Changing of the guard
 

New Hot:
Joe Flacco
Colin Kaepernick
Robert Griffin III
Andrew Luck
Russel Wilson
Cam Newton
Geno Smith
Matt Ryan

Still Hot:
Aaron Rogers
Ben Roethlisberger
Eli Manning

Limbo:
Matt Schaub
Tony Romo
Matt Stafford
Jay Cuttler

Fading:
Tom Brady (36 next year with a weak supporting cast)
Drew Brees
Peyton Manning

Not:
Phillip Rivers

**** this.

Geno Smith on the new hot group already?

I would add an "Emerging" category, and place Luck, Wilson, Newton, Ryan and Griffin III in that category.

Smith probably shouldn't be in the picture at this time either.

9th circle of hell
Matt Cassel

He's a juggernaut.

The Geno Smith ballwashing on this board is getting ****ing ridiculous.

Did no one see him shrivel up in every meaningful game he played in. . . only to be followed up by his childish tirades on the sideline. I do think we should find a quarterback at 1, but calling Geno smith as "emerging" is simply laughable.

Josh Freeman, Jay Cutler and Andy Dalton need to go in here somewhere.

Cutler is in limbo. Freeman, Dalton and Newton should all go in the same category.

I must have missed it.

Where is Stanzi on this list?

You are so quick to forget his performances from the rest of the year, and last year. The guy shredded the top defenses in college football last year. His team ****ing blew donkey balls this year.

That's funny. I don't remember "shriveling" up in the Orange Bowl against Clemson, which is the biggest game of his career to this point.

I'll take any of those guys on my team right now above Manning, Brady, and Brees. A couple may not make it in the long run, but its all about the future and those guys have a really good shot. They're hot.

Which QB do you take then?

Where's Brady Quinn?

I agree with Cutler in the limbo category.

Newton has clear talent, he just has a shitty surrounding cast.

Dalton and Freeman are still footnotes.