Romo/Rivers/Cutler..career losers or franchise QBs?
 

Whats your take on these guys? Would these guys be 5-0 on the Chiefs.....or do they make too many mistakes and turnovers in critical situations? Sure, they put up great "box scores" , but so did Jeff George......

Romoception!

I said years ago that Romo will never go to a SB as a starting QB. Haven't been proven wrong yet.

Those two terms aren't mutually exclusive...

No, no way we're 5-0 with any of them, they just LOVE making huge errors at critical times.

Smiff may not play "pretty" but he doesn't destroy morale with ill-timed mistakes nearly as often either.

Define "franchise QB".

losers when it counts

They're good fantasy QBs at best.

I'm not sure Romo belongs with those other two but I get your point.

Good QBs, but not ELITE QBs.

We're 5-0 with Rivers

Romo has kept a mediocre Dallas team relevant for a while. I'd absolutely love to have him here in KC

The problem with these guys is they play just good enough....to break your heart....but never lose their jobs. tough situation to be in if your a GM or fan. Heck, for all we know, Alex Smith might be the same type of QB.
Posted via Mobile Device

not sure if serious

With Romo we have at least two losses this year.

They're all good enough to beat any team, but they're all big enough chokers that you can't rely on them to carry you all the way to the title. They're like Peyton that way, only they don't get the referee help that he did in '06.

They're almost opposites of Eli that way. He's not particularly good, but he's capable of getting hot and making it through the playoffs.