What is the knock on Brady Quinn?
 

Why is Brady Quinn a bad qb? I confess, I don't watch much college sports, and hardly pay any attention to the Cleveland Browns, so I don't really know what he can do. What I do know is that he has a pretty strong arm, was drafted in the first round, and has had time to mature, albeit holding a clip board. 13 games is low sample size in my opinion. I am pretty sure alot of quarter backs who have turned out to be pretty good didn't play well or having wining records in their first year or two. I don't know, it just seems like all the media guys are really down on this kid, and it seems he has not had much of a chance in Cleveland, and/or backing up Tebow who was Denver first round pick. Some of those guys on 610 and 810 have very narrow views, and shady agendas. They say all the fans are mad about this or that, and everybody calls in and goes yeah! fire this guy and fire that guy and the masses by into a bunch of hype men on the radio. I am going to wait to form my own judgements and to see if Quinn guy can play and win us some motha****in games.

Completion %, and cant throw the ball downfield with any sort of accuracy at all.

Way to mechanical....

He touches other dude's dicks.

Oh, I'm sure it'll become clear over the next few months.

/thread

Footwork has been a knock. Also questionable decision making, mentality and accuracy....has a tendency to over-throw or throw too high or just seemingly throw at something other than the receiver. He has his moments though.

That

He is Cassel who can throw a long ball with power.

Meaning, he sucks, but he's just a little more fun to watch since he can rocketball into a pick rather than float a screen pass pick.

He's got everything you would want in a QB but accuracy. When your QB lacks accuracy, he has nothing.

Yeah that long ball with power is about as accurate as an Iraqi Scub Missle...

He's like Casshole on red bull.

Iraqi Scud Missle > Quinn

Sounds alot like Kyle Orton who can still win some games. I would rather have some one with some talent and ability instead of someone who maybe physically cant do it like Cassel.

Loves to check down and not look downfield.

Stronger arm than Cassel um thats it?

Abortion was a joke... Most over hyped QB in KC in the last 30 Days...LMAO

I didn't say it landed anywhere near the receiver~

No, Kyle put Brady's dick all in the dirt in Denver. He's no Kyle Orton.

:clap:

Fair Enough...

Orton is 3x the QB Quinn is. And hes sitting on the bench behind Romo. Think about it.

Then Tebow came along and clown suited both of them.

the knock on quinn?

he sucks

That is something I never want to think about. My god that is like thinking, Hum, do I want anal raped with a rusty chain saw or a dull wore out belt sander...

Sucks like a boss

He's Cassel with a stronger arm and quicker release.

13and3, take a breath buddy.

Inaccurate as ****.

Makes Cassel's accuracy look like Trent Green.

Their inaccuracies have striking similarities...I think they are neck and neck in that category. Brady has a much better arm, poise and mobility though.

Everything else is pretty much the same, though.

This dude had trouble beating out Derek Anderson and Tebow. Tells me all I need to know.

I saw Brady make a couple throws Cassel would never make. Sad part is they were too far and few inbetween a lot of Cassel style passes

I think we know Tebow was a publicity move. I will cut Quinn a tiny bit of slack since the guy has only started 13 games in 3 years. But I have to take that back because he has only started 13 games in 3 years.

IF he is so ****ing awesome, why are we the only team willing to take him. Why are the 31 other teams avoiding the guy?

Not defending the guy, but who said they were?

I know Quinn said he turned down a bigger offer to stay in Denver...

Cassel can be accurate on short passes.

Quinn was throwing horrible slants last week. Just dogshit.

He sucks. Couldn't beat out Tebow. /thread

I think you missed the point of my last sentence.

Not a valid argument, Tebow had to be traded because even the almighty Peyton would have had some situations if Tebow had stayed. Thats why he was traded so fast. Denver was blinded by glourious light of tebow.

Couldnt beat out Cassel.

Satisfied?

I'm not so sure that's a valid argument either. Only 2 people could have beat out Cassel. One was Manning and the other was Jesus Christ. Neither wanted to come here.

Brady Quinn =Matt Cassel + a 16oz can of Red Bull seems to be something I could come to grips with.

So you trust that Pioli can pick out the best Qb on the roster?

No. See banner thread.

You trust that he can pick out a decent QB in any capacity?

I have nothing against Brady Quinn. He's the perfect QB for this team.

Under his guidance we will very likely lose all the games we need to lose to draft Geno.

How dare you recommend a QB that wears his hat backwards at times ROFL

He had Tom Brady on the roster and didn't know it.

LMAOLMAO...about as accurate too

Ohhhh Black Boooooooooob!!!!!

Exactly.

so we got an upgrade?

orton is the best qb has had fro 10 years?
jamal wept
bowe blows town
and chunt counts money

really?
I saw cassel hang receivers up to dry, or die for 4 weeks
the high throws could have killed or ruined any WR we have

Is it Bratt Cuinn or Mady Qassel?

brady isn't a 1st round pick, we want to loose so we can pick a first round pick dammit, get with the program....

Most people just love to hate. He's started one game for us and he's the worst QB since Cassel.

He was Cassel before he started one game in KC...

Jesus people do you ever look at stats, history, reports? Or do you just cock holster any player in Red and Gold?

Quinn is what he is, a well below average 1st round bust QB.. He is Akili Smith and Tim Couch rolled up into one.

I am not so quick to buy into the "bust" label. The dude hasn't started many games and the ones that he did start were with the Browns who had NO weapons to help out a rookie QB. He has a lot of potential that has not been properly developed. Hell McNabb had a strong arm and was inaccurate as shit but took his team pretty far under the right guidance of Andy Reid. It isn't always the QB's fault for his successes or failures. I for one hope that Quinn succeeds. He has a lot of weapons to include a legitimate running game. If he fails here it is going to be because he has the same POS head coach he had in Cleveland backed up by a POS OC that can't draft an offensive plan to suit his strengths.

Establish the running game and then run some play action passes to draw in the safeties and give this guy some passing lanes. If the OC can do that (I have my doubts) then I don't see how Quinn cannot be a successful QB in the NFL.

It just amazes me how most don't have an original thought in their head and just ****in regurgitate what they hear on the radio. Brady quinn is a bust, he can't do it. For **** sake he has only played in 13 games. How can you have these concrete conclusions so fast. Most likely none on this board has seen al 13 games and are just reading stats or being a damn paraet. What's the point of being a fan if all you see is despair?

What's the point of being a fan if all you see is failure?

Quinn is a guy who could have been THE guy but wanted to be a different guy and now he is just A guy.

You sure he didn't want to be a girl?

One thing I noticed from last game is that he panics at the very first hint of pressure.

I do think that that will get better with more reps and familiarity.

Yup.

If a QB doesn't have mid-range accuracy (15-25 yards) he's going to struggle against any quality defense. This is why I liked RGIII so much. His mid-range accuracy was awesome.