Offseason silliness - rate Katharine McPhee
 

OK so the ratings go from 1 to 10

A 10 in my opinion being someone like
http://www.moono.com/celebz6524lol89...0_7361_big.jpg
Daniela Pestova

A 9 would be like (OK I knew she would be controversial so for the benefit of those who hate Angelina) I now give you another one of my 9s

http://www.moono.com/celebz6524lol89...1_4349_big.jpg
Jennifer Garner

A 5 would be like Debra Messing of Grace Adler fame on Will and Grace

A 1 would be like Janet Reno (OK she is probably a 0 but my scale only goes down to 1, so kill me)

Please provide a comment as to why you rated her the way you did and the number you give here

Drum roll - now here is Katharine McPhee
http://image.com.com/tv/images/proce...d/cd/33297.jpg


Again
10 smoking hot
9 hot
8 gorgeous but not quite hot
7 My motor is definitely in gear and racing
6 I would do her she has potential
5 Meh I would do her but not that thrilling
4 I could be convinced after enough beer
3 Ok I was shitfaced what can I say
2 I started knawing my arm off when I woke up
1 Kill me now I have lost my mind

I haven't seen her much other than a few pictures. I would say somewhere between a 5 and a 6. Would probably be a 7 after a decent amount of beers.

4 or 5.

8. I like women with curves. Not fat, or overweight as you claim she is Logical (she isn't), but normal curves.

And maybe you should show a good picture of Katherine, like in the yellow dress, just to be fair.

If you don't want her I'll take her..... :)

I think she's plain. And the fact that she's a singer lowers her another notch or three in my book.

The fact that she is a singer makes her better in my book, but then I'm a musician. I've worked with some fine looking female singers over the years.

I'll "work" with Katherine any time she wants.

I was fair I did not pick one of the outfits where she is wearing the maternity clothes like she did 90% of the time nor was I going to give her best shot either. A hot woman is hot no matter what she is wearing.

I give her a 6 because she has potential.

Yet for the other girls you put up professional modelling shots. That's fair... :rolleyes:

I got that off the Idol website evidently they consider it one her better shots. By the way I challenge you to find a bad picture of Daniela Postova or Angelina Jolie either would look great in a gunny sack.

The fact that I was once a musician is exactly what brings her down a notch in my book. I didn't meet many singers who weren't self-absorbed.

I've worked with 7 chick singers over the years and only one was self-absorbed. In fact, with the exception of that one, they were all much easier to work with than most of the male singers I've worked with.

And all but one of them was hot. :)

Splatbass, would Daniela and Angelie in your opinion look outstanding in that dress that Katharine is wearing?

Sure, but Kat does too.

Are you talking about the male singers? :hmmm:

:)

Why, do you want their phone numbers? :hmmm: