Actually you voted for your mom, pervert.

This isn't even a debate anymore.

Take Peyton if you want to win a fantasy football league

Take Eli if you want a clutch QB in the playoffs.

If you voted for Peyton you're either stupid or just trolling.

It's not like we're saying Indy was blown out every year in the playoffs. They were in a lot of tightly contested games where Peyton just did not make enough plays at the end where it mattered most. In many cases, he threw picks at the wrong time.

I know people talk about the David Tyree unbelievable catch against New England. I am still in awe at the pass Eli threw to Mario Manningham. It's passes like these that I just don't see enough of from Peyton in late game playoff situations.

Does anyone think Manning was hurt? He didn't seem to have much on the ball, and they didn't go deep at all. Running out the clock with 30 seconds left, and no sense of urgency in OT.

Eli is more clutch, but today's game was lost by the Donkeys secondary. They were pretty awful. Manning played a factor of course, but when your defense has a 7 point lead with a minute left, the other team 70 yards away with no timeouts you have to hold on.

I'd still take the choker in a playoff game. Sorry. He's never had a defense like those Giants. I'd take Matt Ryan and Tony Romo over Mark Sanchez too

Peyton = Best Regular Season QB of all time

Eli = One of the best playoff QBs of all times



They are almost polar opposites. Peyton is mediocre playoff QB. Eli is a mediocre regular season QB. Weird......

Definitely. Peyton controls a lot of the playcalling, so it's telling that he checked into a bunch of screens and run in OT. Think he knew his arm was shot, and we saw it on several passes.

That being said... his last pass was picked because of what looked like a terrible decision.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

For sure, Eli: :D

http://i758.photobucket.com/albums/x...yInc/eli-2.jpg

i stole this ^

hope they don't hunt me down

Who are the 2 idiots that voted for Peyton?

Eli has proven he's the better of the 2 QB's. You get Eli into the playoffs and he turns that shit up another level. Peyton turns it down.