You're high if you don't think Stafford is any good.

8 yrs is a long time in this league. It's a career.

McNabb has become such a hater...

I'm simply talking about this year who's the better QB. Not which QB I'd start a team with.

Stafford has immense physical tools and has had some real hot flashes, in this QB-centric era thats enough for most teams to rest their hopes on.

Cry into your piles of cash McNabb, that contract is just a sign of the times... i'd take Stafford with Reid in a ****ing heartbeat, jimping all over the living room.

He's alright. He's had two pretty good years but makes alot of mistakes and has Calvin F'n Johnson to throw to. Honestly, I've never been as impressed by Stafford as others. Always seemed like a choker to me.

But I don't love Romo either. But I won't take a lesser player over a better player just because they are younger. The promise of youth, does not a better player make.

All I know is a couple years ago when the Lions played the Saints in the playoffs they gave the Saints all they could handle.

Stafford's better than his team. He plays for the freaking LIONS.

He does seem to be injured a lot though.


<iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/vPVyavQn5mY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

McNabb shut the **** up you dumbass

It's too late to worry about becoming Daunte Culpepper, Donvan. Wipe the steam from your own puke off the mirror. Nobody cares.

Yeah because you're soooo much better Donovan.

Between the rookie and this contract he has now gotten around $84MM in guaranteed $$ and is 5 games over .500.

Yea McNabb has a point.

Not really.

What should the Lions do? Cut him loose and trade for Alex ****ing Smith?

I was lurking and saw people calling out members for being skeptical over the extension and calling Stafford a bit overrated because we have Alex Smith and we have no room to "judge." What? A QB can be overrated even if the Chiefs have a shitty QB. I didn't get that thread.

You as always are missing the point.

Just because Detroit doesn't have another option doesn't mean Stafford has EARNED a big contract.

That's not the same thing its called being in the right place at the right time.

Use your brain.

You are smarter than 98% of CP.

What should the Lions do, then? You know, since Stafford hasn't earned this big contract.

What is their other option?