Sherman was in charge of PP in GB?

Sherman wasn't the GM.

Thompson gave him a 2 year extension and fired him that same year saying how he wasn't a good fit for the future. I don't know sounds like theres something there.

Mike Sherman absolutely had full control when he was there

what the **** you guys start watching football 2 years ago? lol

Not sure bout Polian.

Had one of, if not the greatest QB in history and consistently underachieved.

Rumored to be as big a dicbag as our current GM. He has put together some pretty good rosters tho.

TBH, I'd rather go with a younger up and coming guy, with a great scouting eye who isnt' a huge dicbird, but we need stability.

Not in 2005 he didn't.

Sherman succeeded Ron Wolf as General Manager of the Packers in 2001, taking on the dual role of Head Coach and General Manager. Although the promotion of Sherman to GM was made prior to the 2001 NFL Draft, Wolf handled the actual draft duty in 2001. Sherman brought in three of the core players that were on the Packers 2010 roster. He drafted Nick Barnett (2003 Rd 1 #29), Scott Wells, (2004 Rd 7 #251 - complimentary pick), and acquired Cullen Jenkins as a rookie free agent after the 2003 draft.

Sherman's first solo draft pick as GM and in charge of the draft was Javon Walker in 2002, who made the Pro Bowl in 2004, and was traded to the Denver Broncos in 2006.

In 2005 the Packers hired Ted Thompson from the Seattle Seahawks to take over Sherman's General Manager duties, although Sherman remained the Packers' head coach for one more season.

No, we remember

good thing nobody was talking about the 2005 draft and we were talking about Mike Shermans coaching years

He did have it for a few years, you're right about that.

So now we're blaming Manning's chokes on Polian?

Can't have it both ways.

Either Manning was a choker or Polian underachieved. Pick one.

Either way I'm not gonna blame them for losing to Brady. That's like turning up your nose at Elway for losing to Montana.

Come on, man.

If Bill Polian doesn't scare you, Chris Polian taking over in a couple of years should...

Can we blame his horrid, undersized defenses on him?

essentially 4 years, and they remind me exactly of Piolis talent evaluation in 4 years here

was my essentially my point

Your statement that Sherman had full control when he was there is incorrect.