Quote:
I don't. 10 years in the league and not a single 4000 yard season - only 2 seasons over 3500. 1.5 TD's per INT. Only two seasons of a QB rating over 90% He's solid, but not Top 5 worthy. JMO. |
Quote:
i disagree... super bowl appearance, solid, pro bowls... that is a top 5 pick. You can't expect a Hall of Famer with a top 5 pick, you expect an impact player. Hasselbeck is an impact player, if not flashy. JMO |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Carson Palmer ALREADY has more: 3500+ yard seasons (3, including two 4000+) Seasons of 90%+ QB rating (2) 25+ TD seasons (3) Than Hasselbeck, all in 4 years to Hasselbeck's TEN. THAT is a Top 5 QB. Not above average. |
Quote:
|
Matt Ryan is Brodie Croyle with a bigger frame. Those two are identical in about everything, its just the freaking year they are drafted that makes the difference.
|
i feel the same about QB and DT..we need top talent, not more mid-round maybes...
if we want a QB then draft Ryan, if we want a DT than draft Ellis/Dorsey.... otherwise don't waste a pick on the positions....(unless it's a 5th or lower...) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I would go Ryan if Long, Long, Dorsey and Ellis are gone in the first round.
If we were going for a back up or project. In the middle I would consider Dennis Dixon and late I would consider Josh Johnson. |
Quote:
Also Ryan and Croyle are not remotely the same as prospects, for starters I think Matt Ryan can be breathed on and not get injured. |
Quote:
|
Hasselbeck was in and, without the refs idiocy, would have a super bowl ring. Look, I agree we should have high expectations but lets be realistic... If we drafted Matt Ryan and he had Matt Hasselbeckesque career, how could you be disappointed? BUt lets put away the time machine for now...
|
one other thing... Carson Palmer was the #1 pick... I think you're projecting number one overall expectations on every player in the top 5.
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:36 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.