Who needs defense when you're scoring 40+ per game?

Denver.

They puke pts...

Poe. He creates opportunities for the entire defense. Domino effect. At least three of Houston's sacks are because of Poe.

Alex Smith close second.

Andy Reid's chef.

/thread

It's all relative.

Smith - he's not great, but the Chiefs would ultimately be no good with Daniel or Geno Smith or whoever else they could've had. In the most literal sense, he's the most valuable player on the team. 1-3 without him, I'd say.

Charles - he's the best player on the offense and the only guy who can consistently be relied upon to get yards. Without him they would very likely be 1-3. I don't know that they'd beat the Giants with Knile Davis replacing what Charles did today. And they damn sure wouldn't have beat the Iggles.

Poe - he's taken a huge step but no, he's not the MVP at all. Simply no argument for him so not worth discussing.

Hali or Houston? - no. They compliment each other and if either hadn't played a snap, they'd be at least 2-2.

Sutton - I can see an argument. I don't really wanna make it. But it could be. The question is how good they would be anyway with Reid, Dorsey, new QB and plenty of FA help.

Reid? Again, you can make an argument, I think.

Albert? I don't think he's quite good enough to say MVP, but from the perspective of who replaces him (hard to say Fisher would suck at LT since it's his natural position, but...)? I dunno, man. It could be real ugly. It certainly was when he went down, albeit an unfair sample size.

Smith's the literal answer, Charles is probably the right answer. The offense is Charles, the defense isn't reliant on one guy.

there was no score from either team the first qtr, Colquitt layed out the best game I've ever seen him play. He was money.

It was our special team gunners

There are 15 guys in the league that could do the same thing that Alex Smith does.

You can't find 15 Dontori Poes or Justin Houstons. Those guys are disruptive talents that could not easily be replaced.

Clark Hunt!

He hasn't been made quite the impact Houston has. But Berry has quietly been unstoppable so far

Houston didn't flash on the fantasy boards today either but that's because he was in coverage a TON.

That happens when you're an overall ****ing face-raping stud...

Did the Giants have a TE in the game today?

Should be Defense unit 50/ Smith 50

defense

Probably true, but the defensive tackle is never voted MVP. Its either the sack specialist end/LB or the back with the interceptions. People aren't smart enough to judge something they can't put a number to. Looking at him last year, Poe looked like he would be another in a long line of busts we had at tackle. He has a shot at the Pro Bowl this year.