Originally Posted by Setsuna (Post 9194353)

Stupidest post I've ever seen.

Originally Posted by Dylan (Post 9194333)

RG3 might be a some what dynamic rookie- but the key to the Redskins offense is Albert Morris.

Originally Posted by Baby Lee (Post 9194361)

He was benched for a concussion dumb****. In case you've missed it, the league has been kind of touchy about those things these days. While recuperating CK came in and played QUITE well. Well enough that it's tough to pull him back to the bench regardless of Smith's play level.

CK is teetering between Good Enough and Elite the past few games. Won't know for sure where the spindle falls until the postseason.

Originally Posted by Baby Lee (Post 9194337)

IMO there are four levels of QB in the NFL [not counting Castle who secures his own personal circle of Hell].

Elite, Good Enough, Not Good Enough, and Chokers

Elite is Eli, Rothlisberger, Rodgers

Good Enough is Smith, the other Manning [may shock some, but he's had plenty of post-season woes], Rivers Cutler.

Not Good enough captures all the nondescript journeymen, Foles, Sanchez, Palmer

The prototypical Choker is Romo, is the other Manning hadn't gotten his SB victory against Chicago a case could be made for him as well.

There aren't enough elites to go around, so you make do with Good Enough and both work like heck to edge towards elite and vigilantly continue to suss out an Elite.

You think only Elites can get to a SB, I differ insofar as I see enough Good Enoughs out there than can get there as well.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 9194320)

Nope.

Originally Posted by Setsuna (Post 9194353)

Stupidest post I've ever seen.

Originally Posted by Baby Lee (Post 9194388)

So, . . . you post blindfolded?

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks (Post 9194362)

Agree.

The hate for Peyton on this board is insane. The dude is probably the best QB ever. It's hilarious.

Good enough.

hahahaha

Originally Posted by Chiefs Pantalones (Post 9194373)

Good points all, consider me completely refuted.

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks (Post 9194380)

I think of Alex Smith as a Rich Gannon type of QB. I don't think he's elite but I definitely think he's worthy of being an NFL starter for 10 teams, or so.

Originally Posted by Dylan (Post 9194333)

RG3 might be a some what dynamic rookie- but the key to the Redskins offense is Albert Morris.

Originally Posted by Baby Lee (Post 9194401)

First, I don't hate Manning.

But you can't have it both ways, either Elites prove their mettle in the playoffs or they don't. If they do, Peyton has more than adequate postseason disappointment and non-production to knock him out of that category. Before his SB win with his best defense of all of his playoff runs, the name Peyton Schottenheimer was thrown around regularly.