5000 Completions!!
 

Is Brett Favre the Best ever??

Fred Smoot thinks so!

No.

No.

not even close.
Montana, Unitas,Elway,Graham,Starr,Bradshaw,Staubach were more consistant IMO. Favre, while a great QB, was too reckless at times and outside of 1996, always ended the season with a rotten game.
I'd put him in the next tier with Aikman, Brady, and above the gag-club,
Manning, Marino, Fouts, and Moon.

Even a blind pig can throw an acorn 8 million 400 thousand times.

FAX

Over 57,000 yards

256 Consecutive games

5000 Completions

413 TD's

3 Reg Season MVP's 1 SB MVP

He gets my vote.

Favre is the man. Top 5 of all time.

Another win tonight. Should put him as the winningest QB in history??

Perhaps, but without fingers, I would think they would have difficulty grasping the acorns in the first place.

He's no jay cutler...thats for sure.

If Brett was a Chief his whole career-we would have a few SB's to talk about.

what?

Brett Favre is going to have to get in line behind Montana, Unitas, and Elway for the GOAT designation. I wouldn't even put Brett in the top 5. Certainly, he belongs in the HOF. But he's definitely not deserving of being in the GOAT discussion.

Elgay in the top 5 are you high. Brett blows his stats away. Montana never had the heart our arm of Favre-he played on a great team.

Marino has to be number 2.

No. Simply because you are Halfcan, not a whole can. The TalkingCan is more impressive than both a half can and a whole can, so that's that.