Qb for one year
 

You run a nfl franchise. The nfl is shutting down next year for whatever reason. This year is your final shot at a superbowl. And if course, you have shit for qb.

Also for whatever reasons, the following Qbs have become available.

Matt Stafford
Eli Manning
Jay Cutler
Mike Vick
Matt Schaub
Alex Smith
Kurt Warner says he'll return

Please rank those qbs I'm order if which one you want the most for your final superbowl run.

Eli Manning. No contest at this point. Today
Posted via Mobile Device

Then Stafford Warner Schaub Vick Smith cutler
Posted via Mobile Device

Eli Manning
Matt Stafford
Matt Schaub
Kurt Warner
Mike Vick
Alex Smith
Jay Cutler

Tyler Thigpen. He's better than all those guys.

Yep.....

Peyton Manning

Is this suppose to be some fantasy football thread?

I'll go with the guy with multiple 10+ win seasons and is a probowler: Matt Cassel.

Eli, Warner, Stafford, Alex Smith, Cutler, Schaub, Vick.

Eli, obviously.

Ricky Stanzi

Eli, and then Warner. If I have one shot at the SB, I want to be led by a QB who has actually won a SB. None of the others have even been to one.

I was curious to the ranking of the group of guys, and if anybody would take Stafford over Eli. I would.

Stafford, an injury prone QB who hasn't won a playoff game, over Eli, who has 2 come from behind SB wins against one of the best teams in the league for the last decade. SMART!

Eli hands down. He has done more with less.

Just one year? I'm taking Eli. I'll think about Stafford if we're talking multiple years.

Defense.

Like, what Qbs -- out of all of them in the NFL -- would you take over Eli for one season?

Brady, Rogers, Brees, Rothlisberger. That's it. And I might take Eli over Ben.

Really? Eli is waay over hyped here.

You wouldn't take rivers or peyton over eli?

This is a badass point.

**** no I wouldn't. Eli has won 2 SB, and he's not a game manager. He makes plays when the pressure is on (unlike his brother).

Hell no I wouldn't take Crybaby or Brokeneck over him

No way. The teams Rivers has been on have been just as talented, if not more so than the teams Eli has won SBs with IMO.

Peyton has also had loaded teams and choked in the playoffs.
Regular season: Peyton>Eli
Playoffs: Eli>Peyton

I would take Stafford.

Staffard is a arrogant bitch who threw a party for his player of the week before MNF

1.) Eli Manning
2.) Matt Schaub
3.) Matt Stafford

WhoCares.) Cutler, Vick, Smith all suck and Warner's too old

Any list that doesn't have Eli at #1 is ****ing reeruned.

if a great O-line was there too .. Warner .....

Alex D. Smith is an up and comer.

I see the middle schooler is back posting again.

He used his hour of internet time...
Posted via Mobile Device

obvi Eli Manning

I would be 100% on board with grabbing Kurt Warner right ****ing now.

Rivers over Eli??

Oh, no no no.

Philip Rivers? :spock:

Are you related to BlackBob by any chance?

troll or stupid? which one is it?

Eli Manning
Matt Safford
Matt Schaub
Alex Smith
Kurt Warner
Jay Cutler
Mike Vick

I think he's BlackBob's illigitimate afterbirth.