I didn't.

Just pointed out that the 49ers sucked that year and Alex sucked in his 7 games.

He's not a guy who can "elevate" his teammates.

We had shit QBs and the most horrifically reeruned offensive staff in football history last year.

I plan on seeing vast improvement from McCluster and other players like him.

All of these absolutes. I prefer to wait and see them play the games.

BS.

He played 7 games total. He was hurt in the 4th game and did not ot play after the 1st qtr. He played 3 more games hurt before deciding that he was a liability with the injury. He did not produce 8-8 as you imply. He was 2-1 healthy. He didnt play much the 4th game. Played 3 more games injured because Nolan pushed.

What part do you want to deny?

He played in 10 games and had a 5-5 record on an 8-8 team.

Stats here. 2009 season. Did you get confused?

http://www.pro-football-reference.co...s/sfo/2009.htm

I'm pretty sure he was shitty as **** while the 4th ranked defense cursed his name ever night.

2007. You are trying to change dates. Damn, you are good.

he didn't play bad in 2009. That was the best hes ever played actually.

Mav would you quote the first post of page 26 for me. I can't quote links.

here it is.

Played well enough to get a team with a #4 defense to 8-8.

Holy ****ing shit.

There's your ceiling, folks!

LMAO Arguing with someone who can't argue back...

that's not true. Marty wanted to keep Brees. His GM wanted to move on with the younger Rivers. You know, the same idiot GM that fired marty after he went 14-2 and replaced him with the venerable Norv Turner. Brees was a legit non-game manager qb and he was still young at the time. CANNOT be compared to Alex "My best work in 7 years is as an efficient game manager" smith

To be fair, firing Marty wasn't idiotic. He was choking away playoff games every year as usual (including the most idiotic challenge of all time during his last playoff game with the Chargers), he was insubordinate (the same reason he was fired in Washington), and he was trying to hook his family members up with jobs regardless of qualification. The time had come for a new coach.

Replacing Marty with Norv Turner was so dumb, it helped cripple the franchise for a very long time and cost AJ his job (AJ's shit drafts and cheapness played a role in that too).

And getting rid of Brees wasn't THAT idiotic. At the time, it was extremely questionable whether he'd ever play again because of his shoulder injury (brought on by, surprise surprise, Marty being stubborn). And Rivers ended up being an elite quarterback until the past couple years.

Tony Romo, much like Brett Favre was, is a dumbass with big time playmaking ability.

Mike Holmgren was able to reel Favre in early on, and won a SB, but his dumbassery through the following years cost the Packers further opportunities.

Romo's playmaking keeps the Cowboys competitive, but his dumbassery costs them equally.

I'd be no more happy to have traded for him than I am with Alex Smith.

The only real question, how do you want to lose your playoff games?

LOL...