Best active NFL player without a ring?
 

I caught about 10 seconds of some sports talk show yesterday, and they were asking if Donovan McNabb is the best current player to not win a ring. I don't think he's even close, but I liked the question.

I'd go with Tomlinson. Tony G. came to mind, but I don't think he's top 10. Who's on the list?

Not Gonzales? Stupid. If you think Tomlinson deserves and not TG, then you may be reeruned.

I care a hell of lot more for Brian Waters to get a ring than Tony Gonzo.

Fitz of the cards
he should come to KC to get his ring

Players with the best career, or player who is best NOW?

If we're talking -now- then I think Fitzgerald is a nice starting point.

Randy Moss, Brian Urlacher

best career

LT, Tony G, Fitz, Moss, TO, McNabb, Aaron "Jesus" Curry, Hasselbeck.

Not based on their current talent.
Posted via Mobile Device

Patrick Willis or Frank Gore







seriously not being a homer...

Tyson Jackson





Actually, I would go with Jamal Charles somewhere in the top 10

I'd probably put Moss at #2.

Aaron Curry :spock:

I agree with you about Willis, disagree about Gore.

If there's someone who deserves one for the effort he puts in week after week, it's Steven Jackson.

Would also like to Gonzalez, Fitzgerald, T.O, Andre Johnson, McNabb, Charles and L.T to that list.

Tony G tops my list, the best TE EVER not a top 10 in your book OP? really?

LT
McNabb
Randy Moss
Jason Taylor
Champ Bailey (even though I hate him)
Urlacher
Ed Reed
Julius Peppers
Brian Dawkins
Rivers
Antonio Gates

all-time
Barry Sanders
Dan Marino
Dick Butkus

Brandon Gibson.