QBR is complete and utter crap
 

Look at the stat line. How in hell can Andy Dalton beat any of these 3 guys in rating? He is smoked in passer rating but dominates QBR. It looks like the completion % is way too heavily weighted. That is all I can figure. I don't give a damn if he completed 80% to Peyton's 65%, there is no way in hell a guy with 7 TDs and 0 INTs should be trumped by a guy with 2 TDs and 2 INTs, especially with 180 less yards.

I realize QBR is complicated and that a game losing INT is weighted far differently than an INT in the first minute of a 50 point blowout. I realize a TD in garbage time is not rated the same a game-winning walk-off TD. That is the good news.

But this is just WRONG.

QBR is just pure and utter crap if it can't handle this kind of immense disparity. There is no way in any sane world that 2 TD/2 INT/282 yards beats out 7 TD/0 INT/462 yards. It just isn't possible.


QBR
91.8 - Dalton
89.8 - Kaepernick
83.6 - Peyton
70.0 - Rodgers


Passer Rating
141.1 - Peyton
129.4 - Kaepernick
102.6 - Rodgers
97.2 - Dalton


Stat Line
Peyton - 27/42 for 462 yards, 64%, 7 TDs, 0 INT, 3 sacks
Kaeper - 27/39 for 412 yards, 69%, 3 TDs, 0 INT, 2 sacks
Rodgrs - 21/37 for 333 yards, 57%, 3 TDs, 1 INT, 2 sacks
Dalton - 26/33 for 282 yards, 79%, 2 TDs, 2 INT, 1 sacks

Yep, it's stupid.

The PFF QB rating is a lot better.

Nobody cares about the 49ers.

Go **** Colin Kaepernick in the ass and kill him with your AIDS. Then gargle some antifreeze

Manning only got a QBR of 83.6? WTF?

Jealous are weROFL

I'm definitely jealous...of whatever chiefs message boards there are that haven't been swimming in 49er trolls for the last 6 months.

No we don't give a **** about the 49's.
Smith fans coming here is one thing but the Kap
lovers who follow them around are worse if that's possible.

The 49er asshole problem has gotten out of hand. Not even Chiefs Planet's abusive nature can chase them away. There's too many of them.

The mods need to have a goddamn Holocaust for 49er fans. Don't care if they're polite and good-natured. There's just too goddamned many of them posting 49er garbage nonstop.

Yeah, pretty ridiculous.

That's an ugly word. And I realize I'm just a visitor.

Time for us to give them their own site...49ersPlanet.com? :)

YES YES YES

Do it noa plox. thx.

7 tds is nothing.

It took you this long to determine that? Anything that weighs "clutch factor" is absolute bullshit.