Eli vs Peyton
 

Who is more clutch?

Is this even a question?

Eli.

/Thread.

Despite Peyton's strong showing tonight, I'd say that Eli still has him beaten out when it comes to his affinity for pouty expressions.

Eli is clutch Peyton is not. Eli didn't have a good year but twice he beat the Patriots in the Super Bowl with clutch performance.

I vote Archie Manning

Peyton had a horseshoe on his helmet and Eli had one firmly planted up his ass.

Bitter much?

A little bit...:harumph:

You have the same team makeup everywhere but the QB position. You are about to start the playoffs. You have a choice between Eli or Peyton. Who do you choose?

Can we say that Peyton definitely has more talent? But would you choose him over Eli, with all else being equal on the team?

Are you new here?

I am the first to call Peyton a playoff choker, going back years.

Took a ton of shit for that.

I am taking Eli, and not even thinking about looking back.

Hope the OP is not asking a serious question.

Peyton is a luckier Dan Marino. Loaded with talent but just can't get over the hump and gets in his own way at the worst time. The only year he won the SB it was due more to his running game and defense, and he was the least-important factor. On the other hand, Eli underwhelms with his presence but just keeps winning.

Newish.

But my buddy and I were arguing over text about this. I called Manning a definite choker after tonight's performance. He says it isn't fair to call Eli more clutch because those Giants defenses won them games/Superbowls while Peyton played in Indy with shitty defenses.

He claims if they both were Quarterbacking the same team, you would take Peyton because his talent is superior.

Yep I'm talking Eli too.
Posted via Mobile Device