever hit the ground. It was bouncing around a lot, but when the play was done and Von Miller had put his knife back in his sock, the receiver had the ball in his hands and it had never touched dirt. That's by definition a catch.

Originally Posted by New World Order (Post 12070453)

If it barely hits the ground and the receiver maintains control then it's a catch. I think the tip of the ball hit the ground causing the receiver to lose control. That's why it was ruled an incomplete pass.

Originally Posted by jd1020 (Post 12070448)

You mean I should listen to the guys in the booth who are called idiots 50,000 times a game? Sure. I'll get right on that.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 12070462)

No. You should listen to the official on the phone who said if it was him, he would reverse it. The only thing you really should get right on is a refresher course of what constitutes a catch.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 12070462)

No. You should listen to the official on the phone who said if it was him, he would reverse it. The only thing you really should get right on is a refresher course of what constitutes a catch.

Originally Posted by B2chiefsfan (Post 12070313)

Chronic lurker... and constantly busy...

Originally Posted by jd1020 (Post 12070457)

He didnt maintain control. What about this is hard? The ball was moving all over the ****ing place after the ball appears to hit the ground.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 12070480)

Yes he did, till after the fact. Dude cupped it, it did not hit ground. He rolled and had it pinned on his hip - still maintaining control. THEN it moves AFTER he satisfied what constitutes a catch. It was an easy call to make once seen on replay.