Better NFL QB: Young or Leinart?
 

Forget Young vs. Vick, Young vs. Smith, Young vs. Cunningham, Young vs. Peete, Young vs. World...

Leinart is more of a prototypical NFL QB, while no one will ever question Vince's heart and desire.

Push - depends on what o-line they each play under.

Leinart's overrated. His arm is pretty average.

Young has all the tools, can scramble as well as anyone outside of Vick, and plenty accurate.

Leinart lacks all the intangibles.

Young is a taller Michael Vick, who happens to be right handed, as well. In the NFL, he doesn't get a lot of those runs you saw tonight. BTW, the Trojans must have watched our game vs. the Giants, because they immulated that tackling performance to a "T."

I don't think either of them have great arms. Young's probably more efficient and obviously has better legs. I think Leinart's pretty intelligent, and can go down the field better. They let him change calls and all that at the line of scrimmage.

His arm is pretty average, but so is Green's.

Leinart has composure and pocket awareness.

Those traits usually lend themselves to success.

Young will have NFL Gm's pisspantsing themselves, line art not so much.

Young's is clearly better than Leinart's.

When asked to comment on Vince Young's NFL MVP award, former Saint/Buccanneer/Texan/Jet/Cardinals player Matt Leinart responded, "I'm still the better quarterback."

There are a lot of factors beyond the individual's talent.

Leinart to the Texans with a lousy line? Bad news for him.

I could see Young going to the Titans and having pretty quick success.

Personally, I think Leinart is more likely to succeed.

ROFL

Cardinals? Does his arm translate to right field? I'll bet he bats 7th.

What was that? Arizona has a football team?

Ah, let's put this thread up after everyone is jizzing about Young.........but I ask. Why are you comparing a top 10 NFL draft pick to a player who will likely be moved to WR?

Leinart is more accurate. I'd rather have accuracy over arm strength, just me though.

I think Young would make a good WR, slash type of player.