alnorth |
06-19-2010 12:43 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by tk13
(Post 6831260)
Yeah, that's why Rany isn't a GM. I don't know about Gordon, I hope he's turned the corner. I think Kila is ready though, time to find out what he's made of.
But, in the large scheme of things... it isn't going to hurt either one of these guys to wait a couple more weeks. Everybody always wants to rush. The smart play has to be running Guillen and some of these other guys out there and see if anyone bites. With our luck no one will and we'll keep playing them.
But until that happens, the correct move is to run out the veterans who are actually playing fairly decent and flip them for whatever we can get. Then actually give Gordon and Kila AB's everyday and not some platoon garbage. Kila really should be up now, but it's in the best interest of both him and Guillen to get AB's everyday.
|
Regarding Rany, you might want to re-read his article, particularly the "I hope we are trying to trade Guillen and Podsednik" part. He said if they are not playing August 1, then our front office is screwed up.
Quote:
I remain hopeful that the Royals really do understand that Gordon and Ka’aihue could step into the team’s lineup tomorrow and improve the team at two positions, and that they’re simply waiting to unload guys like Guillen and Podsednik onto other teams first. Whether they’re able to do that or not is a question that requires its own article. For now, it’s not unreasonable of the Royals to hope they can swing a trade. But the team’s excuses will pass with the trading deadline in six weeks. Come August 1st, both Gordon and Ka’aihue are in the Royals’ everyday lineup, or I’ll take back every nice thing I’ve said about this organization this year.
|
Even given that though, I simply do not agree at all with even that point. I believe you reach a point where it gets utterly silly. 1.100-1.200 OPS in a lot of AB is that point, where you pretty much have to play or trade them right now. The fact that Gordon and Kila could be in Omaha instead of here another 4-5 weeks is highly difficult to defend. These aren't marginal guys who are maybe hopefully getting close. They are, right now, arguably 2 of the best baseball players in the entire minor league systems of all 30 MLB clubs. There is not a very good reason for them to keep playing in Omaha, at all.
edit: as far as "rushing" them, they are 26. In Kila's case, he is being held back, not rushed. He should have been up here all of last year. Gordon... who knows. It's not a fluke small sample size with him though, perhaps he figured something out this year and wasn't given much of a chance this season at all before being banished up north.
|