He's significantly better as a prospect than Gabbert, and it's not close.

But when you enter the Matt Ryan territory there's too much gray area to say beyond a shadow of a doubt he's better.

IMO, if you do that you're entering the homer territory Dane is harping on about.

Matt Ryan and Geno Smith are entirely different QBs with different backgrounds and different strengths.

Matt Ryan had all the squeaky clean white boy QB shit going for him that draft guys love. He just threw a ton of picks in college. A LOT.

Geno Smith had 6 INTs the whole year and like what, only two fumbles? Three?

In terms of a guy with the arm who can also take care of the ball, Geno Smith is a far better prospect coming out of college than Matt Ryan.

Except that I've been 100% consistent about my feelings on Matt Ryan since his college days.

My feelings on this subject have FAR more to do with how I rate Ryan, NOT how I rate Geno.

There's nothing "homer" about it.

Actually Cutler ceiling is what Geno seems to have. Nobody questions his passing talent, but we don't know shit about his head. He does strike me as possessing a Cutler type of head. Until that's shown to be wrong, I'll worry about picking him at the top of the draft.

Like many of us are saying, let the combine unfold before you tear each other up about Geno Smith.

i believe we know plenty about his head. The man is wicked-gifted and a firece competitor.
Posted via Mobile Device

TOTALLY. If Ryan can't get to the Super Bowl with THOSE weapons one has to question how good he really is.

There's so much evidence for this. ROFL

This is why I bang on Frankie.

He posts stupid shit that serve as clear evidence that has actually never watched Geno.

Other than him not playing in a pro style offense he's got it all.

Above average arm, above average mobility, has a solid deep ball, and his completion percentage is reeruned good.

He was born to play the WCO/Phat Andy offense...

I think placing Geno betwen Gabbert and Ryan is probably accurate.
Here is the top 5 winning QB's since 2008.
Joe Flacco 41 wins - 19 losses
Matt Ryan 40 wins - 18 losses
Aaron Rogers 39 wins - 20 losses
Tony Romo 27 wins - 20 losses
Eli Manning 26 wins - 24 losses

Now adjust for playoff wins...

Geno played in a pro set as a sophmore, and had a ggod season.

I can't wait for Geno to go on Jon Gruden's QB camp show.

"I question his head" ROFL

Why the **** would you question his head? Just because he went to West Virginia?

I think Pete is legitimately dumb, but Frankie may be a master troll.

Well...it's a legitimate argument...