warpaint* |
10-24-2013 05:38 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prison Bitch
(Post 10118630)
If you believe that - and it's logical - then you must also agree Kansas proved they were better in 2008. Won head to head and both went 4-1 against the North. Have to pick a side and stick to it.
It meant Kansas won the game but it doesn't prove they were better. Va Tech certainly could've won if they replayed it, just as Mizzou would beat Norfolk 9 out of 10 tries. That's my only point regarding head to head.
|
?
It's not the same thing. Our record in '07 including H2H was better. In '08 it is the same. No different than comparing OU and Kstate last year.
You can however provide a compelling argument that they proved they were on par w/ the Tigers in spite of the overall 2 game difference in the win column. The South Fla game is a clunker of an OOC we don't have on our resume but still it was by a fg on the road and was probably an outlier AND that was the year all those South teams went 11-1...I hadn't looked it up before you said that b/c they had 5 losses and had forgot KU's third South game that year was against Ttech. Considering OU and TX bombed us into submission in games that weren't remotely competitive there's not any reason to believe we'd have beaten the Red Raiders either.
To your second point there's no question that it's true VaTech could maybe win a rematch but I don't get into stuff like that w/o other evidence (Mizzou/Norfolk as you said or Southern Cal/Stanford in '07 are both dramatic examples, it doesn't have to be defining for me but I need something) b/c the games played are supposed to mean something and they do to me. If it's a conference opponent where we have a bunch of common opponents to compare such as what we've been discussing then sure. Last year for example, Kstate beat Oklahoma but I don't think they were better than the Sooners. Reason? They finished w/ the same league record. For every person that touts their H2H I point to the fact that OU beat Baylor, they didn't get housed by them like the Wildcats did. That game counts just as much in the standings as the H2H. OU has that loss to Notre Dame but the Irish beat Stanford who beat Oregon who smoked Kstate in their bowl. Now could Kstate beat Notre Dame in terms of 2012? Absolutely, what I just said doesn't in any way provide a convincing argument that they couldn't have but it does make things murky enough that we shouldn't penalize the Sooners for that loss to the Irish when we compare their season to Kstate's given that they didn't play. I put more weight on the H2H in bowl games like the '07 OB and others b/c the records are similar enough but are from different leagues w/ a dearth of common opponents.
|