Would you pull the trigger on this?
 

I get Cam Newton, Cedric Benson and Mike Wallace.

I give up Chad Henne, DeAngelo Williams, Lance Moore and M. Massaquoi.

That would give me this team.

Big Ben, Newton and Cutler
F. Jones, B. Jacobs, C. Benson, M. Barber
V. Jackson, B. Marshall, M. Wallace, D. Moore, J. Ford
V. Davis, L. Kendricks

I start QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR/TE

Ehhh....I pulled it. I'll pick up Leron McClain off of waivers and hope he goes back to 2008 form.

yep

Hell yeah..

Umm. Yeah.

Newton > Henne
Benson (even with 3 game suspension) > Williams
Wallace > Moore + Massaquoi

Not even close to a fair trade.

Benson is getting a 3 game suspension by the sounds of it. But yes, i would have pulled the trigger on that.

I did.

Now I just need to find a 4th RB.

That's all good for you.....why the hell did the other guy want to trade?

I just traded Tony G and Tolbert for J. Finley and A. Bradshaw.

Thoughts? I think the upside on Finley is greater than what TG has been doing

The only reasoning behind the trade that I can determine is this.

Newton hasn't really proven shit. Teams are going to start gameplanning against him. That in turn is going to cause the Panthers to run the ball more....causing Williams to go up. Henne is going to be throwing a lot this year and he looks decent.

Moore averaged 10 ppg last year and he's finally healthy. Benson is out 3 games and there is no guarantee that he's going to be the main fantasy back when he gets back.

He wanted Massaquoi because he has Colt McCoy.

Yeah, none of those are good reasons.

Would it be more balanced if I pulled out Cam Newton?

So you just made an offer. Probably, since he'd be reeruned to accept that trade.

He offered it the trade in the OP.

So why would you take out Cam?